Search results

Oof guys look at this art piece, it's gorgeous! Only a link because it cannot be embbed :)

I thought au contraire that the song title was very evocative of how CA wasn’t meant to be; I also didn’t think it would be good if it was going to be about Zack either. In FF, promises are often strong romantic tropes, so saying there was no promise to keep was basically saying there was...

While I agree with all of this (and the parallel you made there is quite nice), I think 99% of players will NOT analyse this scene at all and take it as they see it. It's all well to make scenes that need analysing but most people simply won't make the effort because they take everything at face...

There is no CT star imagery in Rebirth, and even the shooting star was missing in Remake's flashback of the promise. I know it is done on purpose for p3 and probably the Lifestream scene. But someone with no knowledge of the OG will associate stars with CA and not CT now.

It honestly felt that they knew a lot of little CT motifs were really nice so instead of getting new ones for CA, they just used the CT ones which pisses me off as it comes really bad and unimaginative.

I'll agree partly, but it does dilute the water tower motif to being exclusively CT. Yeah that's the thing. It's a date spot. It was only Cloud and Tifa's. Cloud and Aerith had dates all over Rebirth, couldn't they let that one out?

Basically, things we can't claim 100% as CT as we did before: stars motif, water tower motif and even Tifa calling Cloud cute like a little chocobo (and have him subsquently styling his hair every time we'd stop by the Costa del Sol house). I know people are like "but it got way better for CT!"...

In the OG I found it cute that Cloud heard her and saved her; the fact that they hear each other and save each other is a theme I hold dear but honestly they've already stripped out nearly all the themes CT has so I guess this is possible. I wouldn't like it personally, but given how Tifa was...

It is not part of the canon Compilation, and Benny has said already it was only his view of the thing. Maiden has been contradicted by the Compilation, many times. The fact that people keep referencing it is stupid. CAs are all over it when it proves CT and Aerith is jealous of Tifa lol, is...

I would really want to see some memories from ToTP, but from Cloud's POV this time, to answer Tifa's memories; the bridge, but not only! When he asked her to come at the water tower, when he refused to answer her calls, why he stopped coming in her house. My theory is that since Tifa already...

Nomura said she hates the sky because it took away her mother Ifalna and Zack.

While I agree generally with this, ACC came after CC IIRC. AC didn't really set up Zack as much as ACC paid hommage to him and his relationship with Cloud and Aerith. I always felt that it was CC that allowed ACC to exist as it does, because they needed people to know who Zack was before pushing...

Yeah the problem is when it got big; Nomura became involved and wanted nothing but visuals so AC ended up as the mess it was. The short story would’ve been much better.

Really? I never heard that. Rather they were creating a small project for fun (CT with the kids bringing them a message from Aerith) and it grew bigger and bigger so they ended up making a movie. I think for them it was training at first and exploring how to create a movie, learning a lot at...

Here is the video BTW, but it's so long that I have put it off for now xD

I am sure that true Aerith is also there when he hallucinates fake Aerith; but he can't see her anymore (he fought Sephiroth in the Lifestream with her, that guy from the video earlier was wrong, it wasn't a reflection of the lake it was the Lifestream as told by the Ultimania for Remake and...

I think "our" Aerith is only the one who says goodbye to Yuffie and Red+Tifa (and I think Cloud doesn't necessarily pay attention to her then so he isn't seeing her; in the illusions where he creates her, he is always in sight of her and paying attention to her. So when she's near the Tiny...

I personally never took it as "oh she knows everything". In the OG, Sephiroth mentions that he scoured the Lifestream to find every bit of knowledge, but I don't think that's how Aerith does it; if we look at how she acts at the Temple, she lets the Cetra knowledge guide her. So I think it's...

And yet Cloud says it they are nakamas, so they are friends. No matter how you turn it, the church scene is her realisation that they aren't on the same level or that her feelings aren't as strong as she thought they would be. The HA version is a nicer way to say it, IMHO, since if I look at the...

Yeah so basically interesting mhhhhhhhhh....... this is not Remake church in the dream date or in Zack's final scene, it's most likely CC church for both...... yeah I'm still back at "this must be Aerith's Promised Land", sorry. XD It works even better.