Search results

If Stamp has been changed because of defeating the Whispers then one would expect that Stamp is now different in thier own timeline, Stamp will have changed. Cloud and co have been running around in Midgar, they see Beagle Stamp everywhere. They defeat the Whispers in the Singularity where all...

This is easy... Destroying the Whispers caused Zack to live Destroying the Whispers caused Biggs to live Destroying the Whispers caused Stamp to change Something which caused Stamps design to a Beagle changed when the Whispers were destroyed, as a result Stamp is no longer a Beagle. This...

Not necesarilly, because the Whispers don't function like that. However, what you describe could potentially be indicative of a time loop. The Whispers do not exist to make sure change does not happen, or new and different things don't happen. They exist to prevent changes that affect the...

Right. How can you say this is the case? How can you know that we have created a split timeline? You don't know that, you assume that. It's possible that we have created a split timeline, but its also possible we have changed one timeline, its also possible that there were multiple timelines...

Okay, I don't think this is quite right and I think even if you're right about multiverse theory, that Zacks Last Stand was still a past event that has been changed. 1. We see Zack at the start of the Last Stand, the Whispers appear to ensure he meets his fate (past vision shown to Aerith) 2...

You presume they happened simultaneously, but that is not a given, nor is it the most likely or least likely. There are multiple possible scenarios and frankly they're all valid. Scenario 1: Its possible that we saw a vision of Zacks Last Stand happening in an alternate timeline that was taking...

It doesn't clarify that it was not a flashback of a changed past though. How does it clarify that it was not a vision of a changed past? I don't think there are doubles of characters. 1, 2 and 3 are possible. 4 is possible but unlikely because it would be a shit show

Yes, I agree, but as TwilightMexican pointed out, thats answering a stupid point because obviously they aren't physically in the same time and location in that moment. Yet, thats what they clarified and left all other options on the table.

... I know... but... thats literally what they're saying and yes, it sounds ridiculous. If I were to take a random punt, I would imagine they're grinning while they say it. As a reader its one of those answers that leaves you like "well, thank you for pointing out the bleeding obvious and...

Yeah, this is why I wanted the original Japanese to see for myself. Audreys translation is accurate (I have some comments though), I never doubted that, but you can read her translation in two ways. Also, when a translation gets "beautified" or the translator tries to make sense of something...

Okay, this might not be a satisfying opinion for anyone. My opinion on this is that it's trying to get us to speculate over whether the two scenes exist in different dimensions or whether they exist in different points in time without really giving anything either way. You can read it in two...

I find part 1 doesn't have the replayability because its so linear. I'm hoping part 2's world is more explorable kinda like OG was. That would help a lot. Yeah... I said that and now I'm in weekly, occasionally daily, arguments over theories... its pretty much all I discuss. So, best of luck.

Indeed it was, I loved the music. This games soundtrack is excellent.

I have to say, I'm impressed you got to where you are in 5 days... thats some marathoning, it took me a month or more to get through it.

No, he's a 'lab rat dog'. Tifa's a laugh :D TBH the girls are wrecking balls in Remake.

That was one of my favourite scenes, totally out of the blue. Totally agree about Neo Midgar, also kinda made me want to see more of what the Ancients world was like too.

Well that escalated quickly

Well, yeah. Thats always an option, I think multiple endings are more about the experience than anything else though. I have a response to those kinds of arguments, even if I don't say it. I find this stuff weird though, because if you do have multiple scenarios and each are canon, then if you...

Fair enough, if its an issue of "keeping it clean" I kinda get that. This on the other hand I don't. Usually when these arguments appear its typically people having a tantrum that a ship that competes with theirs is a thing, or their favourite character isn't as important in a particular...

If they were creating two timelines where we are switching between a Team A with one story and a Team B with another then I doubt it would be more work, likely less tbh. Also, I was replying to Roundhouse, while I like the idea of divergent storylines, something that gets very fanservicey isn't...