What the Remake Soundtrack should sound like
- Thread starter hian
- Start date
hian
Purist
Well, considering how music works in SE action/non-transitional RPGs like KH, FFXII, FF Type-0 and FFXV, I do think we're getting a regular battle theme (maybe several different arrangements that change depending on things like how hard the enemies are etc.) - they'll just cross-fade, rather than change in the abrupt manner of earlier FF games.
But I do think we're likely to lose out on the use of the standard victory theme, because having people stand around doing their victory poses etc. after each enemy is vanquished really messes with pacing. That will probably be limited to the aftermath of bosses, or when every single enemy in an area is defeated.
But I do think we're likely to lose out on the use of the standard victory theme, because having people stand around doing their victory poses etc. after each enemy is vanquished really messes with pacing. That will probably be limited to the aftermath of bosses, or when every single enemy in an area is defeated.
- AKA
- Ite
XII had dungeon music which accounted for both exploration and combat. The only battle-specific tracks were the boss themes. It was well done, but you'd have to pretty much gut VII's OST to make similar tracks (goodbye Lurking in the Darkness and Chasing the Black-Caped Man)
CC had the abrupt thing going on, I could get on that (without the obnoxious AI lady screaming at you) and I don't know KH or FFXV
CC had the abrupt thing going on, I could get on that (without the obnoxious AI lady screaming at you) and I don't know KH or FFXV
hian
Purist
You sure about that? Granted I was playing on the European version, I still have a pretty distinct memory of the music changing the moment you actually bumped into enemies.
Actually I just checked game-play footage from the Giza plains, and the track definitely changes upon combat, with the addition of more pronounced percussion, and the addition of brass.
https://youtu.be/JvjhEso-ke4?t=987
It follows the same melody to an extent, but it's obvious that the track changes dynamically to complement the combat.
It bumps up a couple of notches when you encounter an enemy, and goes back down when there are no longer any enemies in your close vicinity.
KH and FFVX both have combat themes that cross-fade.
KH :
https://youtu.be/DZZHaNtvgLM?list=PL6zNqSnoLmqgJSneE1umSF8WyoaPwLlYR&t=272
FFXV :
https://youtu.be/665NAiDV-hQ?t=821
hian
Purist
Maybe.
Point still stands though, as KH and FFXV still have distinct combat themes using cross-fade.
Seeing as both projects were directed by Nomura, and most likely have more in common with FFVII:R than FFXII by miles, I think it's more reasonable to assume the remake will follow that pattern.
Point still stands though, as KH and FFXV still have distinct combat themes using cross-fade.
Seeing as both projects were directed by Nomura, and most likely have more in common with FFVII:R than FFXII by miles, I think it's more reasonable to assume the remake will follow that pattern.
- AKA
- Ruby Rose, Lucy
omg Interrupted By Fireworks, all the feels and so many more with that song.
They did an excellent and interesting selection of songs. While Aerith and OWA would be obvious choices he went with Fireworks and Birth of a God which are sometimes underappreciated.
Also, gawds, Judgement Day is one of my favourite songs and I think this needs a bit more oomph, it was still chilling to listen to. <3
I dig it.
They did an excellent and interesting selection of songs. While Aerith and OWA would be obvious choices he went with Fireworks and Birth of a God which are sometimes underappreciated.
Also, gawds, Judgement Day is one of my favourite songs and I think this needs a bit more oomph, it was still chilling to listen to. <3
I dig it.
Here's an interesting question: What should be done about music used in more than one area? Do we want a different song used in the Train Graveyard instead of sharing it with Nibelheim? Should Wall Market and Rocket Town use the same music?
Should towns have their own distinct take on the music used originally (something like Crisis Core's mix of Anxious Heart)?
Should towns have their own distinct take on the music used originally (something like Crisis Core's mix of Anxious Heart)?
Random Nobody
local roach
I'm a little hesitant when it comes to the Orchestra vs Synthesizer debate. I feel like the electronic/techno elements of the original soundtrack really served as part of the personality of VII, and something important and irreplaceable would be lost if they went for a straight orchestral or even 'real' instrument track. A lot of people had similar problems with the X remaster track, which still had some synth, but did alienate a few people.
leadmyskeptic
Pro Adventurer
I have been thinking about that (orch/synth) at least since the release of AC, and yeah, there's no doubt that the synthesizer soundtrack was a huge part of 7's (and 8's, et al) personality, even if it was just a matter of the tech at the time. But, going down that same road, turn-based battles were also a huge part of it's feeling and persona...so despite the attachment, I won't be expecting to see a synthesizer soundtrack. I mean, has there been a (even moderately) recent game released with a 7-styled soundtrack??