New year, New LTD thread. (Round 5)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ryushikaze

Deus Admiral Parsimonious, PHD, DDS, MD, JD, OBE
AKA
Tim, Ryu
#1
So, new LTD thread. As always the question of the thread is which person Cloud chose, which pairing is canon.

The basic rules of evidence and debate apply.

The rules of off topic posts in this thread are that if it is off topic, it had better amuse me.

Now then, at each other's throats.
 

DrakeClawfang

The Wanderer of Time
#2
So we're discussing if Cloud loves Terra or Esper Terra right? I say Terra, he loves her but lusts for Esper Terra - I've written the sex fanfic to prove it ;p

</thread>
 
AKA
Sonique, Quexinos, Pinkie Pie, Derpy Hooves
#3
Wow, off topic in one post, that has to be a record :monster:

I found a monologue in Dismantled that I haven't fully translated yet where Cloud remembers the promise, the star and the beautiful night. Makes me rethink what I said about Cloud saying that "Wishing on a star" line in Dissidia wasn't about the Promise. ...

that's all I gots :awesome:
 

Tifabelle

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Tifabelle, Nathan Drake, Locke Cole, Kain Highwind, Yamcha, Arya Stark
#4
Cloud loves and has always loved Tifa.

You may close the thread now.


Wow, off topic in one post, that has to be a record :monster:
In 13 minutes no less.

I found a monologue in Dismantled that I haven't fully translated yet where Cloud remembers the promise, the star and the beautiful night. Makes me rethink what I said about Cloud saying that "Wishing on a star" line in Dissidia wasn't about the Promise. ...
You know, it's funny. I never considered that line in relation to Tifa. It wasn't until I really thought about it that I thought it could be possible. There was a shooting star on the night of the promise, but it's kind of a stretch to just assume. If you have the quote, can you post it? I forget what it was (if I ever knew to begin with).
 
AKA
Sonique, Quexinos, Pinkie Pie, Derpy Hooves
#5
I don't have the full thing done yet... and I haven't looked at it in a while XD aaannnd I'm tired...

But I've heard in the files for the game, The Promise Scene is labeled "Promise under a Star"

anyone know if that's true?
 

DrakeClawfang

The Wanderer of Time
#6
Wow, off topic in one post, that has to be a record :monster:
Excuse me?

Ryu said:
So, new LTD thread. As always the question of the thread is which person Cloud chose, which pairing is canon.
I don't recall two specific interest for Cloud being mentioned in the opening post. For all I know this is the ZackxCloudxSephiroth thread, or TidusxCloudxSquall, or LeftHandxCloudxRightHand. You people need to narrow these things down.
 
AKA
Sonique, Quexinos, Pinkie Pie, Derpy Hooves
#7
Well maybe not off topic but... silly nontheless... and the only thing I have from that monologue is:

Tifa said, "Cloud it's been a while." I also remember that star in the beautiful night, and speaking with her at the village water tower. I am Tifa's childhood friend and Cloud of Nibelheim.
 
#9
Ever notice how when you say C/T is canon to some clerith shippers they proclaim that you are "bashing the pairing" or "attacking them for liking C/A"?

Who knew that when SE made the Ultimania and stated that C/T reveal mutual feelings what they were actually saying was "C/A is dumb and you are dumb for liking it"?
 
AKA
Sonique, Quexinos, Pinkie Pie, Derpy Hooves
#10
Or they call you a shipper :monster:

I guess I can kind of understand the logic but if I say Romeo and Juliet were a couple does that mean I'm a huge Romeo and Juliet shipper?
 
Last edited:

Vorona

affirmative.
AKA
Aerina, Elle
#12
Cloud loves and has always loved Tifa.
Seriously.

I've been out of FF fandom for a while but i'm slightly surprised the LTD still appears to be going. Well, emphasis on the word slightly haha. Idk, I guess i'm just finding it hard to understand/amusing how the same old people are still continuing to argue for Clerith in the face of so much well, blatant obviousness? I can't believe that they still believe the stuff they're arguing, surely it's more of a "I've been arguing for 14 years, I will never concede defeat!" type thing right?...right!?

Ah what am I saying, I already know the answer :monster:
 
#15
It's not so much that there's anything left to debate as it is there are still people pretending like they can make a case for Cloud and Tifa not being canon.

But for the thread... Cloud loves Tifa, Aerith loves TsengZack, and Clerith is a cute fanon pairing.
 

Ryushikaze

Deus Admiral Parsimonious, PHD, DDS, MD, JD, OBE
AKA
Tim, Ryu
#16
Excuse me?



I don't recall two specific interest for Cloud being mentioned in the opening post. For all I know this is the ZackxCloudxSephiroth thread, or TidusxCloudxSquall, or LeftHandxCloudxRightHand. You people need to narrow these things down.
Drake is correct. I did decide to expand the thread this time. I mean, Cloud and Nanaki got Amano art alone together. That's enough to be canon, according to some.

Hey, don't you be hatin' on my pairing! CloudxEsperTerra is true love and deep down you know it! No one can resist those sexy purple curves.
Oh, just admit it, Drake. You don't ship Cloud/Esper Terra, you ship Drake/Esper Terra.

Ever notice how when you say C/T is canon to some clerith shippers they proclaim that you are "bashing the pairing" or "attacking them for liking C/A"?

Who knew that when SE made the Ultimania and stated that C/T reveal mutual feelings what they were actually saying was "C/A is dumb and you are dumb for liking it"?
Or they call you a shipper :monster:

I guess I can kind of understand the logic but if I say Romeo and Juliet were a couple does that mean I'm a huge Romeo and Juliet couple?
In response to both the quoted above, I have had people get very angry and react in much the same way when I argued that Romeo and Juliet was not intended to be read as approving of the two's pairing, but as an indictment of the stupid, rash acts of two children who simply did not think. It's about the destructive nature of the whole shebang.
And then I got accused of hating Shakespeare.

Mukki:

[/thread]
Now now, that's inadmissable. Mukki took advantage of Cloud in his sleep.

Seriously.

I've been out of FF fandom for a while but i'm slightly surprised the LTD still appears to be going. Well, emphasis on the word slightly haha. Idk, I guess i'm just finding it hard to understand/amusing how the same old people are still continuing to argue for Clerith in the face of so much well, blatant obviousness? I can't believe that they still believe the stuff they're arguing, surely it's more of a "I've been arguing for 14 years, I will never concede defeat!" type thing right?...right!?

Ah what am I saying, I already know the answer :monster:
Really, at this point, the whole shebang really is just a running joke.

Why do you have to start the new year with this shit? :(
Because it was funny. I figured the "The rules of off topic posts in this thread are that if it is off topic, it had better amuse me.

Now then, at each other's throats." would give away that I was not entirely serious with this.
 

DrakeClawfang

The Wanderer of Time
#17
Drake is correct. I did decide to expand the thread this time. I mean, Cloud and Nanaki got Amano art alone together. That's enough to be canon, according to some.



Oh, just admit it, Drake. You don't ship Cloud/Esper Terra, you ship Drake/Esper Terra.
Admit it? I'm looking for someone to do fanart of it.
 

Elisa Maza

NYC Detective
AKA
Darkslover, Lilith, Seras Victoria, Tea-chan, Groose
#22
IF Dissidia 012 was out, maaaaaaaaaayyyyyyybe there would be a need for a new thread, just for the sake to over-analyze the material it'll give (because it will give them. OH BOY, I'm sure!). Just maybe. Did I emphasize "maybe" enough? I've been reading the old LTD threads of this forum the past month (shut up!), and I can say, there is really nothing to discuss.

Which saddens me, because I had arguments, but I see that all of them are already expressed. :(

P.S. Hey, I became a full member?



EDIT: On the other hand, maybe I have the chance to ask this:

Case of Tifa said:
At night, they slept under a plate in Midgar where rumor had it that it could fall anytime.
I think we agree that Cloud wanted to begin a new life with Tifa by his side, there is the argument that he was determined and supportive, looking forward to this new life, but... the above part... doesn't sound suicidal to you? They sleep under a place they know it might collapse and smash them anytime? How does that indicate any desire to live in order to repent for past sins and whatnot??

Thoughts?
 
Last edited:

DrakeClawfang

The Wanderer of Time
#23
Random conversation on a chat channel on Terra and Cloud brought up a neat idea. Names blocked for privacy ;p

<Drake|FF2>I hope Terra's EX Mode in her new alt is a Blue Esper
<UserA>Why blue?
<Drake|FF2>Because blue is sexeh
<Drake|FF2>Also it would make sense with her outfit
<UserB>Or.... she turns into a CHOCOBO!
<UserC>smurfist
<Drake|FF2>No
<Drake|FF2>That's Cloud's new EX Mode
<UserC>so....terra turns into smurf porn?
<UserB>Chocobo smurf porn
<Drake|FF2>TerraxCloud = SmurfxChocobo?
<Drake|FF2>I'll watch
<UserC>XD
<Drake|FF2>Anyone here do fanart?
<Drake|FF2>We need a pic of that
<Drake|FF2>Smurf!TerraxChocobo!Cloud
So....any takers? :p
 
AKA
Noctis
#24
IF Dissidia 012 was out, maaaaaaaaaayyyyyyybe there would be a need for a new thread
Yeah because seriously... Tifa x Laguna... THERE'S SOMETHING THERE

In all 'seriousness' though, on that matter, I think it's funny that Tifa being in the game, saved by Cloud, and partnering with Cloud means absolutely nothing, but Dissidia still has a CxA ending even though there is no mention of Aerith in the game... EVER.
 

Tifabelle

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Tifabelle, Nathan Drake, Locke Cole, Kain Highwind, Yamcha, Arya Stark
#25
I think we agree that Cloud wanted to begin a new life with Tifa by his side, there is the argument that he was determined and supportive, looking forward to this new life, but... the above part... doesn't sound suicidal to you? They sleep under a place they know it might collapse and smash them anytime? How does that indicate any desire to live in order to repent for past sins and whatnot??

Thoughts?
Living in a bad neighborhood isn't suicidal. Cloud & Tifa's situation is somewhat comparable to that. There really is no where for them to go while they are rebuilding/building Edge.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom