[quote author=Ryushikaze link=topic=155.msg2758#msg2758 date=1229646884]
[quote author=Makoeyes987 link=topic=155.msg2752#msg2752 date=1229645459]
It's not going at each other's throats, it's a dicussion, and I think it's fun
There's no hard feelings or anything.[/quote]
Mayhaps I should employ a facetious tag...
But no, I just meant let's not get ahead of ourselves. We no almost nothing, so we can determine very little. We need more information from which to form an accurate conclusion.[/quote]
Oh I see, you're right. But I'm just honestly addicted to talking about dorky things like this. I'm sure it'll be clearer with more information of course. I just want to see how close to the mark I am XD
Yeah, the question is where along in that timeline is he? Somewhere closer to AC, to FF7, to DC? Similarly, we have an absolute lower limit for Cecil's PoE, but no clue as to where after that he is.
Honestly, I think we won't really get a definite conclusive point in time as to where they're from. It'll be just like how you described, where along the timeline are they closest to. I definitely agree that for Cecil its easier since his story and tell-tale signs are more obvious. I think its probably at the end of FFIV and before "The After" since Golbez hasn't changed his appearance yet, and doesn't harbor the overwhelming hatred he did while under Zemus's control.
Personally, I think if Cloud is feeling a depression, he's almost certainly Pre-AC Cloud.
It's really not depression though. It's more of a sense of frustration, since now that he's fighting...Sephiroth is once again standing before him. He's not truly depressed like he was in AC.
But yeah, we will see
OneWingedDemon said:
I think Square just put them in outfits that the public knows them best in. These guys don't think any deeper than they haev to, lazy mofos.
Honestly, I get a little irritated at that line of thinking because it flies in the face of all of the effort they *have* put into making this game consistent with each source material story and the storyline which tries very hard to keep everyone in character. They obviously put some form of intent and effort into this, and they've stated as much. There's no harm in actually looking beyond the surface of a story and connecting the dots regarding its plot. That's what most Final Fantasies are all about, after all.