Would anyone have thought that messed up? I don't know. Neither do you.
There are so many incidents of casual indifference that we certainly can make an educated guess.
Clement Rage said:
It's completely unremarkable that there are large numbers of refugees during a major war. Some people keep walking. Some do not. That's how people work, it's not culturally significant.
What people do when a woman is dying with her small child watching isn't significant?
How do we even try to proceed with discussing the topic from there? =|
Clem said:
The train guard may have helped lots of refugees for all we know, no one can save everyone.
I guess he just didn't feel like rounding his purchase up to the next dollar for a donation that particular day. lol
Clem said:
We don't get to see the broader cultural context of these things, because the main characters are busy with terrorist bombings and world saving.
We have way more to go off than just the original game (which offers us a lot to go on anyway).
Clem said:
Why is the random guard the benchmark, when Ruvie Tuesti taking Denzel in is not?
We're discussing a fictional world where an authorial intent presumably was in play. When enough behavior of any sort is shown for average people, one has to start to think a certain picture is being painted.
In cases where casual negative behavior shows up all the time while kindnesses like Ruvie's are highlighted as so meaningful ... well, a picture is worth a thousand words.
Clem said:
Why should the bad examples carry more weight with you than the good?
In real life, they would not. In the context of literary analysis, though, they carry a different weight (not necessarily "more"; just different).
Clem said:
Cloud reflexively tries to save people at every available opportunity.
The real Cloud does. Rather unironically, the composite Cloud who embodies what Cloud perceives to be a cool dude, though? That guy who shrugs his shoulders and says "It's not my problem" or "It'll cost you"?
Come on, bro, this world's paradigm is as subtle as a pile driver.
Clem said:
The WRO isn't solely a military organisation, and in the context of thousands of orphans post Meteorfall, employing them could be one of the possible answers to 'how do we keep these kids safe?'
Reeve, at the beginning of the interview:
"Now then, Denzel… I’m short on time, so allow me to get right down to business. I should warn you up front, our organisation has changed. Gone are the days when we welcomed just anyone into our ranks. If it’s volunteer work you’re after, contact your local leaders. The WRO is an army now."
Clem said:
Zack doesn't have the full story of what's happening, the more he learns, the more disillusioned he becomes.
A lot he does with any of it. =|
He always had enough to make a moral judgment. Even as his disillusionment grows (good for him, I guess), he doesn't take much in the way of moral action despite all he has learned.
It isn't until he takes care of Cloud that he actually becomes a hero.
Clem said:
Shinra controls the narrative. How do you know there's no movement about slum conditions? But they won't get to publicise themselves on Shinra TV, so they won't get a large scale following no matter how many people want to help. Shinra tried to use the 'benefit people' narrative, but Rufus believes it's not working, and open repression is necessary instead.
Rufus never said it wasn't working. He said it was too much unnecessary work doing it that way when open repression would also work.
Clem said:
Cid makes a big speech in Dirge about the inherent value of life ...
The guy who, for years on end, domestically abused a woman so devoted to him that she was willing to give her life to ensure his safety and give him his dream?
Now, look, I'm not saying he's a bad person when I point that out. I'm mostly taking the piss that you're using him as a point of reference even as I acknowledge that, yeah, as the world at large goes, Cid is one of its decent folk.
But let's let that sink in: a guy who domestically abused a gentle, demure, loving woman
for years is one of its decent folk. One of the people who inspired Annette Townshend to choose among her final words to her son, "There's something I've learned in my adventures. There is so much good in the world. I've traveled so far, despite my ignorance, thanks to all the good in other people."
You say, "If anything, FF7 world has a pretty high rate of people that will risk their lives to benefit strangers," and where I disagree with you here is in your choice of the word "high." If you had chosen "inspiring," I would agree. Because it's inspiring when such people show up in FFVII, and all the more so because it is not something anyone expects of anyone.
I mean, believing again that authorial intent is at work in these stories, I also then believe that "The Kids Are Alright" emphasizes for a reason an analysis of people as morally convoluted, as well as notions that kindness can be found in unexpected people or affection expressed in peculiar ways.
I'm not sure why we seem to be disagreeing so intently here. It's not like I'm being cynical or putting humanity down. If anything, insisting on assessing them as they are makes me take an optimistic view about them and makes me see their kindnesses as more special when they are presented.