Hypothetical scenario

Roger

He/him
AKA
Minato
Chances are that he'd still just off all of them, without that much of an effort, honestly. :S

Plus, if Sephiroth was convinced to join Genesis's rebellion, wouldn't it be logical that Sephiroth would be convinced to share his S-Cells? Hence, stopping Gen's degradation?

The Sephiroth from FFVII and AC is a LOT stronger then the one were talking about. And Safer Sephiroth was still brought down by AVALANCHE. None of these eight guys are sure win for AVALANCHES best fighters one-on-one. (Well Azul vs Cloud maybe) Also we have little reason to believe S-cells are gonna do much. First Hollander refused to use Sephiroth's blood, thinking only Angeals would work, then they go after Jenova after that doesn't work then they go after Zack after that doesn't work then they go after Cloud after that doesn't work.
 

Wolfmania

Saint of Killers
The Sephiroth from FFVII and AC is a LOT stronger then the one were talking about.

Yeah, I'm totally aware, but not only is Sephiroth stated to already be the strongest in the entire planet at that point in time, but after Genesis was taken to Deepground, he just casually strolled out of the place, without his sword -- and I'd doubt Weiss or the Restrictors would allow him to do that, for distinct reasons.
Maybe it's just my hatred for Dirge's crappy stuff, but I'm pretty sure they couldn't stop Genesis from doing what he wanted to. And Sephiroth during the Before Crisis era was still stronger than Zack or Genesis, heck he defeated Zack. Not to mention, they do have an entire Genesis Clone Army.

And Safer Sephiroth was still brought down by AVALANCHE. None of these eight guys are sure win for AVALANCHES best fighters one-on-one. (Well Azul vs Cloud maybe)

I'm not quite sure what you mean? Could you re-phrase?

Also we have little reason to believe S-cells are gonna do much. First Hollander refused to use Sephiroth's blood, thinking only Angeals would work, then they go after Jenova after that doesn't work then they go after Zack after that doesn't work then they go after Cloud after that doesn't work.

Yes, but Zack himself didn't work because his S-Cells were corrupted.

Sephiroth and Cloud were stated to have pure-S-Cells.
 

Unlucky

WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN
I like Octo's scenario best.

^Same here. :desu:

But who knows, maybe they do get their 'happy' ending. Cloud would come back to Nibelheim and they would've fallen in love anyway. And then have lots of babies and move to Midgar in the upper plates to escape Tifa's dad constant nagging and harassment. Tifa would become a housewife and Cloud, I don't know.. a delivery boy? :desu:

I got confused because there's a thread of the same name. The idea of using DG against Seph was also brought up, although in a different scenario and led to lots of lulz
 

Roger

He/him
AKA
Minato
Yeah, I'm totally aware, but not only is Sephiroth stated to already be the strongest in the entire planet at that point in time, but after Genesis was taken to Deepground, he just casually strolled out of the place, without his sword -- and I'd doubt Weiss or the Restrictors would allow him to do that, for distinct reasons.
Maybe it's just my hatred for Dirge's crappy stuff, but I'm pretty sure they couldn't stop Genesis from doing what he wanted to. And Sephiroth during the Before Crisis era was still stronger than Zack or Genesis, heck he defeated Zack. Not to mention, they do have an entire Genesis Clone Army.

I'm surprised the Restrictors just let that happen, yeah but Weiss doesn't really have a say in the matter, he gets chained back up to that throne when he gets back to base. Nero isn't allowed to just waltz around either.

I'm not quite sure what you mean? Could you re-phrase?
I could see Cloud beating Azul fairly handily but the others I'd all place pretty close to him in strength.

Yes, but Zack himself didn't work because his S-Cells were corrupted.

Sephiroth and Cloud were stated to have pure-S-Cells.
Yeah, they gave a reason after they tried it and it didn't work. Just like with everything else.
 

Wolfmania

Saint of Killers
I'm surprised the Restrictors just let that happen

Most probably because they couldn't really do anything about it.

At this point in time, not only did Genesis recover from his degradation, he was even stronger than before he started degrading -- and so was Sephiroth, after all, everytime he appeared in BC, everyone gasped that he could do things he couldn't before. Unfortunately, Genesis kinda lagged behind because of his degradation?

Besides that, we do know that Weiss and Nero had a time where they tried to coerce Genesis into killing the Restrictors for them, meaning he was talking to Genesis in containment or something like that, since Genesis was set to become an experiment. We know Weiss can't attack a Restrictor, so why would he let his one best shot of rebellion walk out of there, if he could stop it? Especially when Genesis was under orders to become an experiment there.

I think, coupled with the fact that he was Sephiroth's rival at one point, Genesis just didn't give a crap about their efforts to contain him.

I could see Cloud beating Azul fairly handily but the others I'd all place pretty close to him in strength.

Um. Really?

I'd bank money that FFVII Cloud was way stronger than anyone in Deepground, since I consider him around Zack-level. Nevermind AC/C Cloud.

Yeah, they gave a reason after they tried it and it didn't work. Just like with everything else.

Sure, but what points to the S-Cells not working in the case that they're pure like Cloud's or Sephiroth's?
 

Roger

He/him
AKA
Minato
Most probably because they couldn't really do anything about it.

They could, I dunno, just throwing this out there, try to force him, attack him, challenge or fight him? I'm not saying they'd succeed. I'm surprised thy'd just be like "yeah whatever, he can just leave."

At this point in time, not only did Genesis recover from his degradation, he was even stronger than before he started degrading -- and so was Sephiroth, after all, everytime he appeared in BC, everyone gasped that he could do things he couldn't before. Unfortunately, Genesis kinda lagged behind because of his degradation?

In BC he failed to kill Elfe and failed to kill Cloud and Zack and the Player Turk. He was far from unstoppable.

Besides that, we do know that Weiss and Nero had a time where they tried to coerce Genesis into killing the Restrictors for them, meaning he was talking to Genesis in containment or something like that, since Genesis was set to become an experiment. We know Weiss can't attack a Restrictor, so why would he let his one best shot of rebellion walk out of there, if he could stop it? Especially when Genesis was under orders to become an experiment there.

I don't remember coercing being the word used. As far as I know Weiss asked and he declined. He might have just respected his choice, he might have no had a choice because he is always chained up and trying to avod causing problems directly as part of his scheme.

Um. Really?

I'd bank money that FFVII Cloud was way stronger than anyone in Deepground, since I consider him around Zack-level. Nevermind AC/C Cloud.

I didn't get that impression from the Rosso/Cloud encounter. And I'm not saying he wouldn't have won eventually but the same Rosso is absolute pudding in the hands of the Restrictor we see and Weiss. AC Cloud may still be the strongest, but we're talking about their collective strength facing an opponent not as strong as the one AVALANCHE defeated (AVALANCHE membership aside from Cloud and Vincent most definitely not being hyped up as much as the Tsviets or Lost Force).

Sure, but what points to the S-Cells not working in the case that they're pure like Cloud's or Sephiroth's?

Well, nothing since Genesis gave up and decided to try to something vastly different. If Genesis had looked elsewhere sooner we wouldn't have any reason to doubt Zack's cells curing him either, or Jenovas, or Angeals. So yeah, just Hollanders fourth guess doesn't inspire me with a lot of confidence.
 

The Twilight Mexican

Ex-SeeD-ingly good
AKA
TresDias
I don't think it was ever said anywhere that Genesis was being taken to Deepground for experimentation. As far as we know, he was just taken there to contain him the same as Weiss and co.

May well be that when he wished to be sealed, the Restrictors were like, "Sounds cool."
 

Wolfmania

Saint of Killers
They could, I dunno, just throwing this out there, try to force him, attack him, challenge or fight him? I'm not saying they'd succeed. I'm surprised thy'd just be like "yeah whatever, he can just leave."

Yeah, I agree.

I was pretty much saying that they weren't strong enough to stop him from leaving. They probably did try to stop him.

In BC he failed to kill Elfe and failed to kill Cloud and Zack and the Player Turk. He was far from unstoppable.

I didn't say or imply he was, I just said that everyone noted how his power climbed visibly everytime he appeared on-screen.

I don't remember coercing being the word used. As far as I know Weiss asked and he declined. He might have just respected his choice, he might have no had a choice because he is always chained up and trying to avod causing problems directly as part of his scheme.

Assuming Weiss could even talk to him, from the quote, it implies that he went to visit Genesis in containment or something. Not like they'd let Genesis wander around before he decided to break-out, and apparently Genesis only decided to leave after he talked to Weiss.

I don't really see Weiss as the type of guy who'd just take "no" for an answer, if he could've kept Genesis there. Plus, the Restrictors were under direct orders to keep Genesis in there, and if they were really intent on doing that, they'd just release Weiss and tell him to collect Genesis again -- which actually aligns quite well with Weiss's objectives.

Unfortunately for him, he probably got his ass kicked, and Genesis just went to seal himself up in a cave.

I didn't get that impression from the Rosso/Cloud encounter. And I'm not saying he wouldn't have won eventually but the same Rosso is absolute pudding in the hands of the Restrictor we see and Weiss.

The fact that we didn't see the fight dosen't mean we can assume that there was a fight.

What I mean by that is, the Ultimania described their off-shoot as Cloud simply ferociously fighting her off, or defending himself from a direct attack. He was hardly trying with the same strenght or vehemence that he used against Loz and Yazoo, or Kadaj and Sephiroth, evident by the fact that he just took one blade to that entire battle.

For all we know, Rosso was probably sent flying after that first clash of blades, effectively being fought off, and Cloud just continuing his mission, un-interested.
Certainly is the more consistent scenario when combined with Cloud's power, so I go with it.

AC Cloud may still be the strongest

I'm sure Cloud is stronger than anyone from that train-wreck of a game. After all, he did easily beat Kadaj quite easily, who was stated to be around as strong as Sephiroth in VII, and then squared off with Sephiroth in AC/C pretty well.

Heck, I'm sure Zack, Angeal and Genesis are also stronger than anyone in that game.

but we're talking about their collective strength facing an opponent not as strong as the one AVALANCHE defeated

Maybe I implied that he'd be facing 8-10 SOLDIERS at the same time alone, but that was not my intention, sorry. Genesis would likely be there too, and they have an army of Genesis Clones. And I don't think they'd even care to face those odds -- after all, both Sephiroth and Genesis can just fly away and kill them later when they're not grouped up.

My point is, with those resources, and Sephiroth, strongest in the world, they can't really lose. Shinra would go down.

Well, nothing since Genesis gave up and decided to try to something vastly different. If Genesis had looked elsewhere sooner we wouldn't have any reason to doubt Zack's cells curing him either, or Jenovas, or Angeals. So yeah, just Hollanders fourth guess doesn't inspire me with a lot of confidence.

However, Hollander's and Genesis initial contentions were that Pure-S Cells would cure Genesis.

He never changed that contention, it's just that neither Zack nor the Nibel people examined HAD pure-S-Cells, you see.
 
In BC he failed to kill Elfe and failed to kill Cloud and Zack and the Player Turk. He was far from unstoppable.

I think it's canon that he wasn't actually trying to kill Elfe. He also failed to kill Tifa and Tseng. In fact, the list of people Sephiroth did kill is not very impressive: Tifa's middle-aged father, one fat old President, a bunch of office workers, and a defenceless flower girl lost in prayer. He didn't even manage to skewer Palmer, and god knows, Palmer's no small target.
 

Wolfmania

Saint of Killers
I don't think it was ever said anywhere that Genesis was being taken to Deepground for experimentation. As far as we know, he was just taken there to contain him the same as Weiss and co.

May well be that when he wished to be sealed, the Restrictors were like, "Sounds cool."

Wasn't it pretty much implied in the scene where Nero and Weiss are sent to take him back to DG? Might need to double-check.

I doubt Shinra as a whole would just let him go, though. After all he did, and I don't think the Restrictors would make a decision like that without an executive order from the one man they serve.

In this scenario, it's whether or not President Shinra let him go. Assuming Genesis couldn't do it.
 

Roger

He/him
AKA
Minato
Yeah, I agree.

I was pretty much saying that they weren't strong enough to stop him from leaving. They probably did try to stop him.



I didn't say or imply he was, I just said that everyone noted how his power climbed visibly everytime he appeared on-screen.



Assuming Weiss could even talk to him, from the quote, it implies that he went to visit Genesis in containment or something. Not like they'd let Genesis wander around before he decided to break-out, and apparently Genesis only decided to leave after he talked to Weiss.

I don't really see Weiss as the type of guy who'd just take "no" for an answer, if he could've kept Genesis there. Plus, the Restrictors were under direct orders to keep Genesis in there, and if they were really intent on doing that, they'd just release Weiss and tell him to collect Genesis again -- which actually aligns quite well with Weiss's objectives.

Unfortunately for him, he probably got his ass kicked, and Genesis just went to seal himself up in a cave.



The fact that we didn't see the fight dosen't mean we can assume that there was a fight.

Oh come on. We see Rosso and Cloud face off but we can't assume a fight happened. All we know if Weiss asked Genesis to join, he declined and left and we assume he kicked everyones ass on his way out. What am I suppose to do with that.

What I mean by that is, the Ultimania described their off-shoot as Cloud simply ferociously fighting her off, or defending himself from a direct attack. He was hardly trying with the same strenght or vehemence that he used against Loz and Yazoo, or Kadaj and Sephiroth, evident by the fact that he just took one blade to that entire battle.
Hey now, he was fighting with two swords when he was trying to save Marlene and Denzel after he saw Denzel with slinted eyes, you think that means anything?

Certainly is the more consistent scenario when combined with Cloud's power, so I go with it.
Why because you can't accept anyone from Deepground could be formidable?

I'm sure Cloud is stronger than anyone from that train-wreck of a game. After all, he did easily beat Kadaj quite easily, who was stated to be around as strong as Sephiroth in VII, and then squared off with Sephiroth in AC/C pretty well.

Heck, I'm sure Zack, Angeal and Genesis are also stronger than anyone in that game.
WHY? What did Angeal do that was so jawdroppingly impressive to you? Just being in a better game? Cause that doesn't cut it for me.

Maybe I implied that he'd be facing 8-10 SOLDIERS at the same time alone, but that was not my intention, sorry. Genesis would likely be there too, and they have an army of Genesis Clones.

And I don't think they'd even care to face those odds -- after all, both Sephiroth and Genesis can just fly away and kill them later when they're not grouped up.

My point is, with those resources, and Sephiroth, strongest in the world, they can't really lose. Shinra would go down.
What resources? Genesis clones that Cissnei can oneshot and Zack can take down legions of which with a stick against Shinra's armies, mechanised, SOLDIER, Deepground and otherwise and their informationnetwork?

However, Hollander's and Genesis initial contentions were that Pure-S Cells would cure Genesis.
That is not true. Hollander initially told Sephiroth to get bend, then they went after Jenova, never saying jackcrap about Sephiroth, and they evidently found her and nothing.

He never changed that contention, it's just that neither Zack nor the Nibel people examined HAD pure-S-Cells, you see.
Uh, why? ZACK'S genetic structure already mutated because he was injected with Jenova years ago being a SOLDIER. Cloud is no different from the rest of the Nibel people aside from the fact that it effected him too much.
 

The Twilight Mexican

Ex-SeeD-ingly good
AKA
TresDias
I didn't pick up anything related to experimentation from Weiss and Nero's conversation. Just them discussing whether he would join them in their rebellion.

Anyway, I'm not saying he was necessarily released by the Restrictors, but since he voluntarily sealed himself, then that may have been good enough for them, yeah?

For that matter, do we even know that they got him into the Deepground facility itself? They could have discussed things during the helicopter flight and let him go once they reached Midgar.
 

Roger

He/him
AKA
Minato
Well Weiss and Nero says he is to become their brother, they had instructions from someone else. I doubt they meant Argento suggested he'd be useful to their rebellion. Pres. Shinra just wanted Genesis as part of his private army again if you ask me.
 

Wolfmania

Saint of Killers
Oh come on. We see Rosso and Cloud face off but we can't assume a fight happened. All we know if Weiss asked Genesis to join, he declined and left and we assume he kicked everyones ass on his way out. What am I suppose to do with that.

Please, take it as you will. I'm just stating my interpretation. I agree that there is little evidence on what happened at Deepground, though, so I'm just making an educated guess.

Hey now, he was fighting with two swords when he was trying to save Marlene and Denzel after he saw Denzel with slinted eyes, you think that means anything?

Um, I'm not entierly sure what you mean? I didn't really see Cloud fight Rosso, I only really saw him defend himself and a statement that he fought Rosso off.

Based on that, the fact that Cloud was using a single blade and what his general power is, I'm assuming that Rosso probably didn't get up and attack him again after that first clash.

Why because you can't accept anyone from Deepground could be formidable?

Please, let's stick to solid argumentation. Snark only degenerates a debate, in my opinion.

I simply believe that people like Cloud, Zack, Genesis and Angeal were a cut above the rest of their peers, due to various different reasons.
It's not that the DG SOLDIERS aren't formidable, they're just not as formidable as those people. The Tsviets are Genesis Spawns, after all.

WHY? What did Angeal do that was so jawdroppingly impressive to you? Just being in a better game? Cause that doesn't cut it for me.

With Angeal, I'm simply assuming, due to his status as a "Perfect" Monster and a peer to Genesis and Sephiroth, the latter whom we know to have been the strongest of SOLDIER.

That's sorta how I see it.

What resources? Genesis clones that Cissnei can oneshot and Zack can take down legions of which with a stick against Shinra's armies, mechanised, SOLDIER, Deepground and otherwise and their informationnetwork?

Will Zack be fightning for Shinra's side? Because that would pose a rather large complication.

And such clones aren't useless, I distinctly remember one of them defeating Cissnei, before Zack saved her. They are, after all, mutated 2nd and 3rd Classes. I'm sure they're stronger than your average SOLDIER and robot. Deepground's Tsviets are obviously stronger, but that would be simple enough for Genesis and Sephiroth to take, with caution to avoid being out-numbered.

That is not true. Hollander initially told Sephiroth to get bend, then they went after Jenova, never saying jackcrap about Sephiroth, and they evidently found her and nothing.

Huh? I can't really remember where Hollander or Genesis thought that non-S Cells would cure degradation. I'd be pleased if you reminded me.

Uh, why? ZACK'S genetic structure already mutated because he was injected with Jenova years ago being a SOLDIER. Cloud is no different from the rest of the Nibel people aside from the fact that it effected him too much.

I remember reading about this:
Keyword Guide said:
The Last Pure S Cells

Cells from Cloud, who has undergone the Sephiroth Copy experiments and been implanted with S-Cells. The reason Genesis and Hollander deemed them to be the last pure S-Cells was due to the fact that, after having finished examining Zack’s cells in Scene 09-10 and, prior to Scene 09-14, the cells of the Sephiroth Copies roaming Nibelheim, Cloud was the only one who possessed S-Cells which they had not examined.

Apparently, the copies roaming Nibel did not posses pure Cells.
 

The Twilight Mexican

Ex-SeeD-ingly good
AKA
TresDias
Well Weiss and Nero says he is to become their brother, they had instructions from someone else. I doubt they meant Argento suggested he'd be useful to their rebellion. Pres. Shinra just wanted Genesis as part of his private army again if you ask me.

Ah, right. I forgot that the official English localization completely ruined the point of that conversation. In Japanese, they were talking about whether he would agree to join them.

The Scenario Q&A from the Crisis Core Ultimania also specifies this:

http://thelifestream.net/lifestream-projects/translations/340/crisis-core-ultimania-scenario-qa/
 

Wolfmania

Saint of Killers
I honestly think experimentation is the best guess, considering they took Genesis and didn't try to kill him in his sleep. Aside from that, killing or sealing in DG him due to fear of public exposition, which they seemed pretty scared of(so much so that they tried to erase his name).

I doubt they would ever be able to get Genesis to agree to be Shinra's employee again.
 

Roger

He/him
AKA
Minato
Um, I'm not entierly sure what you mean? I didn't really see Cloud fight Rosso, I only really saw him defend himself and a statement that he fought Rosso off.

I don't take he "fought off a ferocious attack" as that's all that happened, that's just a description of what we were seeing in the FMV.

I simply believe that people like Cloud, Zack, Genesis and Angeal were a cut above the rest of their peers, due to various different reasons.
It's not that the DG SOLDIERS aren't formidable, they're just not as formidable as those people. The Tsviets are Genesis Spawns, after all.

With Angeal, I'm simply assuming, due to his status as a "Perfect" Monster and a peer to Genesis and Sephiroth, the latter whom we know to have been the strongest of SOLDIER.
Perfect Monster more refers to his greatest capacity to utilise Jenova's talents then his fighting ability. And none of Tsviets are just Genesis spawns. Each of them spent their whole life being the sole survivor of one experiment to enhance their combat ability after around save for Azul who came in later.


Will Zack be fightning for Shinra's side? Because that would pose a rather large complication.
Same situation as Angeal (except that Sephiroth isn't Zack to pushing him to fight him) really, Zack believes in putting an end to Genesis and Hollanders war but he's not gonna fight to kill with Sephiroth.

And such clones aren't useless, I distinctly remember one of them defeating Cissnei, before Zack saved her. They are, after all, mutated 2nd and 3rd Classes. I'm sure they're stronger than your average SOLDIER and robot. Deepground's Tsviets are obviously stronger, but that would be simple enough for Genesis and Sephiroth to take, with caution to avoid being out-numbered.
They aren't useless but I really dunno what you mean by "with such resources", they are up against Shinra. They do not have the advantage in resources. Deepground alone dwarves their number and mech support.

Huh? I can't really remember where Hollander or Genesis thought that non-S Cells would cure degradation. I'd be pleased if you reminded me.
We are first introduced to Hollander through a Sephiroth flashback. Angeal and Sephiroth both offer themselves for a transfusion to help Genesis, Hollander tells Sephiroth that he is not eglible.
 

Roger

He/him
AKA
Minato
I can't see how it would be anyone's interests to force somebody to be in their private army if he didn't want to be there, but oh well.

Now this is the right way to run a forced-levy army:

http://assassinscreed.wikia.com/wiki/Janissaries

Deepground is entirely a forced slave army. For three years after Meteorfall the three Restrictors left were able to rule over Deepground with an iron fistthrough their chip implants. Guess they weren't smart nough to tag Genesis before he woke up.
 

Wolfmania

Saint of Killers
I don't take he "fought off a ferocious attack" as that's all that happened, that's just a description of what we were seeing in the FMV.

Which is all we see of their fight, and that's my point.

By all means, it's possible that there was more. But, by all means, it's possible that that strike was the strike that "fought her off".

I'm simply assuming one over the other based on my interpretation of Cloud's power shown independant from that scene.

Perfect Monster more refers to his greatest capacity to utilise Jenova's talents then his fighting ability.

Of course -- but that capacity it'self enhances his fighting ability. After all, Jenova Cells are a strong source of power for the body.

And none of Tsviets are just Genesis spawns. Each of them spent their whole life being the sole survivor of one experiment to enhance their combat ability after around save for Azul who came in later.

I'm pretty sure this has been ret-conned from the online by CC:

QnA said:
Q7-2: In DC it is said that “the appearance of G changed the course of Deepground (DG)” and “SOLDIERs branded with epithets of colour are the hell spawn of G”. Does this mean that Weiss and the other Tsviets with colour epithets who were created in DG were created using the results of Project G for reference?

A7-2: Yes. Only the DG SOLDIERs who have been injected with Genesis’ genes could become a Tsviet with a colour epithet.

Same situation as Angeal (except that Sephiroth isn't Zack to pushing him to fight him) really, Zack believes in putting an end to Genesis and Hollanders war but he's not gonna fight to kill with Sephiroth.

So, what do you think Zack would do in this situation?

They aren't useless but I really dunno what you mean by "with such resources", they are up against Shinra. They do not have the advantage in resources. Deepground alone dwarves their number and mech support.

Do we honestly know the numbers of Genesis's army? By the reports of genocide that he did, it was probably really large. I don't know if Shinra would have more SOLDIERS overall after the mass desertion. Certainly, though, their regular army is bigger.

We are first introduced to Hollander through a Sephiroth flashback. Angeal and Sephiroth both offer themselves for a transfusion to help Genesis, Hollander tells Sephiroth that he is not eglible.

But how does that discredit the later guess of the S-Cells? After all, Angeal was a G-Type, same as Genesis, and at that point in time, the wound was simply not closing, instead of Genesis degrading.

However, after Genesis started degrading, he quickly changed his tune into getting the S-Cells.
 

The Twilight Mexican

Ex-SeeD-ingly good
AKA
TresDias
One does get the impression that Hollander was full of shit as far as the S-Cells concept is concerned.

At first, he says they need Gillian in order to stop the degradation. Whoops, she's dead. Then they need Jenova's cells. Oh, hey, not Jenova cells, Genesis, you silly goose, you. S-Cells, a concept I just pulled out of my ass just now because you have a sword pointed at my neck. Well, what do you know, these S-Cells in Zack and the other black cloaks are no good! Must mean that only pure S-Cells can do the trick, and only Zack's little chocobo-haired buddy -- conveniently, the only guy Hojo experiemtned on that we haven't checked out yet -- has them.

I'm pretty sure Hollander was just trying to stay alive and kept coming up with bullshit stories.
 

Roger

He/him
AKA
Minato
I'm simply assuming one over the other based on my interpretation of Cloud's power shown independant from that scene.

And Rosso's? Where does the interpretation of her strength independent of that scene that neccesitates she wouldn't last more then a few seconds against Cloud come from. Her backstory goes to much more pains to hype her up then Angeals does (or Zacks but CC speaks for itself on that one.)

Of course -- but that capacity it'self enhances his fighting ability. After all, Jenova Cells are a strong source of power for the body.

And Azul and Vince are the biggest shapeshifters of all.

I'm pretty sure this has been ret-conned from the online by CC:

Well they all are given Genesis' cells or genes too. But it didn't end or start there for any of them.

So, what do you think Zack would do in this situation?

I'd say he'd try to convince Sephiroth to come back but as I said, I don't think Genesis, Hollander or Lazard have what it takes to make Sephiroth defect in the first place.

Do we honestly know the numbers of Genesis's army? By the reports of genocide that he did, it was probably really large. I don't know if Shinra would have more SOLDIERS overall after the mass desertion. Certainly, though, their regular army is bigger.

Zack was quite convinced they had wiped out the Genesis copies. Their offensive to free Hollander was huge but by then they weren't composed of SOLDIER 2nds and 3rds anymore, we get reports of people being kidnapped don't we?

But how does that discredit the later guess of the S-Cells? After all, Angeal was a G-Type, same as Genesis, and at that point in time, the wound was simply not closing, instead of Genesis degrading.

That's what Sephiroth thought back then. The reports Zack and Sephiroth were reading contradicted that and said he was deteriorating (though here the english dub is pretty sloppy).

However, after Genesis started degrading, he quickly changed his tune into getting the S-Cells.

DEFINE QUICKLY He sure didn't bring it up when he talked to Sephiroth at Mako Reactor 5. Nor did he bring it up at Modeoheim. We don't hear jack about it until the Nibelheim Reactor two years later. They spent all that time looking for Jenova.
 

Wolfmania

Saint of Killers
However, he was degrading himself, remember? Genesis probably forced him to do that for precisely the reason which you're describing.

Hard to think that he would not be intent to save his own life.

Minato Arisato said:
And Rosso's? Where does the interpretation of her strength independent of that scene that neccesitates she wouldn't last more then a few seconds against Cloud come from. Her backstory goes to much more pains to hype her up then Angeals does (or Zacks but CC speaks for itself on that one.)

It comes from my contention and interpretation of Cloud's power through his doings, even before he received S-Cells, to the point where the fought Sephiroth in AC/C.

However, would you really like to get into a such diatribe to see who has the better "feats" or "doings"? This is an un-winnable battle, like the old saying goes. Best if you just stick to your interpretation, and I stick to mine.

I will say that I don't think anything Rosso has done comes close to Angeal's portrayal as a peer to Genesis and Sephiroth, but that is also based on interpretations on what those two have done. If we were to debate that, we could be here for days.

Minato Arisato said:
And Azul and Vince are the biggest shapeshifters of all.

Maybe, but probably not? Jenova can take on any form it wishes, too, and Angeal is, well, what we stated. I mean, Angeal has one preferred form, just like those guys.

However, shape-shifting isn't the only power which comes from the cells. There's tons. They're basically multi-functional and really, really useful.

Minato Arisato said:
Well they all are given Genesis' cells or genes too. But it didn't end or start there for any of them.

Nor did I ever that it started or ended there, I was merely quoting the quote it'self there. I was just bringing light to the fact that only SOLDIERS with Genesis's genes could become one of the colored Tsviets, and Genesis is their older brother, hence, as the quote states, they are Genesis spawn, in a certain manner of speaking.

Minato Arisato said:
I'd say he'd try to convince Sephiroth to come back but as I said, I don't think Genesis, Hollander or Lazard have what it takes to make Sephiroth defect in the first place.

Well, Genesis certainly didn't have an enticing offer the first time.

Minato Arisato said:
That's what Sephiroth thought back then. The reports Zack and Sephiroth were reading contradicted that and said he was deteriorating

Oh, ok. I don't remember, so that may be the case.

Minato Arisato said:
DEFINE QUICKLY He sure didn't bring it up when he talked to Sephiroth at Mako Reactor 5. Nor did he bring it up at Modeoheim. We don't hear jack about it until the Nibelheim Reactor two years later. They spent all that time looking for Jenova.

But is that enough to discredit the notion that Hollander was convinced the cells would work? Especially when he himself was suffereing degradation?
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom