Flintlock
Pro Adventurer
Take your time; now we know the theme is going to be a dark one (well, the poll hasn't closed yet, but I don't see the result changing), I can start working on that. The background is pretty much the easiest thing to change anyway so we can tweak it until we get it right.
I think the text in the banner looks better than it did in your previous mockup, but I'd still make it a bit bigger and reduce the letter spacing. And to be fair, the main reason it looks different (apart from the size) on my mockups is that Gimp doesn't handle Photoshop text very well.
I agree that it would be a good idea to make the body stand out a bit from the background, but I don't think a gradient is the way to go. While gradients are making a quiet comeback in web design, they're pretty much all self-contained (i.e. with a definite edge, like in this example). The "fade to black" gradient still feels very much out of date. If we can't come up with a better solution, I'd prefer just pushing the body colour up a touch, perhaps to something like #07191d, to increase the contrast without dramatically changing the theme.
I think the text in the banner looks better than it did in your previous mockup, but I'd still make it a bit bigger and reduce the letter spacing. And to be fair, the main reason it looks different (apart from the size) on my mockups is that Gimp doesn't handle Photoshop text very well.
I agree that it would be a good idea to make the body stand out a bit from the background, but I don't think a gradient is the way to go. While gradients are making a quiet comeback in web design, they're pretty much all self-contained (i.e. with a definite edge, like in this example). The "fade to black" gradient still feels very much out of date. If we can't come up with a better solution, I'd prefer just pushing the body colour up a touch, perhaps to something like #07191d, to increase the contrast without dramatically changing the theme.