If Palpatine's character develops, his return adds to the story, is necessary to the plot, and performs world-building stuff (etc), I'm all for it
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0c00d/0c00d567532d0bc7027140c4a4a520dc39ecc5ff" alt=":p :P :P"
. I think I'd prefer a fresh villain though, something that explores something else than the old Jedi versus Sith thing.