Very interesting read.
However, I doubt even S-E put so much thought into it, unfortunatelly.
And really, there are some things in your analysis/theory that are a little... Off, in my opinion.
For example: You completelly ignored Weiss' existence. You assumed that Safer Sephiroth have a connection with the Planet(and Minerva in specific) just because of the angel-wings, when we all know that S-E add angel-wings to different entities and enemies from different FFs, just because they love doing this(a better indication for Safer's connection with the Planet would be his halo, because this is a characteristic only found in higher beings created by the Planet[Minerva, Omega, and Zirconiade, all have them]). You assumed that Jenova used the Planet's memories to gain knowledge of the Ancients, when in fact, the game tell us in two different moments that Jenova-cells can read the mind of people close to them(a better explanation of how Jenova obtained the information it needed, in my opinion). And IMHO you gave too much importance to Jenova itself, degrading Sephiroth to a mere host for it's revival(and eventual destruction), something I doubt S-E will ever do.
I'm sorry for criticizing your theory so much, but that's just my opinion. There are some very good and well-thought points in it, and I congratulate you for that. But I don't think everything you said, is gonna happen in the next game.
No worries, I appreciate the criticism as much as the praise.
Weiss was more connected to the general lifecycle of the Planet with Omega and Chaos. Since he lacks any J/S/G Cells, and is being manipulated by Hojo some of the time, despite being a powerful entity, I don't really see him being a largely significant portion of the Planet's fight against Jenova. He is present at the end of DoC in Genesis' arms, but that seemed like something more plot specific that didn't really fit the speculation that I wanted to focus on for this particular article. It's less about who is involved, and more about the Planet & Jenova's perpetual War, and how Genesis could be used to end it, not really who is involved in it's accomplishment, aside from the basics.
The halo is a good thing to point out, and something that I didn't notice, but is a good indicator. The 6 equally spaced white wings all arranged at the base of the Goddess Statue & the ones on the lower half of Safer Sephiroth seemed more than just an SE wing fetish. Seraph Sephiroth was the FIRST thing I thought of when I saw it upon playing through Crisis Core, and it's stuck with me ever since. Admittedly, it's probably one of my most broad assumptions, because it feels like there's a connection that hasn't been talked about, but very little documentation to back it up.
You mention Jenova's mind-reading powers. If you have a link to any of that text, I'd be more than happy to see it, as it's something that I did in fact overlook.
As for Sephiroth, I still see him as playing a role, although I did rather downplay his importance in my article, because there's a lot that I COULD get into that. He and Genesis have a fairly fierce rivalry, and whether or not Jenova actually fully comes back isn't really important as long as her will is removed from Gaia's Lifestream where it currently resides. That's why I was focusing on her bringing her will back to her fully re-formed body. Sephiroth popping his head back up isn't really something I felt was too important to make a big deal over because it's happened before, whereas Jenova coming together is key to her being purged from Gaia, and is my reason for focusing on her and not Sephiroth. I've always seen Sephiroth as humanity's embodyment of the war against Jenova, and Jenova as an entity/being as the real threat to the Planet's ability to heal, and that's what I wanted to focus on.
Again, most of this is wishful thinking and speculation, and sequels are usually far from what anyone expects, ESPECIALLY ones from SE, but I think that the lack of information has been on long enough that getting speculation and some theorycrafting started was a good way to get some ideas and thoughts flowing back on the universe of FFVII, because although it feels that everything's been done to death in this series a lot of the time, because of the Compilation, I still think that there's a lot of mystery and magic that's untouched, it's just a little harder to assemble.
X ![Neo :neo: :neo:](/forums/images/smilies/neo.gif)