I hate this 'winner takes all' philosophy.
There's always next time.
Most games we've chosen for Community Playthroughs have finished second in a poll before winning later on. That was the case with Final Fantasy VIII, Chrono Trigger and Final Fantasy V, which came second a ridiculous
three consecutive times before winning.
X now has the second-most cumulative votes of any game not to have been selected. XII is in first place in that count but has never finished higher than third in an individual vote/nomvote.
Yes, I made a spreadsheet, yes,
you can see it, and yes, I know I'm a nerd.
Note that I only included the first round of voting this year, and that there was no vote for our first two* playthroughs, which were VI and VII.
* Mog started a VII community playthrough but didn't complete it; I then restarted and finished it. I think we should count it as one complete playthrough, even though it took place across two years.