Makoeyes987
Listen closely, there is meaning in my words.
- AKA
- Smooth Criminal
I'm endlessly fascinated by the Remake's depiction of how Cloud's memories are fucked up.
Like, it's making a lot more sense how they've hinted at Cloud's fragmented mental state in Part 1.
Cloud remembers being imprisoned and experimented on by Shinra. And needing to escape from Hojo as shown in Chapter 14.
"I saw you lying there. I figured it was too late."
This is 100% inaccurate. We know Cloud carried Tifa, cradled her, and felt to see if she were alive, while she was unconscious.
But from Zack's perspective?
It isn't inaccurate at all. Zack shared no such intimate moment with Tifa. She was just left lying there after he briefly tried to talk to her.
Think back to Chapter 7 of FFVII-R. Before the Airbuster fight.
Cloud has a flashback of Tifa saying her iconic line, stating how sick of SOLDIER she is.
Cloud thinks to himself, "It's just like... When I failed you."
But think back at who Tifa directed those biting words to. "Sephiroth... SOLDIERs... Mako... Shinra... I'm sick of this. I'm sick of ALL of this!" Who was she speaking to?
Cloud wasn't there for that moment. Zack was.
I'm reminded of how the explanation for Cloud's false persona in FFVII was a mixture of his own inadequacy, Jenova cells filling giving him the info of what happened with the blanks filled in with some of Zack's recollections, and how he was never just a clear Zack copy in terms of how he saw himself.
But the hilarity now is, Cloud is emulating Zack much more than before. Especially with the potential of him literally transposing himself in his role all the way down to looking for who he escaped with...
Like, it's making a lot more sense how they've hinted at Cloud's fragmented mental state in Part 1.
Cloud remembers being imprisoned and experimented on by Shinra. And needing to escape from Hojo as shown in Chapter 14.
"I saw you lying there. I figured it was too late."
This is 100% inaccurate. We know Cloud carried Tifa, cradled her, and felt to see if she were alive, while she was unconscious.
But from Zack's perspective?
It isn't inaccurate at all. Zack shared no such intimate moment with Tifa. She was just left lying there after he briefly tried to talk to her.
Think back to Chapter 7 of FFVII-R. Before the Airbuster fight.
Cloud has a flashback of Tifa saying her iconic line, stating how sick of SOLDIER she is.
Cloud thinks to himself, "It's just like... When I failed you."
But think back at who Tifa directed those biting words to. "Sephiroth... SOLDIERs... Mako... Shinra... I'm sick of this. I'm sick of ALL of this!" Who was she speaking to?
Cloud wasn't there for that moment. Zack was.
I'm reminded of how the explanation for Cloud's false persona in FFVII was a mixture of his own inadequacy, Jenova cells filling giving him the info of what happened with the blanks filled in with some of Zack's recollections, and how he was never just a clear Zack copy in terms of how he saw himself.
But the hilarity now is, Cloud is emulating Zack much more than before. Especially with the potential of him literally transposing himself in his role all the way down to looking for who he escaped with...