Claymore
3x3 Eyes
Why did we decide against Xenforo again? I ask because that's what the new ResetEra is using and I'm finding it pretty great to use so far. Pretty much in love with the notifications button - it's similar to Discourse's but has a more TLS-like traditional feel.
Yeah it's so nice and familiar to navigate around that I felt the same. Despite the issues you guys have mentioned, maybe it's worth giving it another look for an upgrade option.