(Adding spoiler tags to your post.)
For me, that's just not going to work. It's already a questionable change from what was there before, but at least one I can live with without bitterness since it leaves the characters' existing arcs as they are.
Changing their knowledge of that event in addition to the facts of it, though, also changes the facts as they understood them in the post-FFVII material where they went about processing their guilt and looking for atonement in their own ways. The idea of having part of Tifa wish that the Lifestream would wash her and the place of her mistakes away along with Meteor ... because "she let herself be duped" ... while the tragedy of people's actual lives being destroyed is right before her eyes -- that's just about the most myopically painful cringe I can imagine.
Only in the most melodrama-fueled writing would getting duped by someone into thinking you're responsible for something terrible they did (and wanted to do anyway) be a thing worth going through existential anguish over. I personally can't stand angst over crap that just isn't that big of a deal. Like Angeal "losing his honor" because he found out he was experimented on prior to birth and the other experimentation done on him as a young man. Which he volunteered for.
Nope. Can't do it.
(Adding spoiler tags to your post.)
For me, that's just not going to work. It's already a questionable change from what was there before, but at least one I can live with without bitterness since it leaves the characters' existing arcs as they are.
Changing their knowledge of that event in addition to the facts of it, though, also changes the facts as they understood them in the post-FFVII material where they went about processing their guilt and looking for atonement in their own ways. The idea of having part of Tifa wish that the Lifestream would wash her and the place of her mistakes away along with Meteor ... because "she let herself be duped" ... while the tragedy of people's actual lives being destroyed is right before her eyes -- that's just about the most myopically painful cringe I can imagine.
Only in the most melodrama-fueled writing would getting duped by someone into thinking you're responsible for something terrible they did (and wanted to do anyway) be a thing worth going through existential anguish over. I personally can't stand angst over crap that just isn't that big of a deal. Like Angeal "losing his honor" because he found out he was experimented on prior to birth and the other experimentation done on him as a young man. Which he volunteered for.
Nope. Can't do it.
Except that the post FFVII-material already out there was based on the original game, not the remake. Any new post-game content would be different.
Jairus said:And I never said anything about having Tifa wish that - you're putting words in my mouth.
Not holding back at all, huh? lmao But really, though:
Is the premise of that circumstance that different from say, Cloud's grief in AC? Though if you dislike that as well, that is fair, but for I've seen it's quite common to have characters "blame themselves" for things that aren't theirs to shoulder, or be bogged down by something they couldn't do something about anyway. (which sometimes, it was something that could've been done, but they didn't for whatever reason that probably adds to their grief) If it sounds like melodrama angst that is cringy, well...that sounds pretty close to how even real-life people can get, honestly. XD
That's what I said.I mean, Cloud is dying slowly and painfully, it's not some kind of inconsequential concern. That's in addition to repeatedly watching people he loves die in front of him in various grisly ways while powerless to stop it. And now he's got to watch Denzel die on top of that.
These are not small issues he should just get over with some kind of pep talk.
Kitase recently said that "all of the lore from the works created after the original game, the Compilation of Final Fantasy 7, that’s all very much in the base of the canon for the remake, and going forward it will be too."
We should basically assume that the events of the Compilation happened in both the universe of the original game and the universe of the remake.
I was clearly talking about the opening scene from "Episode:Tifa" of "On the Way to A Smile." =|
Taking the gravity of really having been part of something that hurt people away from Tifa's anguish would just make her look silly to me. Especially in a moment like the opening of "Episode:Tifa," juxtaposed against all that's happening in Midgar below.
I definitely want to see how it all plays out in the remake, butunless Avalanche finds out that Shinra was behind the number 1 reactor blowing right away, I think they're still plenty culpable just because they chose to go after the next reactor regardless. They saw all the death and destruction--and while assuming they were responsible--went to go do it again. To me, this makes them seem both dangerous and reckless/incompetent, which in some ways is a scarier combo.
Not to mention the Inside FFVIIR documentary from the other day shows Avalanche celebrating at a train station, which I assume happens after the first bombing mission. So they're excited enough to jump around even seeing all of the destruction they believe they caused, which I don't think is a great look, but fits their character.
I've seen it argued that the plate drop is enough to establish Shinra's ruthlessness, and that them also being responsible for the reactor is redundant.
If this were the original game, I'd agree, but it isn't. From what I understand, plate fall happens well into the remake. Over half way through. So there's potentially 20 hours of gameplay before then. Shinra needs to be established as the ruthless group they are earlier than that.
I think they're still plenty culpable just because they chose to go after the next reactor regardless. They saw all the death and destruction--and while assuming they were responsible--went to go do it again. To me, this makes them seem both dangerous and reckless/incompetent, which in some ways is a scarier combo.
Many elements of it, yes, but not necessarily all the specific events. That quote says nothing of those. I think he meant more that they're taking many elements of the Compilation and remixing them into a coherent lore rather than say every event in them actually happened, especially when some of them clearly contradict each other and can't have both happened - such as Last Order/Crisis Core and their depiction of what ultimately happened to Sephiroth in the Nibel reactor. Both show it completely different, so both can't be true - either Cloud threw him in or he didn't.
Jairus said:It's been a while since I've read that, but why would you think any such pondering about any guilt concerning the reactor bombings would be done at that moment instead of another?