Their excuses absolutely hold no water. They seem to be going for the "Tira was an afterthought and won't be ready by launch, so she HAS to be DLC."
1. Make her free.
2. She's a mainstay character. Fuck you.
3. If she won't be ready by launch, how is she a "Day 1" DLC??
4. They actually said she was added "because of the immense community demand for her" which absolutely means that she was MONETISED because she was popular.
So, I checked
the quotes they gave from this article, which I'll quote and try to dissect what sounds legit vs. what sounds shitty:
Pierre Tartaix said:
"I know it hasn't been the most popular decision, we had people being pretty mad, not understanding what's happening there. So, the idea is Tira has been a huge request from the community since we announced the game, and when we realised how popular Tira was, we decided to integrate her into the game. Unfortunately, it was late into the development process, The public usually sees a game when it's announced, roughly a year before it's released, but a game's development can take two years, three years -- it's a long, long process. So we started developing Tira -- her model, her abilities, her gameplay -- late into development, so we can make it work to be there on release, but we can't make it work to be in the game when we submit. The end of [the game's] development is way before the release of the game."
So, back to your points:
1. Yeah. Do THIS. Period.
2. It looks like not ALL the big Soul Calibur characters were planned for this. They're drawing a majority of the cast (revealed so far) from SC2 and
very few outside of that. Given how they talked about it, she wasn't in that initial list for a long time and I definitely believe that. It makes sense especially given when she comes in to Nightmare's story and when it seems like they're setting this. Working in software development, it makes sense that if they became aware of a big push to get her in the game that they worked hard to add her in, and they have enough to show her off in a trailer, but that can still be a ways before she actually works as a character. Additionally, because she's a late addition, she's gonna feel different because she was literally an after-the-fact addition and not a big planned integration, if that's the case.
3. Sprint planning for software release. Given how roadmaps work in software, you're prioritizing the things that you need for game release, which is everything that you need to send to publishers with the game finished, as-is for physical copies. That means everything initially planned is good to go by then, which it will be. Her being a "Day 1 DLC" character means that they believe that between the game going gold and the actual street date, that they can get her working
as an additional fighter. Her status as "Day 1 DLC" also means that they're openly separating her from how closely her role/story/etc. is integrated with the other core parts of the game. If she wasn't added until later, there're story beats and other elements that she won't be a part of EVEN IF they still managed to get her workable and cram her in in time for the physical release. Given the timelines and presentation it sounds like there's a reason that she's listed as a "Day 1 DLC" character even though the full in-game roster hasn't been revealed.
4. 100% this, and that's why this situation feels so shady. Even if you're gonna do a season pass with DLC fighters in it
like basically every fighting game ever does, this comes off as scummy. They totally announced her to build up hype that she WILL be available at launch for the people who want her. That did its job. If she's DLC, it's still apparent to most folks that she's been added afterwards and won't feel as completely tied in as the other character. ...But then they just shot themselves in the foot at the same time by putting her behind the Season Pass. If you made her a free, "Day 1 DLC" character and STILL announced a Season Pass with more fighters, people wouldn't be shredding them apart in the same way.
Here's my tl;dr take on it all: This definitely feels like something where they wanted to keep the hype of having her at launch because the fans wanted her when the game dropped, while also making it so that her and the other Season Pass DLC characters are apparent as separate additions that are different from the core cast of the on-disc game. They didn't make the connection of why doing both things at once was completely the worst possible way to go about accomplishing it. I'd definitely chalk this one up to stupid rather than greedy/malicious, but it doesn't make it any less shitty.
X