Red sounds too soft to me.
Oh, don’t get me started. I mean, seriously. One lousy line and they still manage to go WTF with the voice. Even before FFX came out, I imagined Nanaki sounding like Kimhari(sp?) (but less Hulk speak).
OK, we get it SE - Nanaki is young for his species, but still. Pity is, Liam O’Brian could have done it brilliantly. I mean, Ukitake in BLEACH? That would work just as well for Nanaki.
Cait Sith can suck it, I know he's based on a creature from Scottish/Irish folklore but ffs, that accent is atrocious on him.
Aww, c’mon! If it wasn’t for the accent, I would have hated having Cait hanging around all the time through DC.
Still, both he and Cloud seemed like they'd be more... informal, mid-West American in the original game.
As for Sephiroth with a British voice... David Bowie. Or possibly Paterson Joseph. Seriously. Just listen to this clip - he’s the second male speaker (the one without the Scots accent). But you should watch it, too, as his character has an awesome coat.
The Marquis de Carabas
I also felt I should possibly stick up for Ms. Cook, but I then remembered I had told someone that I liked Tifa's new English VA in KHII much better than her AC one. So, yeah.
...Ah, this might just be me being an old fogey, but I feel like the series (that is, Final Fantasy as a whole, not just VII) has gotten worse since the introduction of voice actors. The scripts seem a lot lazier. I mean, the wittiest parts of the scripts seem to be the shout-outs to - if not direct quotes of - previous games.