Was Aerith told that...

He remembered the truck ride with Zack talking about crashing with a girl in Midgar, and he probably pieced it together at some point that with how Aerith had been talking about him, he must have been talking about her. Add in that AC shows Cloud flashing back to a number of different scenes with Zack and it's fully possible that Cloud's remembered other memories with him too. Then toss in that CC Zack dies thinking of Aerith and was determined to get to Midgar for her and it's easy to imagine that he rambled about her to a headbobbing Cloud once or twice. Especially since the dying thought was for Cloud to say "hi" to her for him, implying he thought Cloud might know her if he saw her.

On the other hand, there's not much suggestion Tseng has had any communication with Cloud prior to Advent Children for Cloud to know from him. The Turks are busy with their thing and mostly staying in the background, Cloud and Tifa have their own worries. Tifa's line to Reno on the phone implies it's been a while since any contact occurred. I think it's more likely he figured it out on his own.

I don't think there's any solid reason to suppose that he ever figures it out. Of course we, the audience, read a certain significance into the fact that Zack and Aerith leave the church together at the end of ACC, because we know that they shared a bond which had nothing to do with Cloud, but for all Cloud knows, they are both there for him only and have no other reason to be in the same place together.
 

minimosey

Pro Adventurer
...And did you read a certain significance to Cloud bringing Zack's sword to the church, or did you figure he was just making grave visits more convenient???

Because that in itself has Cloud placing them together in their memorials.
 

Danseru-kun

Pro Adventurer
I dunno if I had mentioned this before I think I did but I hope Zack's parents also get a closure. In CoT they visited Elmyra and I kinda hope they visited his parents too. They're still waiting for their son to come back home :(
 
...And did you read a certain significance to Cloud bringing Zack's sword to the church, or did you figure he was just making grave visits more convenient???

Because that in itself has Cloud placing them together in their memorials.


I just think we need to be careful not to assume that Cloud knows everything we know. And yes, given that the Remnants kicked Zack's sword around and abused it, I think you could make an argument for saying that Cloud brought it to the Church so it would be safe. Obviously it's likelier that he brought it there because he finally made the connection, but we never see him making the connection or hear anybody helping him to make the connection.

I reckon Cissnei turned up one day and told him.
 

minimosey

Pro Adventurer
Licorice, I have no idea why you're protesting the idea that he pieced together information he has available right to him (discard the conjecture about additional memories and he'd still have enough to go "hey..."), but you're okay with suggesting a Turk we haven't seen in post-game era at all turned up to tell him the relationship status of Zack and Aerith when she had no investment in Zack and Aerith as a couple.

But you already admitted it was likelier so I'm just stopping, because seriously, I don't get what you're gunning for at all. Do we need everything spelled out?

So Zack can symbolically watch while Cloud spirit bangs Aerith?

I would change this to Zack spirit banging Cloud while Aerith watches.

Because she does like to watch over everyone... ;)
 

AYAHIRANO

The Supreme Ruler
Aerith was never notified about Zack's death,not even Zack's parents knew of his demise.But somehow,Aerith sensed something was wrong,although she wasn't sure of it,all she knows is that Zack "left" her.


 
Top Bottom