Most reasons to kill oneself seem stupid to people with rational brains (the exceptions are terminal diseases that cause a lot of pain or memory loss or some other horrible consequences, or other situations where there is no escape and likely to be lots of negative consequences), but the key point is that the brains of most people who commit suicide are not rational. Saying "I'm as bad as Hitler" sounds absurd to someone with a rational brain, but acute enough depression where a person thinks that killing themselves is a rational decision makes it likely that the person who makes such a statement is incapable of rational thought, and thus won't realise how absurd the comparison is.
No shit. I myself realise how stupid suicide is, it hasn't stopped me from coming close to harming myself or ODing on some shit.
I looked at the context of what she said, the fact that she's done this before on other sites, and I said I had some suspicions. I am not certain, but there's something that didn't seem genuine about any of it. Of course context can fix this.
We have no idea what else she's been through dude. All we know is what she's been through on the forum. As far as I'm aware she's never even talked about her real life shit, apart from saying: For all we know she could have terrible real-world problems she's never brought up on the forum before. Not everyone shares all their trauma with people
Annnnd? That doesn't dispel my suspicions, or the fact that none of what she's said or done has made sense. She hasn't even attempted to tell anyone the real cause of her problems despite everyone show her their support, and this is the second time this has happened here.
Of course it'd be best if we had some context here. Instead of these threads making these declarations that don't help anyone help her.
Indeed, people who are depressed enough to want to kill themselves are unlikely to think anyone else cares enough to hear about their problems in the first place.
Or they know people care and they just don't give a damn. I sure as shit didn't.
If you're depressed enough to want to kill yourself you probably won't in a rational enough state of mind to think you need help unless enough people point out that you should get help.
Yet people have told her she needs help before and that they were available to talk about it in her previous thread , voiding this supposition entirely. You're making the assumption that some reason is entirely lost to her, when it clearly is not.
