Well ngl I'm not crazy about the PI thing. I'm at peace with the fact that Beckett unrealistically is never going to take a promotion and they're going to find ways to jam their cases together in every episode now, but once upon a time I really had high hopes for a shake up to the procedural nature of the show. I was so so hoping that when Beckett got a promotion it would be to the CIA or FBI or there'd be some kind of new initiative that allowed the core characters to work more closely together on cases.
I don't know how to explain what I'm trying to say properly. In the middle of season 3 if I could have looked into the future and saw them still at that bloody precinct with no major change it would have put me off the show. While this season has definitely been the shows worst based on the first 6 or so episodes, it has improved and become as good as the previous good episodes. The last episode rivals some of the best in terms of how well done it was.
I mean I get it, I know how procedurals work. I got excited when Beckett got that random promotion to that thing in DC which was never going to work for obvious reasons because I was hoping at the end of it we'd get a bit of an upgrade somehow. I just find it harder to connect with a show that doesn't evolve, and procedurals don't evolve. They don't have a continuous changing narrative like the shows that I enjoy the most, they have walls and rails and boxes that need to be ticked. In Castle 99% of the time the killer is the second or third person you meet who is in some way connected with the person who died, even though it seems like they have nothing to do with it at the start and they go through 5 other suspects who they have IRON CLAD EVIDENCE on first.
The only thing that has kept me watching is the quality of the writing, the quirks of humour and the characters. The writing got lost at the start of this season and the show suffered horribly, because it has pretty much nothing else going for it. I can pretty much guarantee at this point that the craziest shake up is going to be when (not if) Beckett becomes Chief because Gates dies tragically or heroically or something. I can see that happening at the end of this season tbh. Then Castle will be back in the precinct and the status quo will be restored yet again.
I'm missing the episodes where the FBI and CIA and whoever else got involved, those 2/3-parters were always so much more interesting to me.
I still love the show and that's saying a lot because I can't stand procedurals. I think they're cheap. But it would hands down be my favourite thing on TV if they were willing to step outside the box a bit more often. I only engage with the episodes where the lives of the main or secondary characters are impacted by what's happening, and 9 times out of 10 this show is person x dies for these reasons, person y did it for these reasons and they always somehow get a bloody confession. Then Castle and Beckett have a light-hearted conversation or one of them make an angsty expression (upgraded from flirting in early seasons to foreplay now) and that's it. That's your whack. That's all you get to keep you engaged and make you excited for more episodes. It just doesn't work for me any more.