Captain Jack Harkness
not a out-of-bounds guy
- AKA
- 4nn4-chan, Loras Tyrell, Loki
they was his adoptive parents, that because he kill them and say that "they have always bertrayed me".
While I find the Aerith cult a plausible idea, y'know given how fucking stupid people are, the idea that Cloud would be taken in by it or whatever sticks in my craw. A) Because he actually knew Aerith, he shouldn't be mythologising (?) her like that. He knows her as a real human being with all the quirks and flaws that entails and B) It would basically be back to square one with the 'us or a memory' thing, and I just can't see (and wouldn't want) Tifa to tolerate that.
I'd rather see someone else manipulating the 'cult of Aerith' for their own ends, and Cloud and Co trying to put a stop to it. It would be kind of interesting if Shinra were responsible, because Tseng wouldn't stand for that one!
I second this. I wouldn't mind Cloud investigating the cult for example, but being taken in by it is another issue and I feel a bit like that would send his character backwards as far as his characterization goes.
I figured I'd hop in to this thread and toss around some of my ideas for what characters who weren't involved in my post-DoC story conclusion article could be up to.
I've always liked the idea of Nanaki maturing a little bit, and trying to learn how to hear the Voice of the Planet. He'd obtain guidance from Bugenhagen's research, and start learning more about his past in the process. It'd also be interesting to get into the idea of Undeath in the FFVII-universe, with Gi Nattak's tribe and some of the other things that happen there taking a somewhat sinister role in a subplot looking at bringing things back from the Lifestream.
During this subplot, we have Vincent pull a "surprise appearance in the moment of danger, and spout off scientific information" moment. Between Vincent's background and Nanaki's heritage, especially given their brief friendship shown in OTWTAS, it makes sense that these grounds are somewhere that they'd experience a brief, but strong journey together, that could also provide a lot of interesting depth to the mythology. Afterwards, Vincent goes back off to assisting Shelke, and Nanaki starts his own personal search for Deneh.
That's it for now, but I'll try to carve out a little time to post in here again soon.
X
Exactly, and thats like the main thing that fucked off so many fans about AC, so for any sequel that kind of stuff has to be avoided like the plague.
I can sort of see Marlene becoming involved in such a cult though.
Shinra being responsible would be interesting because it would give some decent chance for conflict among that portion of the cast, but that also seems kind of predicable by this point, at least in my opinion. They seem to have a hand in most of the issues the world has both directly and indirectly.
Still, Rufus could be using this to try to regain his former influence through other means.
While I find the Aerith cult a plausible idea, y'know given how fucking stupid people are, the idea that Cloud would be taken in by it or whatever sticks in my craw.
Oh, I don't think he'd be getting in it all the way. The bit about his naivete was just that he might think uh, they're kind of skewing things, but they mean well and people need something to get by, so maybe it's okay...? And then he finds out more going on under the surface and it's a whoa no we're stopping this right now.
The idea was also that others might be worried he's been taken in by it, because of past events, but like you said, he's overcome that. It'd be sort of a little 'gotcha' with players being led to believe Cloud might be doing something really stupid and then it turns out no, actually, he's got things under control this time.
I see it the other way. With this issue at hand I can picture Shinra and his Turks being like they were in AC-- they got Cloud's back but they definitely have a different agenda. As I've mentioned in my previous post, I can imagine Rufus getting rid of new organizations that may threaten his power, and this cult seems to fit the description. So instead of Rufus being behind this, he might want to get rid of it for a reason different from Cloud & Co's.
Oh, I don't think he'd be getting in it all the way. The bit about his naivete was just that he might think uh, they're kind of skewing things, but they mean well and people need something to get by, so maybe it's okay...? And then he finds out more going on under the surface and it's a whoa no we're stopping this right now.
The idea was also that others might be worried he's been taken in by it, because of past events, but like you said, he's overcome that. It'd be sort of a little 'gotcha' with players being led to believe Cloud might be doing something really stupid and then it turns out no, actually, he's got things under control this time.
Granted it is kind of difficult to think of how it'd work out, so maybe it's not a viable idea anyway. But to me Cloud's stance on the cult would depend a lot on what they're doing on the surface. While I don't think he'd ever be a dyed-in-the-wool convert or whatever you call it, I can't see him being all gung ho about stopping it unless it was an established threat. He does idealize Aerith himself, and I think he'd understand others doing it especially after everything that's happened. He'd probably be uncomfortable with how far it goes since he did actually know her, but unless they're supposed to be obviously dark from the beginning (in which case why is Elmyra getting taken in by them??? She's a fairly smart lady) I think trying to check it out more closely makes sense for him. Or maybe just leaving it alone (until the harmless facade comes off, that is).
I should probably put this up in some other thread but anyway... Life, death and the Lifestream. Exactly how do they relate to Vincent? It's easy to say that he's immortal and can't die, but what does that mean when dieing really means: "becoming one with the Lifestream"? Not being able to die then means: "being unable to join the Lifestream", which is what Sephiroth wants to do. From what we've seen, ghosts are people who don't want to join the Lifestream just yet. I don't know how you would work this in, but it would be an interesting point for someone to bring up.
That would be interesting too. I suppose that the only thing that I wouldn't want to see from Rufus is becoming purely a good guy (Which I'm kind of worried about). He's an interesting character because he seems to have taken on this middle ground where he might be helping, but not for clear cut "good" reasons. He's more complex than that. Not purely good or bad in his intentions.
I think that I still have an issue with the fact that his friends would automatically assume such a thing of him because this would indicate that his friends don't trust him and that he's apparently back to keeping things to himself. Given that his big revelation in ACC is that he's not alone and that he doesn't have to suffer in silence anymore, it would seem odd that he's reverted to hiding things again to the point that his friends would believe that of him rather then speaking with them on the topic so that they know his stance.
What I see happening is Cloud going to the Church and finding a cult set up to whoever the people thought cured them and him getting mad that they're dishonoring Aerith's place.