Cowboy Bebop Live-Action Series
- Thread starter X-SOLDIER
- Start date
Makoeyes987
Listen closely, there is meaning in my words.
- AKA
- Smooth Criminal
looneymoon
they/them
- AKA
- Rishi
I still haven't watched it. I've been to busy with things that are lower-risk of feeling like a big waste of time. idk if it's worth bothering now that all the kerfuffle has died down? it seems like it's not even enough of a trainwreck for a laugh.
Makoeyes987
Listen closely, there is meaning in my words.
- AKA
- Smooth Criminal
Unless you get off on watching mediocre live action adaptions of anime that fumble key moments of the source material and add just terrible nonsense on top of it (Vicious and Julia lol), I'm sure you're not missing out on much. 
This isn't like a "so bad it's good" or "so bad it's infamous" show and you suffer through it just to fully understand the psychic damage this thing inflict on others...
It's just sorta there. Ready to eat your time.
This isn't like a "so bad it's good" or "so bad it's infamous" show and you suffer through it just to fully understand the psychic damage this thing inflict on others...
It's just sorta there. Ready to eat your time.
looneymoon
they/them
- AKA
- Rishi
The more I hear about it, the more it sounds like the live action FMA movie
Makoeyes987
Listen closely, there is meaning in my words.
- AKA
- Smooth Criminal
That's actually a good comparison. Mediocre as it tried to mimic the iconic moments of the series while missing the entire point and context of said moments.
Nandemoyasan
Standing guard
- AKA
- Johnny
Funny enough, I had just started re-watching the anime when this news dropped, and was about to come in here and admit that the Live Action thing wasn't quite as good as my initial excitement made me ... I don't know, want it to be?
Then this happened and I said, "Well, Johnny, you went and talked a whole bunch of junk. Better get your fork knife and bib, you got some words to eat."
You guys were right. I re-watched "Asteroid Blues" and "Stray Dog Strut," and came away feeling like "Oh right... this was all drawn by hand, and that's **fucking unreal.**" It's silly at times, but also full of heart and soul and mysticism, none of which are present in the adaptation. Just the silliness and action, and that's about it.
John Cho was delightful as Spike, for sure, but at the same time, ...That's really not who Spike is. Cho is affable, sometimes goofy, and of course can do the kung fu necessary for the role, but...
Spike has a certain deathly calm, mixed in with his whimsy, which you find out almost right away in Ep 1 (of the anime) hides quite a bad temper.
Spike: "You called this 'bell peppers and beef...'"
Jet: "Yeah."
S: "There's no beef in it. So you really wouldn't call it 'bell peppers and beef,' would you?"
J: "Yeah, I would."
S: "...WELL IT'S NOT"
I don't feel like the show captures this "loud-soft-loud" dynamic all that well. Live Action Spike is just too nice.
The rest of the show looks like a very expensive stageplay, intercut with some fairly well-done CGI footage. That's really not very good for a show that apparently cost quite a bit of money to make. It's relegated to the ages, now.
We watched anime because it didn't look cheap and stupid like Disney Cartoons. If you try to skimp, anime fans will know.
And that's what we call, "Learning the lesson the hard way."
So uh, are my words ready yet? ?
Then this happened and I said, "Well, Johnny, you went and talked a whole bunch of junk. Better get your fork knife and bib, you got some words to eat."
You guys were right. I re-watched "Asteroid Blues" and "Stray Dog Strut," and came away feeling like "Oh right... this was all drawn by hand, and that's **fucking unreal.**" It's silly at times, but also full of heart and soul and mysticism, none of which are present in the adaptation. Just the silliness and action, and that's about it.
John Cho was delightful as Spike, for sure, but at the same time, ...That's really not who Spike is. Cho is affable, sometimes goofy, and of course can do the kung fu necessary for the role, but...
Spike has a certain deathly calm, mixed in with his whimsy, which you find out almost right away in Ep 1 (of the anime) hides quite a bad temper.
Spike: "You called this 'bell peppers and beef...'"
Jet: "Yeah."
S: "There's no beef in it. So you really wouldn't call it 'bell peppers and beef,' would you?"
J: "Yeah, I would."
S: "...WELL IT'S NOT"
I don't feel like the show captures this "loud-soft-loud" dynamic all that well. Live Action Spike is just too nice.
The rest of the show looks like a very expensive stageplay, intercut with some fairly well-done CGI footage. That's really not very good for a show that apparently cost quite a bit of money to make. It's relegated to the ages, now.
We watched anime because it didn't look cheap and stupid like Disney Cartoons. If you try to skimp, anime fans will know.
And that's what we call, "Learning the lesson the hard way."
So uh, are my words ready yet? ?
ForceStealer
Double Growth
I'm surprised just because Netflix seems to renew EVERYTHING for a second season, lol
