Ted Lange As Your Bartender said:
Also, in the discussion, consider Garland's human form, not his incarnation as Chaos.
Agreed. Otherwise, take him off the list altogether.
He did beat Sephiroth, you know. Not kill him, but he did beat him.
I would consider it more that they fought until both stopped fighting. More of a standstill than anything.
Which, yes, still means that he's a tough fucker. XD
Mako Eyes said:
Well I'd say Jecht is physically stronger, while Tidus is faster.
Dissidia left me with the feeling that Tidus is the fastest of the heroes period. He not only has that ridiculous performance in the opening FMV, but he was the only one to make a move toward Chaos at the beginning of Shade Impulse before he and the others were telekinetically sat on their asses.
As for my list, I'll do one with the villains in terms of their normal powers and then one with their respective power-ups:
(Normal villain list)
1. Cloud of Darkness - Either a representative or embodiment of the Void. Presumably able to destroy the entire universe if given time, as she was the one "schem[ing] the world's return to the Void" in Dissidia. Probably one of the most powerful entities in existence period
2. Exdeath - Powerful warlock with inherent ability to use the Void. Strong fucker
3. Garland - Presumably extremely powerful given that he defeated summons and Omega. Also known to have some control over the Void
4. Ultimecia - Can freeze moments in time and create powerful living beings out of inanimate objects as well as others' thoughts. Able to bend GFs to her will, and posseses vast magical powers in general
5. Sephiroth - Has an unrivaled will on his world and possesses the powers of JENOVA (shapeshifting, separation and reassembly of body, telekinesis, telepathy, astral projections, ability to phase own physical matter through solid objects, various magical spells and energy projection). Need I say more?
6. Emperor Mateus - Some mysterious mage dude who seems fairly powerful. Like Sephiroth, has a powerful will that allowed him to subvert the natural order of life and death
7. Kuja - Respectable magical ability. Can go toe-to-toe with Eidolons like Bahamut without fear, even taking a blast from him pretty much full-on without suffering more than a small gash
8. Kefka - Able to make Espers his bitches. Impressive magical display
9. Golbez - Decent enough mage
10. Jecht - More or less a normal human
Explanations-
I put Cloud of Darkness first because I tend to think that the villains with a connection to the Void are the most powerful -- and in her case, she's either its representative or an incarnation of it. As such, she's probably also immune to being eaten by it like Exdeath. So that allows her to edge the other two out.
Exdeath over Garland because Exdeath uses energy projection and magic. In terms of their affinity with the Void, who the hell knows who's got the other beat there. Exdeath's the only one we see tapping into it whenever he feels like it, though.
I put Ultimecia above Sephiroth because what we see from her is more impressive to me. In raw magical power, they may be even, but I just feel like Ulti's got him.
I put Mateus above most of the other "mage class" villains because he was able to defy nature with will alone and conquer Heaven and Hell thereby. He outranks Kuja if only because of that, and Kefka if only because he was already emperor, whereas Kefka was a really powerful flunky.
Kuja outranks Kefka because -- though Kefka was able to kill Espers -- this bastard was willing to fight Bahamut and let the dragon get off several shots. Was also able to create creatures out of stagnant Lifestream energy.
(Powered-up villain list; Garland is excluded from this list because his power up is Chaos -- obviously the top contender)
1. Ultimecia - Possessed God-like powers and was absorbing the entire universe into herself, becoming a singular existence
2. Cloud of Darkness and Neo Exdeath - Pretty much the same entity. Ranks up here for the reasons Cloud of Darkness was at the top of the previous list
3. Sephiroth (Advent Children) - Defied his world's Lifestream and bent the spirit of a planet to his will -- and was then going to use it as a cosmic gondola. Presumably possessed all the powers from before, but even more energy. He had become a god-like being (lowercase "g," unlike Ultimecia)
4. Kefka - Like Sephiroth, became a god-like being able to bend his world to his will. Possessed vast magical power
5. Jecht (as Braska's Final Aeon, summoned by Braska) - Able to beat Sin. No more need be said
6. Jecht (as Sin) - Able to scar the surface of a planet in an instant, and presumably split it open given time. Vast magical power
7. Kuja - Decimated the surface of a planet in moments and destroyed a number of large structures in the process. Presumably could have made Alexander his bitch at this point
8. Emperor Mateus - Reasonably powerful demonic/angelic being who ruled both realms of the afterlife
9. Jecht (as Braska's Final Aeon, sans Braska) - A summon
10. Golbez - Decent enough mage
Explanations-
I ranked Ultimecia above the Cloud of Darkness and Neo Exdeath here because we actually saw her destroying the universe, and seemingly at an alarming rate. Furthermore, she wasn't just destroying it -- she was absorbing it and making it all bend to her will.
Even without finishing her goal, she already outclassed the others.
Sephiroth outranks Kefka if only because Sephiroth was known to be able to extend his influence to dominate more planets. As far as we know, Kefka was only able to be the god of one.
Jecht -- as Braska's Final Aeon, and summoned by Braska -- outranks Sin if only because we know he won that fight. He ranks again farther down the list sans Braska because a final aeon's extra power to defeat Sin is provided by its powerful bond with its summoner.
For instance, Anima sans Seymour is powerful. Anima
with Seymour could defeat Sin.
I ranked Kuja over Braska's Final Aeon (sans Braska) because we already know that Kuja should have been able to defeat summons at that point -- he even abandoned his quest for a powerful Eidolon once he realized the power he could gain through Trance.
As for Mateus outranking this version of Jecht, that's more a hunch. It seems like having the power to conquer Heaven or Hell would at least be on par with the power to conquer a single summon.
Finally, Golbez is at the bottom of the list below the regular version of Braska's Final Aeon because Golbez used a summon at one point in FFIV rather than relying on his own power -- so summons are presumably more powerful than him. He was also thwarted by a summoner at that same part of the story, who -- using a summon -- defeated his own and nearly killed him.