Theozilla
Kaiju Member
Check your DMs when you have a minute, Theo.
I think we got some wires crossed here. I DO think the general course of events, as far as locations they go to and the order in which they reach them will go unchanged until probably what would be Disc 2 material, and the key moments that happen there will still happen. Like, Barret will confront Dyne, Nanaki will go see his dad, Dolphins will hopefully be ridden and Rufus' parade will happen in silly fashion. A meteor will probably be summoned and giant kaiju will be unleashed. I just think the bottom level core events and driving forces will change dramatically, especially in regards to Cloud, Sephiroth, and Aerith. Zack being in the main group makes this inevitable lol, and I'm very sure he will be. I think things will get more and more different as the Remake goes, but it's not like they won't go to the Gold Saucer or North Crater. Also genesis will definitely appear, get hype @Roundhouse.
I'll say, another big reason I don't think it'll be a proper retelling of the OG is because of Ever Crisis. It was literally called "Another possibility of a Remake" and seems very 1 to 1. I feel like it exists so new players will be able to appreciate the difference in Remake's story.
I checked my DMs (and replied) Ody.
And I will basically restate my reply here
I have been aware of those data-mines/information (or stuff similar to it) for more than a year now, and they still haven't really changed my opinion/expectations.
Like first off, data-mined stuff isn't guaranteed to be in the final product (the OG and its unused content and text is an example of that).
But even we disregard that factor, none of that is incompatible with what I am (and others) are expecting/arguing. I definitely expect the alive!Zack stuff to play some role in the Remake and have in-game shenanigans going on with him in some plot, and maybe even him interacting with some version of Cloud and the party at some point. But I also expect by the end of the alive!Zack stuff that it will be resolved in a way that is compatible and/or reverts the main narrative back to the essential aspects of the OG story (i.e. stuff like Cloud not being "spoiled" about his identity/past).
Similar to how the games FF Tactics and Dissidia are technically canon to FFVII (and the latter to other FFs) I expect there will be some silly explanation justifying alive!Zack existence and utilization in the Remake (though more directly integrated since it's not a crossover like the aforementioned examples) but keeps the main Remake narrative stuff following the core concepts and plots of the OG.