Disc 1:
1. Melody of recall: Nice piano and violins, which I think successfully does what the song title suggests. 4/5.
2. To the Horizon: Fairly clichéd, almost cringe-worthy, "epic journey" music. 2/5.
3. Into the Labyrinth: Nice flute tune with accompaniment to listen to, fairly average though. 3/5.
4. Duel: Average battle music, no personality. 2.5/5.
5. Victory's Fanfare: Standard FF victory fanfare, nothing extraordinary. 2.5/5.
6. Peaceful Village: Captures the scene well enough, nothing great though. 3/5.
7. Not of this world: Half of this I wouldn't even call a song, interesting alien background sound effects though. 2.5/5.
8. Rain in Forest: No personality. 2/5.
9. The Ancient Life: Nice melody in this one. Good beginning and middle, ends bad. 4/5.
10. The initiation: Forgot what scene(s) this played to, but sounds clichéd. 2.5/5.
11. Mountain valley: JRPG overload, hints of electronic stuff, bleurgh. Doesn't even match the feel of the title. 1/5.
12. Supreme mission: Okay "build-up" music. 3/5.
13. Devided we fall: Lots of potential in this piece, but does little for me otherwise. 3/5.
14. The Emergency: Fairly average "Oh no, something has gone wrong" music. 2.5/5.
15. Onslaught: I think this is pretty good boss battle music. 4/5.
16. The suspicion: Lacks content, but very atmospheric and evocative, which is the kind of thing I'm biased to. 3.5/5.
17. The walkabout: I grind on a level with this music... almost sick of hearing it
. Not bad though, I guess. 3/5.
18. Overcome the Menace: Once again, okay "build-up" music 3/5.
19. Tree of tale: I like this song. Probably ends weak though. 4/5.
20. One More Dance: Has a certain charm to it. 3.5/5.
21. Prelude: Standard FF prelude. Impossible to do wrong, really. 4/5.
Disc 2:
1. Great voyage: meh "epic journey" music. 2.5/5.
2. State of grace: Before looking at the song title, I thought "this is very graceful", so they got that on point. 3/5.
3. The oath: Booooring. It's like really bad movie credits music. 2/5.
4. Snowdrop: Pleasant, but fairly average. 3/5.
5. Joie de vivre: This song grew on me, strangely. One of my favourite tunes on the soundtrack. 4.5/5.
6. Mirage palace: Clichéd ancient egyptian music with orchestral touch. 2.5/5.
7. Sacred Ground: I think this is the summon theme. Doesn't do much for me. 2/5.
8. Amigo De Chocobo: The whistling is funny, but I don't think I can give an honest critique of chocobo music that is in itself not honest.
/5.
9. Antiquities: Spacey electronic giant scientific laboratory labyrinth music, fits the scene. 4/5.
10. The Imperial capital: Fairly clichéd majestic-sounding stuff. Sounds very similar to a tune in SO3, actually, methinks. 2.5/5.
11. Shadow of doubt: There's a nice feel to this song. Evocative, etc. 3.5/5.
12. Mystic Ruins: Decent music. Nothing amazing. 3/5.
13. The Ghostship: I reckon some of these bad songs would have more personality in midi form
. 2/5.
14. Secrets in her eyes: Pretty dull. 2/5.
15. Nothing's in vain: Sounds fitting to the title. Sad music, screechy pleading violins "hey, cheer up!". 3/5.
16. Odyssey: Probably my favourite of the "epic journey" musics so far in this soundtrack. 3.5/5.
17. Force and furious: Another summon theme? *forgets*. Doesn't work for me. 2/5.
18. End is Nigh: Pipe organ music. Don't think I've encountered this yet. Ominous! Nothing great. 2/5.
19. Celestial Battle: Major boss music again, or something. I like it, but not as good as onslaught. 3.5/5.
20. Trimuph of Destiny: Happy ever after music. Slightly more exciting bad movie credits music. 2.5/5.
21. Final Fantasy: Standard FF theme music. Again, hard to make bad. The choir doesn't sit well with me though. 4/5.