I think I figured out why I don't really like Sephiroth.

Cat Rage Room

Great Old One
AKA
Mog
This confusion comes from, IMO, the conflict over what exactly Shinra is. It's suppose to be an electric company but it goes around conquering countries? Why is an electric company making war? Raising armies? If Sephiroth wasn't designed to be a super-solider, and I agree that the game indicates that, why is he put into the army? Because of said beneficial side-effect? Did Shinra decide to alter their aims once they realized what they had in Sephiroth?

The concept of a corporation becoming a global governmental entity (or at least having a big enough hand in politics to function as a government) isn't new in fiction of all mediums. Books, movies, video games (Shadowrun and Blade Runner come to mind for me, personally. Star Wars had some cool examples too) Hell, it's not new in real life either; see some corporations today in third world countries and the East India Company in Great Britain a few hundred years back.

An electric company is making war and raising armies for the same reason why many entities big enough would do so; they want to run shit.
 

Obsidian Fire

Ahk Morn!
AKA
The Engineer
Originally, Shin-Ra used to be the weapon manufacturing company everybody went to. Then they found mako and got into the energy business. And everyone went to them again. Except Wutai. And Cosmo Canyon. And Fort Condor.

If they had created another Sephiroth and helped him learn to care about the people in the company and their ambitions, things could have turned out very differently.
I know you don't like CC, but anyway...

I think this is what SE was trying to show with Project G and Genesis and Angeal. They were developed before Sephiroth was, but they didn't have whatever it was Shin-Ra thought indicated they were Ancients. So Genesis was sent to the mayor of Banora who apparently loved him like a son and Gillian and Angeal were sent there as well where Angeal became good friends with Genesis. So at the very least they had a normal childhood. Then the whole Project G thing comes out and we all know how that ends. To me, the difference between what Sephiroth does and what Angeal and Genesis do is who they take their anger out on. Sephiroth takes it out on the entire world, while Genesis and Angeal take it out on Shin-Ra.
 

Ite

Save your valediction (she/her)
AKA
Ite
Shinra is a fucking mess. It's clear they built Midgar, and how many of the characters were born there? Nobody around remembers a time when the slums were eight different towns. The names have been lost. So it's been around for like fifty to eighty years. But they're still constructing it in Crisis Core? And how old is President Shinra? Did he inherit the company?

But sixteen years ago, according to Cid, they were just a weapons manufacturer, who built weapons for the war. A war that they themselves were fighting to propogate their global conquest? Or was someone else fighting Wutai, and Shinra just gave weapons and power to siphon power from the government. What government? The world outside of Midgar seems like a primitive mess.

And why was Wutai fighting, if not to lash out against the Shinra world order that wanted to assimilate their culture? Who was in charge? What was going on? Does Crisis Core even try to address these questions?

FFVII doesn't make any fucking sense. Why am I a fan of this game?

Back to Sephiroth, though. It's clear throughout the story/stories that the Planet rejects alien Spirit Energy like our bodies reject a sliver. That's why Geo-Stigma exists, and it's probably why the Cetra sealed Jenova instead of killing her, as to not pollute their Lifestream with alien Spirit Energy.

It would stand to reason that if a half-alien dude fell into the stream, the Planet would spit him back out. I totally buy that, it makes sense to me in the context of the science that the game carefully puts forth.

"Absorbing the knowledge of the Ancients" doesn't sound plausible. Can someone explain this to me without just saying the same thing with synonyms, or quoting where it says this in the text? If Sephiroth fell into the Lifestream, bearing in mind that he is half-Jenova, how would he suddenly have access to all of the ancient knowledge encrypted in the dregs of souls? How is this knowledge preserved in the subterranean primordial soup? Is this an ability Jenova has?

And to those that say Jenova's and Sephiroth's goals are different, I always thought that Jenova was basically a Planet-eating monster that feeds on the souls of the dead. Sounds a lot like "absorbing the lifestream to become a god" to me.
 

ForceStealer

Double Growth
Materia works by connecting you to the knowledge of the souls in the Lifestream - most applicably, Cetra's, and you use that knowledge to affect the environment. Materia is crystallized Lifestream, so if you accept that it stands to reason that being submerged in the Lifestream would expose you to a whole boatload of knowledge. Enough to kill or turn normal people into vegetables.
 

Obsidian Fire

Ahk Morn!
AKA
The Engineer
^^Not only that, the reason why some people can't be in SOLDIER is because they don't have enough willpower to remember who they are when they are exposed to all the people/knowledge in the Lifestream. That's why Cloud didn't make SOLDIER and was in a coma when Zack broke them out of the Manor. And that's when Cloud was exposed to just a tiny bit of mako.

Sephiroth falls into the entire Lifestream. Not only does he have enough willpower to remember who he is, but he doesn't get absorbed by the Lifestream. Instead, he starts absorbing the Lifestream itself and all the knowledge with it.

This isn't just limited to Sephiroth either. Cloud and later Tifa both fall into the Lifestream as well. The first time Cloud falls in, he goes into a coma. The second time, both he and Tifa are in the Lifestream together and with some help from Aeirth, Tifa goes into Cloud's mind and helps him remember who he really is.

As a rather interesting note, all of AVALANCHE falls into the Lifestream to fight Sephrioth for the last time. And nothing really happens to them because of it. None of them fall into a coma. None of them go inside eachother's minds. They just... kill Sephiroth. I'm thinking this has to do with the fact that killing Sephiroth is the only thing on their minds so they aren't getting distracted with all the knowledge they're exposed to.
 

Makoeyes987

Listen closely, there is meaning in my words.
AKA
Smooth Criminal
I think this is what SE was trying to show with Project G and Genesis and Angeal. They were developed before Sephiroth was, but they didn't have whatever it was Shin-Ra thought indicated they were Ancients.

It was more like, they didn't manifest any of the theoretical abilities they expected the Cetra to have, and then on top of that, they suffered cellular degeneration. Those two projects were failures because of those two reasons, and Hojo, in his awesomeness discovered the real secret of Jenova, and did the unorthodox method of just injecting a baby with alien DNA right in the womb and voila! A Sephiroth was born.

They failed basically because they didn't do enough shit, and were weak.


To me, the difference between what Sephiroth does and what Angeal and Genesis do is who they take their anger out on. Sephiroth takes it out on the entire world, while Genesis and Angeal take it out on Shin-Ra.

Yeah, there's that. But also the fact the other two just are "monsters" when compared to Sephiroth.


Mr. Ite said:
And how old is President Shinra? Did he inherit the company?

That is one of the few enduring mysteries of FFVII. We don't know how old President Shinra is, but we do know, that the company is a family dynasty. Always held and controlled by a "Shinra" and then passed along to the next.

They've been around for a long time.

But sixteen years ago, according to Cid, they were just a weapons manufacturer, who built weapons for the war. A war that they themselves were fighting to propogate their global conquest? Or was someone else fighting Wutai, and Shinra just gave weapons and power to siphon power from the government. What government? The world outside of Midgar seems like a primitive mess.

Their days as "Shinra Works", a weapon manufacturing company, were way before the Wutai War. Almost 50 years in the past. I'm not sure where you get the number 16 from, but Cid does mention that they were a weapons company. The weapons could've just been developed for self defense or whatever use. We don't know, but one thing for sure, is people always have need for weapons.

It wasn't until the discovery of Mako Energy, they shifted focus from weapons development, to energy production and distribution.

FFVII's world pretty much just seems to be a loose collection of city-states scattered across its vast planet.

And why was Wutai fighting, if not to lash out against the Shinra world order that wanted to assimilate their culture? Who was in charge? What was going on? Does Crisis Core even try to address these questions?

...Yes. That's what I said. Wutai was fighting Shinra because Shinra tried to make inroads into their land, drill for Mako energy, and make them another part of their puppet empire, but Wutai believed that Mako was a sacred energy, and not something that should be used or defiled by their corporate greed. They not only denied Shinra's offer of compensation, they told them never to come back or else face the wrath of Leviathan.

Yuffie's father, Godo Kisaragi, was the leader of Wutai who fought long and bitterly against Shinra and SOLDIER. It's why when Wutai suffered it's final defeat, he became so disillusioned and depressed, and Yuffie became fixated on materia and trying to defeat Shinra on her own. And yes, CC does address this. It was Shinra's use of materia, and basically SOLDIER, that turned the tide against Wutai. Wutai became desperate and even tried terroristic insurgency but even failed there too.

Can someone explain this to me without just saying the same thing with synonyms, or quoting where it says this in the text? If Sephiroth fell into the Lifestream, bearing in mind that he is half-Jenova, how would he suddenly have access to all of the ancient knowledge encrypted in the dregs of souls? How is this knowledge preserved in the subterranean primordial soup? Is this an ability Jenova has?

Jenova is a viral monster with the ability to not just replicate indefinitely, but to also absorb and taken in the memories, thoughts, feelings, and mannerisms of those it uses its mimetic ability on. Remember, that's why Jenova was so perfect at killing the Cetra. It would take in the thoughts, feelings, and memories of its victims, feed them back at them, and use that to get close.

Jenova has the ability to somehow consume, and read memories. What is the basis of Spirit Energy in FFVII (and by default FFIX)? Memories and experience.

It's perfectly plausible that Sephiroth, being a higher form of Jenova if you will, developed an even broader form of Jenova's mimetic ability. He's not just able to mimic and absorb the memories of victims, but even absorb the spirit energy around him and take it within himself in order to increase his power.

On a smaller form, that's what happens when someone uses materia and casts magic. The caster briefly utilizes the condensed knowledge within the materia, to channel/manipulate spirit energy from the planet, and cast magic using the energy.

Sephiroth merely cranked it up to 11, and that's why he was able to use the entire Northern Crater's spirit energy to aid in using the Black Materia and cast "Meteor."

I always thought that Jenova was basically a Planet-eating monster that feeds on the souls of the dead. Sounds a lot like "absorbing the lifestream to become a god" to me.

Jenova never wanted to feed on the souls of the dead. All it wanted to do, according to Ifalna, was infect people with a virus, create monsters, and kill everything. There was never any indication that it was out to absorb the lifestream. It merely was a monster of alien origin. "The Thing" as someone so aptly compared it to. It had no real grandiose design or scheme.
 

Ite

Save your valediction (she/her)
AKA
Ite
Then why was it infecting people and killing them? What was the gain?
 

Makoeyes987

Listen closely, there is meaning in my words.
AKA
Smooth Criminal
Why did the Thing infect and kill people?

Because it's just predisposed to be a malevolent, destructive, and infectious organism. It was born mean, angry, and if it doesn't kill you, it'll make you a monster so you can kill others. All it wants is propagation and destruction. Like any other virus.

Jenova really isn't that deep. It's methods of deceit and predation are very unique, but in the end it's still just a monster.

If anything, Jenova actually resembles the mythical Ethiopian monster called the Crocotta. A hyena like beast that is said to mimic the voice of people, and call out to others by name at night in order to lure them from the village into the dark wilderness of the forest. And once the poor sap is lured far enough away into the dark, they're ripped to shreds and eaten. That's it. Just a very elaborate set up for a simple trap.

Jenova's shapeshifting and mind reading abilities basically are just forms of aggressive biological mimicry that allows it to be a better killer.
 

Max Payne

Banned
AKA
Leon S. Kennedy,Terry Bogard, The Dark Knight, Dacon, John Marston, Teal'c
Why did the Thing infect and kill people?

Because it's just predisposed to be a malevolent, destructive, and infectious organism. It was born mean, angry, and if it doesn't kill you, it'll make you a monster so you can kill others. All it wants is propagation and destruction. Like any other virus.

Jenova really isn't that deep. It's methods of deceit and predation are very unique, but in the end it's still just a monster.

If anything, Jenova actually resembles the mythical Ethiopian monster called the Crocotta. A hyena like beast that is said to mimic the voice of people, and call out to others by name at night in order to lure them from the village into the dark wilderness of the forest. And once the poor sap is lured far enough away into the dark, they're ripped to shreds and eaten. That's it. Just a very elaborate set up for a simple trap.

Seems like a shitty cop out to me. Everything ever does what it does for a reason. To serve some purpose.

Even the monster you mentioned.
 

Makoeyes987

Listen closely, there is meaning in my words.
AKA
Smooth Criminal
Well FFVII never gives any reason to Jenova having some master plan behind its actions against the Cetra. All it did was drive them close to extinction. Sephiroth was the one with the plan and reason for destruction. He focused Jenova's nature to meet his needs. On its own it's just driven by instinct to propagate and destroy things with its abilities. However, it can be controlled and Sephiroth in the end works with it to destroy the planet.
 

Max Payne

Banned
AKA
Leon S. Kennedy,Terry Bogard, The Dark Knight, Dacon, John Marston, Teal'c
Well FFVII never gives any reason to Jenova having some master plan behind its actions against the Cetra. All it did was drive them close to extinction. Sephiroth was the one with the plan and reason for destruction. He focused Jenova's nature to meet his needs. On its own it's just driven by instinct to propagate and destroy things with its abilities. However, it can be controlled and Sephiroth in the end works with it.

Just because we dont know whether or not it had any underlying reasons for doing what it did, doesnt mean there never were any, but that's a different discussion I guess.
 

Ite

Save your valediction (she/her)
AKA
Ite
Viruses have a clear methodology that is similar to parasites. They multiply to survive, to propagate their species. And they feed off a host in order to facilitate this growth. Destruction is a byproduct that the virus doesn't care about, but I would not call it an angry organism.

Which is why, after looking at the textual evidence present in the OG, I determined that Jenova is a parasite that lives on Spirit Energy, which is why her systematic mind-game-wipe-out scheme 2000 years ago is almost identical to Sephiroth's, and probably to the same end. To Sephiroth, absorbing the Lifestream would elevate him to God Status to rule over a barren scratch of rock, with the ability to fly around the universe! To Jenova, it's Tuesday.

Even the Crocatta you mentioned ate its victims.

(mods: we can move this to the headcanon thread if you think we're getting too off topic)
 

Octo

KULT OF KERMITU
AKA
Octo, Octorawk, Clarky Cat, Kissmammal2000
Maybe Jenova just hates fucking treehugging hippies? :monster:
 

OneWingedDemon

NOT AMUSED
I also thought of Jenova as a parasite. A destructive organism that cannot be reasoned with because it is doing what it does in order to survive.
 
Last edited:

Obsidian Fire

Ahk Morn!
AKA
The Engineer
I think this is a case of monster vs. person. A monster does what it does because that is what it does; its existence depends on it. If it didn't do what it did, it would cease to exist. A person has a choice involved; its existence does not depend solely on it. It does what it does because it wants too.

For Jenova, ridding planets across the universe to kill the population of other planets and ride them through the universe is her existence. If she stops, she would cease to exist. This is what the Ancients prevent her from doing by sealing her and causes her to go brain-dead.

For Sephiroth, there is a lot he could have done instead of summoning Meteor and trying to rule the Planet... but that goes into what-ifs...

I think the difference between monster and person is what Angeal's story-arc centers around. When it's revealed he is a product of Project G, he is considered a monster and therefore, anything he does he does not because he chooses to do it, but because that is just what he does. Angeal can't live with that type of existence, he needs a purpose other then mere existence, so he chooses to commit suicide. Ironically he involves Zack in it who didn't ever think Angeal was a monster.
 

Makoeyes987

Listen closely, there is meaning in my words.
AKA
Smooth Criminal
Viruses have a clear methodology that is similar to parasites. They multiply to survive, to propagate their species. And they feed off a host in order to facilitate this growth. Destruction is a byproduct that the virus doesn't care about, but I would not call it an angry organism.

Which is why, after looking at the textual evidence present in the OG, I determined that Jenova is a parasite that lives on Spirit Energy, which is why her systematic mind-game-wipe-out scheme 2000 years ago is almost identical to Sephiroth's, and probably to the same end. To Sephiroth, absorbing the Lifestream would elevate him to God Status to rule over a barren scratch of rock, with the ability to fly around the universe! To Jenova, it's Tuesday.

Even the Crocatta you mentioned ate its victims.

(mods: we can move this to the headcanon thread if you think we're getting too off topic)

Parasitism denotes some form of relationship or exploitation that occurs between the organisms involved. Jenova doesn't exploit or form a sort of harmful long-term bond with any of its victims to further its life. It flat out kills them, or infects them with a virus that makes them a monster.

Viruses and parasites are similar only in the sense that they need a host. But while a parasite means to exploit a host to survive and thrive, viruses only mean to use a host's cells to aid in replication, and by default kill the original cells. A parasite only weakens, or hurts its host over the course of its life, while a virus eventually slashes and burns everything it infects in its quest to self replicate.

Jenova sounds much more like the latter, right?

No where in FFVII does it state Jenova feeds off of spirit energy or Mako. In fact, we don't know what Jenova really eats at all.

I'm not understanding what similarity you see in Jenova's Resident Evil-esque wholesale slaughter of the Cetra where it killed or infected its victims with a monster virus, to Sephiroth's plan to use Jenova's regeneration protocol to carefully manipulate and control a bunch of mind enslaved people to bring him the Black Materia to the Northern Crater as to allow him to slam a giant planetoid into the planet. And when everyone dies in the ensuing impact, he transmogrifies into a god with mastery over every soul around him.

Both of their attacks do involve the mass killing of people, and Sephiroth did his fair share of brutal killing, but for Sephiroth, it was a means to an end. There was an "end game" in clear sight. For Jenova, the only "end" would be where there was nobody left to kill or infect. Jenova, if anything, resembles a sort of biological superweapon run amok.
 

Masamune

Fiat Lux
AKA
Masa
Both of their attacks do involve the mass killing of people, and Sephiroth did his fair share of brutal killing, but for Sephiroth, it was a means to an end. There was an "end game" in clear sight. For Jenova, the only "end" would be where there was nobody left to kill or infect. Jenova, if anything, resembles a sort of biological superweapon run amok.

I've always liked this particular idea. Not that I think they should ever explore Jenova's origin. Some things are best left to the imagination. That, and Squenix would totally botch it.
 

Octo

KULT OF KERMITU
AKA
Octo, Octorawk, Clarky Cat, Kissmammal2000
I've always liked this particular idea. Not that I think they should ever explore Jenova's origin. Some things are best left to the imagination. That, and Squenix would totally botch it.

Yep, I like my abominations as eldritch as possible please. :monster: I dread to think what sucky back story SE could come up with as they are now.
 
Top Bottom