Lord Noctis
Harbinger of Darkness
- AKA
- Caius Ballad
Last edited:
I don't think anyone argued this.. .they just said they were disappointed that Aerith was removed from Cloud's profileI'd like to point out to the silly monkeys who are trying to argue that 'The Japanese dissidia site listed the canon couples blah blah blah bullshit', that this is utterly, completely, undeniably bullshit.
Ryu said:Cait Sith's message is a red herring to soften you up before the left hook. The prediction came out wrong. There was no bright future.
Yes, it is meant that way. However, it's also delivered in the same dramatic fashion as his prediction in the Gold Saucer, which does come true. So, judging from just that, his remark about them "being perfect for each other," is strongly hinted as being correct.
NB said:Yeah, I'm sorry, but I'm not buying that. He brings it up completely out-of-the-blue & t's like he doesn't even notice Tifa. There was no scene resolving their romantic tension. All indications up to & including Advent Children are that he was still very much fixated on Aerith. It was not a "just friends" kind of line.
If we were just looking at the original game, I wouldn't disagree that things looked pretty favorable for Cloud being stuck on Aerith. Even with his subconscious telling Tifa that he'd be so happy to hear that she had liked him from the time they were kids, that could be argued as a red herring.
So, those people who are saying fans are Cloti just because they played CC first ... what percentage of them played KH first, do you think?
Yeah no, sorry, I don't buy that. There is a huge build-up to Cloud's identity, hell it's the driving force of the story. It is a pivotal scene of whcih the intent is revelation. It is the point at which everything about Cloud unwinds and is left open. Tifa (and the gamer) are walking through his fucking mind. We see his fear of failure, his desire to be noticed by Tifa, his secret wishes and tender memories no one can ever know, the importance of the promise by the watertower, etc. This is where the TRUTH about Cloud comes out.Even with his subconscious telling Tifa that he'd be so happy to hear that she had liked him from the time they were kids, that could be argued as a red herring.
The scene where they expressed their feelings under the Highwind not do much for you?Yeah, I'm sorry, but I'm not buying that. He brings it up completely out-of-the-blue & t's like he doesn't even notice Tifa. There was no scene resolving their romantic tension. All indications up to & including Advent Children are that he was still very much fixated on Aerith. It was not a "just friends" kind of line
I like how when one fake Japanese person at a fake Japanese restaurant says CxA is considered canon by almost everyone in Japan and everyone in Japan knows that "sheesh" they peddle that out for years and years. Then when a real Japanese native comes forward and shows EVIDENCE that ZackxAerith is the favored couple and that CloudxTifa is more popular than CxA it doesn't count or it doesn't represent the entire nation.
Really you guys, WTF?
I have no idea what's been talked about.
Context, people.