I need somewhere to write my thoughts so far, so consider this a diary to get it all out, aha. Apologies for the lack of relevance to the current convo.
I’m right before the Reactor 5 mission.
Everything is so perfect.
I now see why they decided to make multiple parts. There’s so much they’re expanding on - AVALANCHE has deep character motivations, where they slowly unveiled as we get to know them. (this shouldn’t be taken for granted - it would’ve been really easy for Square to just give them some self-righteous speeches about their motivations and call it a day. Instead, we see their daily lives, and how their lifestyles and experience inform their ideals. We see their disagreements, their jokes, their triumphs...AVALANCHE feels like real people, where we learn more about them through interaction. Not cliched info dumps.
The dialogue between everyone is so charismatic, too. By this point in the game, it honestly felt like I was hanging out with good friends. The scenes after the parachuting segment are gold. (And anytime Barret’s on screen, he steals the show IMO)
Cloud’s cold shoulder to AVALANCHE slowly melting away the more he spends time with them, the little ways he shows his vulnerability to Tifa...the progression of Cloud’s mood is just as perfect and well done as AVALANCHE’s development. It all feels so natural! Cloud’s becoming a part of the slums community as he helps the townsfolk.
At first, I was shocked they moved some of the plot twists / reveals so early (learning Cloud killed Sephiroth five years ago in the first thirty minutes instead of at the end of disc 2) but the way they’re setting up the plot makes a TON of sense and, I think, makes the plot feel a lot more connected. Before, pre and post Midgar felt a bit disconnected. Now, they’re woven into each other beautifully so far. They even set up Mako poisoning and parachuting into Midgar with segments.
All of the original game moments are in here, our point of view is just “zoomed in” where we get to see everything else that goes into the events on an intimate level.
Also...Sector 7 at night is probably the most beautiful thing I’ve seen in any game, ever.
After putting the game down after a few hours, going back to reality feels like waking up from a vivid dream. It just feels so...real.
P.S. Wedge rewarding you if you beat his score at darts really delighted me. I wasn’t expecting that at all.