Posting about this again cuz I'm nervous and avoiding the news and am hyper focusing on anything else I can do on my phone hahaha oh god. Also I didn't want to keep derailing other threads where this stuff comes up, so I figured I'll put it somewhere more appropriate.
I think one of the types of storytelling I really hate is when... writers insert a lot of hamfisted and/or vague and/or overly drawn out allegory, not in a way to challenge the audience, but as a way to have an intellectual one-up on the audience. It's one of those things where I feel it becomes insulting to the audience. The conversation between reader and writer becomes too one-sided. To me, this type of writing becomes more like a vanity project than an effective exchange of themes and ideas between these parties. Remake's end went too far with giving me this impression, which makes it extremely difficult for me to view it favorably.
I feel like when I hear things like... "well we don't know what the pay off is yet" or "have faith, there's loads of theories that are maybe plausible"... that sort of encompasses my point of why I don't think this kind of approach is good or respectful to the audience, if that makes sense? I dont think theory crafting is inherently bad, or wanna ruin thr fun of anyone who does that sort of thing, but what informs my point above is when the definitions of the rules by which the theories can operate under are... hazy at best, or otherwise can otherwise be explained away with "its just like, a really deep metaphor man." Not referring to anyone here specifically, more speaking to some general things that come up. I am just distracting myself by explaining why I find those kinds of narrative offerings from writers to be... a little tacky, if not downright rude
I was trying to think of a recent example of another writer that does this sort of thing. Then, lying in bed at 3am not being able to sleep due to nerves, it hit me. The Whispers in FF7R kind of remind me of the way the entire plot was written in Darren Aronofsky's "
mother!" I don't think FF7R's writing elicits quite the same response as that movie, where I want to rip my face off when I remember that it exists. It does, however, tickle that same nerve.
Man... I really hate that movie.
But... yeah. I actually just sort of remembered that
mother! exists while browsing some completely unrelated stuff. Then thought, oh god, this same shit has come back to haunt me in the form of hooded Nomura ghosts in my most anticipated media release of the bizarro year that is 2020. The door to Hell House leads to Jeniffer Lawrence being silently upset at Javier Bardem for 2 hours. Except it's Cloud and Tifa's heads in place of theirs.
This is all Darren Aronofsky's fault.