DrakeClawfang
The Wanderer of Time
Doesn't automatically mean they're right about it either.
LTD, round 3: This time, we settle it with Jello Wrestling
- Thread starter Ryushikaze
- Start date
- Status
Doesn't automatically mean they're right about it either.
DrakeClawfang
The Wanderer of Time
Should we tell them there's more than one date scene too?
Madame Mayor
Banned
Actually I recall it used to be "there are 3 highwind scenes!" XPThat's what I mean... and also I find it kind of funny that it took them like 2 months to come up with a response and their response was what it always has been anyway, "There's two highwind scenes!"
Carlie
CltrAltDelicious
- AKA
- Chloe Frazer
That's what I mean... and also I find it kind of funny that it took them like 2 months to come up with a response and their response was what it always has been anyway, "There's two highwind scenes!"
Funny but expected, give them credit they actually came up with something instead of pretend it didn't happened which they do with almost everything Cloti
OneWingedDemon
NOT AMUSED
How does "there's 2 versions" invalidate the fact SE explicitly states Cee & Tee have romantic feelings for each other close to 10 times?
This scene is never treated as optional. How could it? Both versions share the same outcome and are received by their party members the same freakin way. Both times they are teased. Both times, Tifa is deathly embarrassed.
I don't see SE saying "feelings between C/T are dependent on player choice"
They do, however, say that this is the case for the dates. Hell, they say this while they show a picture of Aeris and Cloud going <---- "See this cute pink girl? her date with him means shit, you can have 4 others."
You are given no such option to disregard Cloud's feelings for Tifa.
Also, the affection value is reflective of Tifa's affection, so unless they're saying Tifa rejects Cloud they once again have no leg to stand on.
This scene is never treated as optional. How could it? Both versions share the same outcome and are received by their party members the same freakin way. Both times they are teased. Both times, Tifa is deathly embarrassed.
I don't see SE saying "feelings between C/T are dependent on player choice"
They do, however, say that this is the case for the dates. Hell, they say this while they show a picture of Aeris and Cloud going <---- "See this cute pink girl? her date with him means shit, you can have 4 others."
You are given no such option to disregard Cloud's feelings for Tifa.
Also, the affection value is reflective of Tifa's affection, so unless they're saying Tifa rejects Cloud they once again have no leg to stand on.
Vendel
Banned
It does seem like they discovered the cure for cancer over there. Instead of something everyone should have known all along.
I do wonder at the logic behind "there are two versions of this scene thus nothing is canon". When the scene in question is being used on a page for romantic love. They even go into detail about the scene with 'high affection'.
Is that working backwards or sideways? I don't even know anymore.
Madame Mayor
Banned
You can bet that'll be on the way soon. Tifa doesn't love Cloud, as stupid as that sounds, has been one of their arguments too.
Vendel
Banned
Yeah. Aerith and Zack were never serious. He probably cheated on her. After he disappeared she completely got over him. Then she fell madly and truly in love with Cloud. The real Cloud. Even though she never met him.
While Cloud and Tifa never even knew each other as kids. She bullied and excluded him. Even so Cloud kind of liked her a bit. After Cloud told her he was going to become a SOLDIER she fell in love with this ideal version of Cloud. Who so happens to be Zack. Tifa does get jealous of Aerith because she (and everyone else) can see Aerith and Cloud are lovers. By the Highwind scene Tifa stops projecting her love for Zack on Cloud and they realize they are just friends. For real this time. She knows he loves Aerith and she loves Zack. After this Tifa adopts Cloud as her son.
There you have it. The true story of FFVII.
Last edited:
Ryushikaze
Deus Admiral Parsimonious, PHD, DDS, MD, JD, OBE
- AKA
- Tim, Ryu
Yes. Constantly. Because they're trying to say Aerith's date is canon despite the other three and the other three being just as recognized as hers.
Yep. It took Quex to prove to Anastar there weren't.
Though they came up with something so they can pretend it MEANS nothing.
They could, but then they'd be contradicting their argument where she tries to love him but becomes his mother instead. But they might make it. Like I said, they're that desperate.
Remember their standard- Remotest POSSIBILITY for pink? That's the ZOMFGtruth. Remotest possibility something meaning C/T romance didn't happen/ didn't mean that? Well, it didn't happen, then.
It's a desperate logic that winds up biting them in the ass anyways.
It's working in panic.
That is an accurate description of the pink view of FF7, though 'Even so Cloud liked her a bit', which not all of them like to admit.
And remember folks, the pink view and the Clerith view are not the same thing. The latter, while incorrect, is still FAR saner.
OneWingedDemon
NOT AMUSED
Well, almost for real, because by CoT, Tifa, like an addict, goes back to wanting Cloud to sex her up. She asks him if he loves her (where did she get that idea? How many times must a man reject a woman? For the love of God), and Cloud once again makes it clear that he's not interested in big-boobed women.
After this, Tifa FINALLY gets it, and then goes back to being his mother, who may occassionally have fantasies of getting in on with her adopted son, but that's ok -- she's tragic like that.
The end.
Raquelborn
"I slice your ass in 4."
- AKA
- Raq, Raquel.
Dashell
SMILE!
- AKA
- Sonique, Quexinos, Pinkie Pie, Derpy Hooves
haven't you been paying attention?
This thing:
says only Tifa is embarrassed so there was no sex, cuddling, hugging or anything.
This thing:
That disproves Cloti for some reason that I'm no clear on... that we translated the same day as The One That I Love that we didn't know about even though we translated it... oh no wait we were hiding it because of... some... thing...
says only Tifa is embarrassed so there was no sex, cuddling, hugging or anything.
Dashell
SMILE!
- AKA
- Sonique, Quexinos, Pinkie Pie, Derpy Hooves
oh and I forgot to tell you all that Nojima considers Maiden canon
http://www.gamespot.com/pages/unions/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26350611&union_id=949
Actually I would like to know where he got that. Anyone know if Japanese fans consider it non canon as well?
Oh NM his blog:
http://www.gamespot.com/users/C-Himura/
He just lost all credibility XD
http://www.gamespot.com/pages/unions/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26350611&union_id=949
Actually I would like to know where he got that. Anyone know if Japanese fans consider it non canon as well?
Oh NM his blog:
http://www.gamespot.com/users/C-Himura/
He just lost all credibility XD
Last edited:
Celes Chere
Banned
- AKA
- Noctis
The Twilight Mexican
Ex-SeeD-ingly good
- AKA
- TresDias
For real. Maiden only makes a Clerith outcome less likely.
- Status