On the IRC versus the spam section comment, iirc, we did try sort of a spam section, but it didn't catch and we quit the experiment after a few weeks. Same with social groups, I believe. The IRC, on the other hand, is - at least in my opinion, but as stated before I'm biased - a success, with a lot of activity coming from there.
Let me also remind you that our front page's activity has been booming thanks to the IRC. People like Lex, Fangu, Shademp, Ryu and Flintlock - three of which mainly got an interest in TLS via the IRC, iirc - are currently the primary front page posters and the incentive for a lot of community activities. And let me remind you, that is what this site is for - not petty discussions about cliques and whatnot. IRC is what makes these people come together and discuss things, and based on that fact, and the fact that the front page is pretty damn important, I'm not going to take any action when it comes to the IRC.
On thanks, if it really means that much to people, then, like postcounts, I have no problems with just disabling it. As discussed probably countless times before, thanks should mean nothing, but obviously, they do, and far too much than they should. Alternatively, I can rename "thanks" to "Circlejerk", if that makes it more appropriate to what some people think of it,
.
On popularity, stop trying to measure your own popularity or that of others, this isn't high school, everyone's just a TLS member that should be treated like a normal person and an opinion that should be respected.
On cliques and alienation: You can't force people to like each other, simple facts. You can't stop cliques and groups of friends from forming either; it's impossible to force everyone to like each other, and impossible to stop people from talking to each other outside of the forums. I don't see that as a goal in itself either. At the very least, I expect everyone to be courteous and respectful of each other, and perhaps come to realize the fact that we're growing beyond a hardened group of internets veterans that make fun of everything; think of the new people, etc. Someone mentioned and compared TLS to LOCP and FG, but TLS is neither of those; our front page makes us a publically facing website that draws in fans from all over, and a couple of people being dicks because "That's just how it is here" is not appropriate for that kind of community.
On mods being out of line, please do report it; that way the rest of the staff can frown upon his person and, if anything, it sends off a message that staff should watch their own posts. On the other hand, I've always said - and will continue to do so - that staff are just regular members with powers; they shouldn't get special treatment, but shouldn't be scrutinized more than regular members either. If that doesn't work, there's always a PM directed at me, Mako, or X. If it's Mako or X that's being a problem, there's me. If it's me that's a problem, you'll probably need to bring a couple of rakes and pitchforks and oust me by buying me out of the site, I guess,
.
On not being a dick: If you can't not be a dick, then you are a dick and should gtfo.
On the chatbox, it was more of a shittily-written guestbook kinda thing than a chatbox, but okay
. I like the IRC though, more than a box hidden somewhere at the bottom of the page, and now we've got a fancy /chat page with a browser client, it's quite nicely integrated with the rest of the site, I think. If people want a chat, I'd propose integrating /chat onto the forums homepage in one form or another - although tbh, it would be a bit of a performance hog for front page opening, and I'd much prefer it to remain a separate page.
On all this, I don't understand how an insult and some heated responses to that turned into a two-day tl;dr poastfest where two dozen people or however much there are feel like they should have a say in this. Or well, not anymore; I'm sure some of you remember I was quite engaged in the dramas of TLS back in the day (in fact, I'm pretty sure it was my primary reason for poasting for a long time). But I've grown old and my time has become sparse, so I can't relate with all of this drama anymore,
. Not trying to dismiss everyone's grievances, but... does it really have to be this long?
Finally, if there's any more serious issues that need to be addressed, please state them in as short a fashion as possible and the expected course of action. It's kinda hard to try and filter out what the real problems are and even harder to figure out what the desired course of action would be. So yeah: focus on solutions, not problems, the latter is easy to divulge in but hardly constructive, imho.
Also, I don't like how you guys always do this kinda stuff outside of the ~4 hour window I have to deal with this kinda stuff a day, or weekends,
.