Definitive and Absolute Power Tier List.

ForceStealer

Double Growth
It would also be a spectacularly boring fight.

*Imagines Sephiroth hanging just out of reach as Cloud repeatedly tries to jump for him*
 

The Twilight Mexican

Ex-SeeD-ingly good
AKA
TresDias
Ted Lange As Your Bartender said:
Looking back from whatever corner of hell that he's currently residing in, Sephiroth could have won against Cloud under a different set of circumstances. Maybe he should have done something else with his swordsmanship, magic, NL, or whatever. It's not like we're saying that Sephiroth couldn't have won no matter what. But he didn't. He lost. Just because he could have won doing something else doesn't mean he held back. That just means he lost, period.

+ is a dumbass.

I'm singling you out Tres, cause your post is the larger target :monster:

Come and get me, bitch! :monster:

I'll limit myself to give you a sporting chance. :awesome:

Mako said:
Okay fair enough. Apparently we were using a different definition.

Coo.

Mako said:
What?

A stab to the chest is a kill shot. If you run a person through with a sword straight through the chest, they're going to die right there. It's only thanks to Cloud's tenacity and drive to live that he didn't fall down dead on the spot. Especially after getting stabbed there again, and then sliced to ribbons.

No way is an impalement through the chest not a kill shot.

Seph and Cloud have something of a history where this is concerned, though. Seph knows that impaling Cloud is not a kill shot -- which it isn't on most people, really, because it's not instantaneous death. Aerith didn't even die instantly.

Even where death follows within seconds, it's not quite on the same level as running a blade through the brain.

Mako said:
He definitely lucked out. He had been moving while being skewered so either Cloud moved in time (accidentally or purposefully) or yeah, it was intentional. But the fact is, Sephiroth went for the face and nearly hit it.

I disagree that he went for the face. Seph wouldn't have killed him without making that "What do you cherish most?" line first.

Mako said:
I'm not buying this phasing ability because it's never ever used except for dramatic purposes. He's not Shadowcat. Jenova works by creating illusions and toying with people's heads. It's highly likely that the way Jenova appears an disappears is all thanks to its ability to cast illusions and make the opponent see what they want to see.

Maybe, but it's never been indicated. Seems easier to just go with what was shown to us.

Hell, on one occasion in the Temple of the Ancients, Seph's figure floats down behind Cloud and the others without anyone seeing it.

Mako said:
Sephiroth was playing for keeps in the end too, ya know.

Then he'd have killed them while they were still immobile in front of him, yes?

Mako said:
Again, that's all illusion.

You see Sephiroth literally split himself in two while speaking to Tseng, with one figure stabbing Tseng, and another one monologuing and then flying away out of the room.

Looked like the same one that stabbed him was doing the monologuing to me. In any case, Seph entered the room when he wasn't there before -- and it was shown from the perspective of the Temple spirits rather than Tseng.

This is either teleportation or phasing through -- so the overall function remains the same. Since we see the figure seemingly float in from nowhere, I'd call it phasing.

Mako said:
Yet they were more than willing to use it again in DC.

Vince did. Don't think the others did, though.

And Vince is the guy who Nojima said would have probably walked away from Bahamut Sin if his old comrades weren't fighting it.

Mako said:
I doubt that it would be that significant, especially given the fact that it would help save the planet against a greater threat. Not only that, but I'm dubious of that sudden assertion in the first place. The materia section in the CC Complete Guide may shed some light on it.

Will be interested in seeing it.

And it's not really that sudden an assertion. The energy has to come from somewhere. It's always been said that using materia allows someone to use the planet's energy:

FFVII said:
"Anyone with this knowledge can freely use the powers of the Land and the Planet. That knowledge interacts between ourselves and the planet calling up magic..... or so they say."

Mako said:
I suppose the conflict lies in why we think he did. I believe he only used the sword because he didn't have to and he was fully capable of killing him easily with the sword alone.

I think it's that plus ego-stroking. Or, more to the point, that because of ego-stroking.

Mako said:
The fact the CC Complete Guide refers to the wing as a comparative symbol of power regarding Genesis Copies/G Type SOLDIERs is pretty telling as well. It's not just superfluous.

I agree, but I don't think it means we have a Limit Break at work. Unless Hollander has the shittiest Limit Break we've ever seen.

Mako said:
Sephiroth is very godlike.

But not at all God-like.

Mako said:
We're never told anything about Sephiroth having to exert concentration or effort to hold back Holy.

We are shown that he needed energy beyond himself to cast its opposite, though.

Mako said:
If anything, we're shown he does it quite easily, to the point that Holy didn't move an inch even when his physical body was destroyed.

True enough -- but the fact that he cared enough about Holy to say "We must stop that girl" soon tells me Holy was a problem for him. As does the fact that doing things usually requires effort. XD


At least we agreed on most of this. Fun debate.
 
Last edited:

Makoeyes987

Listen closely, there is meaning in my words.
AKA
Smooth Criminal
Come and get me, bitch! :monster:

I'll limit myself to give you a sporting chance. :awesome:

Roffl. XD


Seph and Cloud have something of a history where this is concerned, though. Seph knows that impaling Cloud is not a kill shot -- which it isn't on most people, really, because it's not instantaneous death. Aerith didn't even die instantly.

Sephiroth did impale him twice, while also cutting him to pieces. So it's not like he did the same thing. He knew more force and effort was required. But honestly. Cloud is still human. With human insides. If you impale someone in the chest you're gonna hit something vital. There's the heart, lungs, spine, aorta. All of that. You get impaled through the chest and you've only got a few seconds before dying.

As for Aerith, it was more in the mid-section, and anyways, she didn't linger very long either. She died right on the spot. Her eyes widened and then she was gone.

Even where death follows within seconds, it's not quite on the same level as running a blade through the brain.

The difference is pretty negligible, man. Cloud's a human. Not a zombie! It's not like a head shot is the only way to kill him.



I disagree that he went for the face. Seph wouldn't have killed him without making that "What do you cherish most?" line first.

...What? Are you really telling me Sephiroth had the whole moment rehearsed down to the timing of when he'd say what and when he'd do the killing?

Sephiroth is vindictive and a plotter, but that's just ridiculous. He's not Kuja-level in terms of his absurdity. And he's not Naraku either. That's kinda silly. He didn't have the entire fight played out down to the very bit of dialogue he'd say.

Sephiroth: Is this...the pain you felt before, Cloud?
Cloud: ......
Sephiroth: Cloud? CLOUD?! Don't you dare fucking die now! I haven't finished this!!! WAKE UP!!! *shakes him and then heals him*
Cloud: What....?
Sephiroth: As I was saying...is this...the pain you felt before, Cloud? STAY AWAKE!
Cloud: ....Oh jeez...

:monster:

Maybe, but it's never been indicated. Seems easier to just go with what was shown to us.

Hell, on one occasion in the Temple of the Ancients, Seph's figure floats down behind Cloud and the others without anyone seeing it.

Which is highly indicative of Sephiroth/Jenova being able to project illusions. You don't think Sephiroth/Jenova can make shadow clones, do you? All of that is illusion. Just like how Sephiroth recreated the Nibelheim inferno in the Northern Crater for Cloud. Just like how Cloud suddenly appeared out of nowhere in the Materia Cave in the Northern Crater to give Sephiroth the Black Materia. That's not teleportation. That's all illusionary shit. Sephiroth and Jenova can't phase through crap or split themselves in two any more than Cloud can just suddenly appear out of nowhere.



Then he'd have killed them while they were still immobile in front of him, yes?

Perhaps that was intent had they not struggled and resisted his will. They were in considerable pain as well. I highly doubt that it was just a harmless attack.



Looked like the same one that stabbed him was doing the monologuing to me. In any case, Seph entered the room when he wasn't there before -- and it was shown from the perspective of the Temple spirits rather than Tseng.

This is either teleportation or phasing through -- so the overall function remains the same. Since we see the figure seemingly float in from nowhere, I'd call it phasing.

...You don't think he was just hidden in the room? We don't even see Sephiroth pass through anything. He just swoops down from above. He could've been levitating towards the ceiling. He could've hidden his appearance. Which is definitely in step with all the other abilities he's shown, such as the whole illusionary mind fuck in the Northern Crater.



Vince did. Don't think the others did, though.

And Vince is the guy who Nojima said would have probably walked away from Bahamut Sin if his old comrades weren't fighting it.

Still is a contradiction though. Nomura was referring to the group never using materia again and sure enough, one of them did. And Yuffie used materia as well. There are two materia orbs in Yuffie's shuriken when she hurls it at Rosso to save Vincent with her Flash spell.



And it's not really that sudden an assertion. The energy has to come from somewhere. It's always been said that using materia allows someone to use the planet's energy

Fair enough.



I think it's that plus ego-stroking. Or, more to the point, that because of ego-stroking.

Well that's likely, yeah.



I agree, but I don't think it means we have a Limit Break at work. Unless Hollander has the shittiest Limit Break we've ever seen.

Limit Break, Overdrive, Hyper Mode, you know what I mean. :monster: I'd say its indicative of a heightened state with his abilities and powers greater than his normal form. Just like in FFVII, Dissidia, etc. It's the literal "One Winged Angel" trope in action.



But not at all God-like.



We are shown that he needed energy beyond himself to cast its opposite, though.

Well that's cause he's casting a spell. He needs the energy to manifest and cast the spell. But his will alone is enough to subjugate and control the actual order of existence. His will. His desire and thought is enough to change the actual coarse of the planet and stop the ultimate white magic spell.



True enough -- but the fact that he cared enough about Holy to say "We must stop that girl" soon tells me Holy was a problem for him. As does the fact that doing things usually requires effort. XD

Well he doesn't want any unnecessary interruptions, and Sephiroth probably had no idea how strong Holy would be.

And doing things requires effort yes, but it does not take much effort at all to have a desire. If you were Sephiroth, and your will was for a car not to move, then the car wouldn't move. That would be the end of it. Holy didn't even hicup when Sephiroth was killed. Because his will, his desire, did not change. It wasn't until his very spirit was scattered to the winds that his will-hold over Holy finally let go.


At least we agreed on most of this. Fun debate.

Agreed :monster:
 

OWA-2

Pro Adventurer
because you know that by "holding back" everyone means "not using his most powerful and deadliest attacks, nor attempting to use more than one offensive skill/ability at a time.


But some people in this forum don't know that. This is why everytime someone say he was "holding back" we have a stupid semantic-war.
 

Tetsujin

he/they
AKA
Tets
I disagree that he went for the face. Seph wouldn't have killed him without making that "What do you cherish most?" line first.

I'd go so far as to say that he wouldn't have killed him before taking away everything he cherished. :monster:
Seriously, if you're out for revenge as much as Sephiroth, you're not just gonna kill your opponent immediately. You make them suffer. :monster:
 

ForceStealer

Double Growth
OWA-2 said:
But some people in this forum don't know that. This is why everytime someone say he was "holding back" we have a stupid semantic-war.

No one made you participate.


And you're right Tets, but that's AFTER he defeated him that he toyed with him, not before.
 

ForceStealer

Double Growth
You say that as though any other kind of war we could have on the subject would be necessary. But on the level that I enjoy discussing with the people here, yes. I'd prefer FF7 semantics to the discussions that normally go on forever. (LTD, staff are nazis, etc.)

And more was discussed than just semantics anyway. Magic, Materia, Vincent and Genesis got involved. Jokes were made, no degenerate name calling. This is by no means that tiresome a thread.
 

Ryushikaze

Deus Admiral Parsimonious, PHD, DDS, MD, JD, OBE
AKA
Tim, Ryu
Remember everyone, Sephypoo wanted Cloud dead, but he also wanted him to know despair. He wanted the boy to die 'slow-like' so he could savor the moment. Excessive force towards that end isn't 'more efficient' it's 'overkill'

Yes, there's crap Sephy could have done better, but I don't think Cloud was in top form either, even sans materia. He's doing better sans Geostigma, but he's not at 100% yet either. Certainly, it seems to be taking more effort than admittedly what little we see of him in DoC.
 

OWA-2

Pro Adventurer
You say that as though any other kind of war we could have on the subject would be necessary. But on the level that I enjoy discussing with the people here, yes. I'd prefer FF7 semantics to the discussions that normally go on forever. (LTD, staff are nazis, etc.)

And more was discussed than just semantics anyway. Magic, Materia, Vincent and Genesis got involved. Jokes were made, no degenerate name calling. This is by no means that tiresome a thread.

I'm not saying this discussion is bad, or that there aren't worst subjects to talk about. I'm just saying it's a waste of time arguing over semantics. There is a moment when you realize that everyone is saying the exact same thing, but they are too fixed in specific words to realize that their meaning is the same, and they are all agreeing with each other(without even noticing it).
 
Last edited:

Deus

Banned
So...does anyone actually think Cloud could take a citybusting attack? Honestly?

Because seriously if they are, you need to put Cloud at the top of the hero list in a leageu of his own. Well him and Zidane by powerscaling.
 

ForceStealer

Double Growth
It is kinda tough to say due to what Ted was saying. Since big powerful magic attacks are impersonal, they will rarely kill a main character (hero or villain) as it would be less satisfying to the viewer/player.

An honest-to-goodness city-busting attack would kill any of the FF heroes I would imagine. ...But they all can use magic meaning they could all likely erect some kind of barrier.
 

Makoeyes987

Listen closely, there is meaning in my words.
AKA
Smooth Criminal
I think the fact Cloud can just cut through Bahamut Tremor's Tremor Flare without any serious injury answers that question.
 

Cat Rage Room

Great Old One
AKA
Mog
A. It never destroyed a city.
B. Cloud needed the help of his friends.

A. Because they didn't let it
B. He needed the help of his friends to beat it, but he didn't need the help of his friends to endure a citybusting attack, just like you asked.
 

Makoeyes987

Listen closely, there is meaning in my words.
AKA
Smooth Criminal
The City of Edge would've been blown to hell had the attack landed.

And yeah. Cloud's friends helped him reach Bahamut, not endure the blast or cut Bahamut in half.
 

Deus

Banned
A. Because they didn't let it
And you have a canon statement stating it can destroy a city?
Because if it didn't then that's the only other evidence you could use to suggest it can.

B. He needed the help of his friends to beat it, but he didn't need the help of his friends to endure a citybusting attack, just like you asked.


Um...what? How does being launched continuously by superhumans and peak humans NOT add to your force? He gained all hs momentum from his friends.
 

Makoeyes987

Listen closely, there is meaning in my words.
AKA
Smooth Criminal
And you have a canon statement stating it can destroy a city?
Because if it didn't then that's the only other evidence you could use to suggest it can.

Why the hell would they be worried then about Bahamut Tremor charging its Terra Flare to the max, and then fearful when he lets it loose on the city? The size of the blast alone would've rendered Edge a crater, especially by seeing how its weakest flare left the Edge monument rubble.



Um...what? How does being launched continuously by superhumans and peak humans NOT add to your force? He gained all hs momentum from his friends.

His force is irrelevant. He endured the attack and chopped it away, and then used Climhazzard on Bahamut. If the blast is strong enough to incinerate and demolish solid stone and iron, a human's momentum wouldn't mean shit. They'd still get burned up. But Cloud wasn't even singed.
 

Deus

Banned
Why the hell would they be worried then about Bahamut Tremor charging its Terra Flare to the max, and then fearful when he lets it loose on the city?

Wow. Talk about a fallacious mess.
For one, you're arguing the characters are always right when they have absolutely no way of knowing its power. They are fallible.
If that wasn't bad enough, you're arguing your own interpretation of that fear. They coudl easily have been afraid because the attack would destroy a few cityblocks and kill a few hundred people. I'm sure that should worry them.

None of what you said can be proven - it's just what a few people think.

The size of the blast alone would've rendered Edge a crater,

Please calculate the size of the blast in relation to the size of Edge to confirm this statement.

especially by seeing how its weakest flare left the Edge monument rubble.

Baseless conclusion. You have no idea how many times stronger than its "weakest attack" its strongest attack is. 10 times? Fifty times?
So saying its weakest attack destroying less than a half-cityblock means its strongest attack is completely illogical.

His force is irrelevant. He endured the attack and chopped it away, and then used Climhazzard on Bahamut. If the blast is strong enough to incinerate and demolish solid stone and iron, a human's momentum wouldn't mean shit. They'd still get burned up. But Cloud wasn't even singed.

Probably because Cloud isn't a normal human and has endured attacks that destroy stone and concrete before.
 

Ryushikaze

Deus Admiral Parsimonious, PHD, DDS, MD, JD, OBE
AKA
Tim, Ryu
A 'mini' flare, roughly the size of a person, was enough to gouge massive chunks in an entire city block's worth of pavement, and destroy a building. The full blast version was aimed at that same spot in order to gouge out more of it- a full blast that was at least as big as a city block if not more.

And Cloud's additional momentum actually makes his surviving the flare more impressive.
He's hitting the flare AT SPEED, and punching through unscathed.
 

Deus

Banned
Here I thought momentum helped you get through things, not made it harder.

And a cityblock buster is fine. A citybuster is a whole different ball game and I won't believe it until there is solid proof.
 

Cat Rage Room

Great Old One
AKA
Mog
I WAS ACTUALLY PLAYING FF7 LAUGHING AT THE DUDE DOING THE PEE PEE DANCE IN WALL MARKET WITH MY SISTER

I'M BACK IN HERE JUST FOR YOU, MAKO

JUST FOR YOU


Here I thought momentum helped you get through things, not made it harder.

Alright. Next time you get a chance, dive out of a car full speed into a brick wall. That's a quick way to test that theory.

And a cityblock buster is fine. A citybuster is a whole different ball game and I won't believe it until there is solid proof.

Why not reasonable speculation? Do you need creator commentary to speculate?
 

Deus

Banned
Alright. Next time you get a chance, dive out of a car full speed into a brick wall. That's a quick way to test that theory.
You're comparing a brick wall to a giant blast of magical energy?


Why not reasonable speculation? Do you need creator commentary to speculate?
Speculation is fine. But that's all it is. You cannot say Cloud has citybusting durability as a fact based on just some rather flimsy speculation.
 
Top Bottom