Jairus
Author of FFVII: Lifestream & FFVII: Reflections
That's all anyone has played yet.
Until then, complaining about how people talk about something they have experienced rather than something they haven't is asinine.
But we've seen a fair bit of the remake and have at least some idea of what to expect.
Don't evade the question. Would you expect people to discuss the Shin-Ra Manager dude as much as they discuss Cid, yes or no?
Actually, SE said he was another character who was being expanded. But basically, if there were people who liked him enough, sure. You're still differentiating between characters like Jessie who have a fairly significant role in Part 1 and those like the SM who aren't likely to have as much of an impact. There's a difference.
Says who?
Common sense. When characters are given more attention and development than they once had, naturally they should be thought of more than they used to be.
It doesn't, but you're the only one who keeps saying what people should do.
Should is not the same as is. I'm allowed to have an opinion, aren't I?
Just because the Remake is not the OG, doesn't mean all characterization, experience, framed expectation or narrative knowledge goes out the window.
It came first, and is the baseline of everything going on here.
Sure. Maybe it will be different in comparison to the OG's depiction of Jessie's death, how it's handled, or how her character is handled in the Remake. Sure, they're going to develop.
But that hasn't happened yet. How can it reflect something not yet depicted?
The game hasn't been released, dude. Ergo, you cannot expect this sudden shift in perception or whatever. That literally makes no sense. Jessie is a tertiary character. Jessie's death was not as weighty as Aerith's. Fact. That's how it's been for 20 plus years. Now again. Maybe the Remake will change that, but stop expecting people somehow adhere to this equivalency of Aerith!Death = Jessie!Death. Because that's not true. Like, I don't understand how you can suddenly be clapping at people over that. It's unreal.
It'd be like me getting extremely upset over Rosso the Crimson not being shown up in the Remake. Because hey. She's a SOLDIER, goddamnit. A Deepground SOLDIER, and she was just as important and significant. She fought with Cloud too and didn't die. So clearly she's legitimate. And you know, she has the potential to be fleshed out and given more backstory. Maybe she could etc etc etc etc blah blah blinding bias statements here
Like. Seriously, tone it down.
You forget, we've seen enough of the remake to get at least some idea of what to expect. Plus the fact that SE's deliberately done everything they can to make her likeable and get us attached to her, all while we all know what her ultimate fate is, if not the specifics of how. She's not tertiary anymore, she's secondary, like the rest of the trio. It's not like the OG. And her death is likely to be the big emotional blow of Part 1, especially if SE does it as well as I think they can. And thus, its weight in Part 1 could become just as much as Aerith's was in the OG as far as the effect it may have on people. So there's enough there for people to draw the conclusion that the trio's ends in the remake will be as emotional and impactful as SE can possibly make them. Thus, allowing the thought and acknowledgement that Aerith isn't the only one who dies in the story and that her death won't be the only one that's important or impactful.