Serah?
(But again, whatever 'seeing Serah happy' means... Serah seemed to be quite happy about saving the world and shit)
Didn't they say that the Unseen World was the land of the dead? If Chaos entered into Pulse, merging both the Seen and the Unseen, doesn't that mean that the dead are not... dead?
Hope said:MOM!
And there's the fact that Valhalla is not really the Unseen World, it's a "border" between the Unseen and the Visible world.
And there's the fact that Valhalla is not really the Unseen World, it's a "border" between the Unseen and the Visible world.
The Goddess Etro
In the ancient annals of Gran Pulse, Etro appears as the goddess of death and chaos. She is said to reside in the world where the souls of the dead find their rest—Valhalla.
Valhalla
Valhalla is an otherworldly dimension, also known as the Unseen Realm. According to Pulse legend, it is the final resting place of the souls of the dead, and the chaotic world where the goddess Etro makes her home.
Unseen Chaos
The chaos of the Unseen Realm is a malevolent energy that seep through into the world of mortals. The existence-defying darkness witnessed by Lightning is an immense and inexorable force, a creeping doom that she is not even certain acts with a unified purpose or will.
Where the chaos of Valhalla leaks into the mortal realm, the laws of the physical world are undone. This paradoxical energy seeks to return all existence to the Unseen Realm, but at times it seems to show an almost affection for those who share an affinity with chaos.
Etro's gate
The instant Etro's Gate opened, a world-devouring darkness slipped through from Valhalla. The goddess turned back the river of time and that terrible darkness—the Unseen chaos—was sealed away.
Her power exhausted, Etro fell into a sleep from which she would never awaken. It was Lightning who sensed that someone meant to exploit that weakness and destroy the goddess for good. She learned of the man named Caius Ballad.
If the goddess is destroyed, the chaos of the Unseen Realm would be unleashed, and the mortal realm devoured by Valhalla. Lightning decided to stand and fight, to protect Etro and see her benevolent will upheld.
Valhalla may be where one first enters into the Unseen Realm after crossing Etro's Gate, and is, thus, the border in that sense -- but it's definitely in the Unseen Realm, if not synonymous with it.
So it's the unseen realm, but not really the unseen realm because it's a gap between the unseen realm and the real world, but because it's not the real world it may as well be an unseen realm full of chaos either way.stolen from wikia said:Daisuke Watanabe, the lead scenario writer for Final Fantasy XIII-2, has explained Valhalla as thus: "Valhalla exists on a different reality plane, one that lies between the real world and nothingness. Time doesn't flow in Valhalla because it is a timeless, lifeless place. With Etro fading from the real world, Valhalla is her only refuge: it is a "middle world" where she waits until she dissolves completely".[2]
It has to be a translation error.
I always figured that Valhalla is in another realm, unknown except by name to a few, and never seen (or hardly seen). It is a land closest to the unseen realm, where the dead finally vanish away or through some other gate they travel to their last stop on the transition between the physical and the spiritual.
Then again, I could be wrong...
I always felt the game was entirely too inconsistent about Valhalla was. I'm sitting on the idea that it's a world between as well,
stolen from wikia said:Daisuke Watanabe, the lead scenario writer for Final Fantasy XIII-2, has explained Valhalla as thus: "Valhalla exists on a different reality plane, one that lies between the real world and nothingness. Time doesn't flow in Valhalla because it is a timeless, lifeless place. With Etro fading from the real world, Valhalla is her only refuge: it is a "middle world" where she waits until she dissolves completely".[2]
So it's the unseen realm, but not really the unseen realm because it's a gap between the unseen realm and the real world, but because it's not the real world it may as well be an unseen realm full of chaos either way.
get it?
Or not.
I've changed my mind a dozen times about Valhalla tbh, because of all the contradictory info coming out. I guess, that leaves me to fill in the blanks with bad theorizing so, I guess I sort of view Valhalla as a buffer zone between the real world and complete non existence.
And because of that nature of existing in neither a place with life (real world) or death (the world of nothing), it has all those wacky rules. I think final word has it that the dead to hang out there, but they definitely pass through it.
Splintered said:Chaos is a weird thing of itself, as its portrayed as both malevolent and destructive, but also the keys to free will in the larger mythos.
While XIII-2 does have some translation blunders that have lead to plot confusion ("I was the very last child to be born" and "the latest in a line of eternal servants," I'm looking at you), this isn't one. Here is the Japanese version of the line, "Valhalla is an otherworldly dimension, also known as the Unseen Realm," as found under the "Valhalla" entry in the Datalog:
「不可視世界」の異名を持つ異界。
That is: "Another world, with the alternate name of 'the Unseen Realm.'"
So, yeah, the official translation is correct.
I think I'm seeing where this confusion is coming from now. I think that quote from Watanabe has been misunderstood.
You had it right when you said that Valhalla lays between the mortal world and non-existence. That place between is the Unseen Realm. The state of nothingness isn't the same as the Unseen Realm, where the dead wind up. Remember, Etro died in the mortal world before arriving in the Unseen Realm/Valhalla.
Non-existence appears to be destruction beyond simple death.
So, I don't think there are any contradictions at work here. Folk just got confused about what the Unseen Realm is supposed to be in terms of existence for those inhabiting it.