SPOILERS LTD Remake — It's like New Coke except ... no, it's exactly like New Coke

[LicoriceAllsorts]

Surely the blue baby thing was a spoof or troll?
Funny how we haven't really moved on from the idea of fictional marriage and family = happy ending, when in reality it's often anything but.

 

[Eerie]

I stumbled on it enough on Twitter to assure you the blue baby theory does exist and is embraced by some part of the clerith fandom :')

 

[KindOfBlue]

Surely the blue baby thing was a spoof or troll?
Funny how we haven't really moved on from the idea of fictional marriage and family = happy ending, when in reality it's often anything but.

The only reason I might agree is because of the comment about “even without Sephiroth, perhaps things wouldn’t work out” or something like that…either way though, if the devs just say they got married and lived happily ever after, that puts detractors in a position where anything they come up with to oppose this would undeniably be literal head canon

 

[kathy202]

I wonder how many of these theories were started by trolls and ended up getting taken too seriously by crazy shippers...

 

[frosty]

Well, we did manage to produce the kinds of people who spam official social media accounts with essays about how a developer should treat their own characters, so there’s certainly some entitlement that Western fans and really fans in general should answer for but won’t.

Are you referring to the Jessie enthusiast
The most recent I saw was him accusing a content creator who does Resident Evil /FF crossovers that it was unfair that he/she didn't give Cloud/Jessie a kiss, the same way the content creator did one for Cloud/Leon Ada/Tifa. He even pulled out a (statistically questionable) Cloti/Clerith/Clessie bar graph to drive his point home.

That kind of dedication is...applaudable.

 

[Eerie]

I wonder how many of these theories were started by trolls and ended up getting taken too seriously by crazy shippers...

I seriously wonder about that too. There's one clerith right now on Twitter who's very famous for being completely stupid, and I wonder if he's a troll. Saying that Cloud and Tifa only knew each other for 5 days... as hilarious as it is, one has to wonder.

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

I think there are a lot of trolls about, and the LTD shippers on both sides are often quite easy to hoodwink.

 

[Ryeleigh]

I've read a great deal of fanfic, and I have to disagree with your assessment. While it is true that there's a significant number of fic writers who like to write about sex, this only reflects the high level of human interest in sex generally. I don't tend to find fanfiction writers' takes on characterisation to be any more or less accurate than that of fanartists, meta-writers, analysts etc.... And there's no correlation between how much the fic focuses on sex and how accurate the characterisations are.

If your fanfic experiences are different that's great!

I don't know if I worded it badly, but I didn't mean that fanfic in general is bad. But like with any medium there is more bad than good. I also didn't mean that *every* fic with sex is bad or that writing about sex is bad. I literally meant the fics where the characters are used as puppets for the writer's particular sexual fetish. I don't really know how to make that more clear, sorry!

 

[eleamaya]

Alien Blue Baby is ridiculous.
But now, as Zack is alive, I can't wait to see if Zerith seized their theory lol

 

[MiraTora]

Hi guys, there’s a quote I want to find. Did Nomura say Aerith’s name was connected with Cloud’s?(like earth and cloud). I try to find the original source but unfortunately I was lost

 

[Thenir]

I've never heard about any quote from Nomura or the other devs about this, nor I've seen any fan mentioning it when making this comparison, that actually isn't new.
Aerith's name is associated to the earth for the fact of being a Cetra. Cloud's name has probably another origin, linked to the mythical lore of Nibelheim/Niflheim (literally "home of mist" hence home of Cloud). It's also a hint of his personality. It's possible that the devs liked also the way these two names fitted the image of the sky and the earth, anyway Zack is constantly associated to the sky as well, so Idk..maybe.

 

[Eerie]

The name Nibelheim is based on Niflheim. Niflheim, also called Niflheimr, is a location in Norse Mythology meaning "mist world". In the story of Gylfaginning, Odin explains that creation began when the ice of Niflheimr met the flames of Muspelheim. Nibelheim is literally translated as "fog-home" in German. "Nibel" is an old-fashioned way to pronounce "Nebel", the German word for "fog", but can also be translated as "cloud" resulting in "cloud home". This is implicitly suggested by being the home of the protagonist, Cloud.

Early concept screenshots shows dialogue where the town is called ニヴルヘイム (Nivuruheim?), the standard transliteration of Niflheim in Japanese.

The names "Cloud" and "Strife" are English words referring to weather and difficulty respectively. Tetsuya Nomura has stated Cloud's name contrasts with Zack Fair's and the idea of "fair weather", in that Zack led a peaceful and happy life while Cloud's has been full of turmoil.

From the Wiki. So that's a lie (in 15 years in and out fandom I've never heard that either).

 

[MiraTora]

Thank you, I just have a little debate with my group fandom. Idk whether they mistake Aerith and Cloud instead of Yuna and Tidus. I tried to search on wiki and they only mentioned Nomura explaining Tidus and Yuna name, so I’m a little confused where that info come from

 

[eleamaya]

Hi guys, there’s a quote I want to find. Did Nomura say Aerith’s name was connected with Cloud’s?(like earth and cloud). I try to find the original source but unfortunately I was lost

From Dengeki PSP Vol.397

Question: You've given Zack a surname, which is also related to weather. Do you have any attachment to that theme?

Nomura: "It wasn't anyone's attachment, in particular, we just found ourselves continuing on with that theme. Cloud and Squall were my ideas, but after that, it wasn't so I didn't mind if we didn't carry on with it. With FFXIII as well Toriyama said he wanted to have something related to weather, and so we named the main character Lightning."

Kitase: "Just like with Biggs and Wedge, even if you say that it doesn't matter people around you will still pay mind to it."

Nomura: "But when we were deciding on Zack's name, since it had gone on it this long we decided to make it weather-related as well, and picked 'Fair (weather)'."

Kitase: "We'd already settled on the logo, so we picked a name with an image of a 'blue sky' based on that. We had three potential names lined up."

Nomura: "We were almost going to go with a different name that Kitase was pushing for, but there were too many objections to it so we went with Fair (laughs). But there are some sunflowers on the swimming trunks Zack wears at Costa del Sol, those are remnants of it."

That's the answer. They named FF's protagonists like Cloud, Squall, and Lightning based on weather. Particularly, Zack's name, although also based on weather, is straightly related to "blue sky" that Kitase even had three potential names about it. The sunflowers is perhaps related to "the sun" since fair weather is the sun shining within blue sky.

Idk about Cloud's origin in particular, it must be from very old interview about OG's development, right? But Nomura indeed loves mythology and FF7 has Norse lore, let's assume the wiki above is right. I guess Aerith's name is from Sakaguchi, dedicated to her mother and that it's about Planet/Earth and Life itself. So I dont think Cloud and Aerith's names are symbolically related.

 

[KindOfBlue]

Kitase: "Just like with Biggs and Wedge, even if you say that it doesn't matter people around you will still pay mind to it."

The FF7 fandom in a nutshell

 

[KindOfBlue]

Sorry for double posting but wtf is wrong with twitter lmao

 

[Thenir]

Lol twitter dramas. There's a similar reddit post of two days ago that turned into crazy takes and rude comments, I guess it's the same people.
It's embarrassing.

 

[MiraTora]

Holy, the comments in that ACC latest tweet were such a disaster. I think the person in Twitter who said Aerith is more mature than Tifa is the same OP from Reddit who post about which girls are more mature, I saw that post and I didn’t want to interact because I already knew what will happen in those comment sections

 

[Humming]

The same 'Doki Doki' group are saying that Zack and Aerith weren't in a relationship so I guess these people didn't even play the games.

 

[Eerie]

Well, some cleriths did not play the game... some didn't even play the OG and fell for clerith through KH lol. One is also known for making multiple accounts - and I'm talking about a shocking number of accounts. I think those people are best ignored lol.

 

[Phantasia]

I think the person in Twitter who said Aerith is more mature than Tifa is the same OP from Reddit who post about which girls are more mature, I saw that post and I didn’t want to interact because I already knew what will happen in those comment sections

Yeah, I read that post too. The person started saying that it was not a Tifa vs Aerith post, but them proceeded to pit one against the other (and gob forbid someone said Tifa). We all know the true nature of those questions, and I don't get why people need that kind of validation... Is not like they ask looking for different points of view anyway.

They are both great in their own way. Having a preference is fine, but you don't need to belittle one character to raise the other, and especially them, for they work in tandem.

 

[Stiggie]

Sorry for double posting but wtf is wrong with twitter lmao
View attachment 11181

Lord these people are insane, I just don't get it, how do these peoples brains even function?

 

[KindOfBlue]

Sorry to make this thread more meta by the way lol. I don’t keep up with who’s who on Twitter or Reddit but I’ll occasionally look at the shipping tags for a good laugh or two. Between #Cloti being full of hornyposting and arguing with Clerith shippers, #Clerith full of logical leaps larger than any building Superman could leap over, and #Clessie full of…well, Jairus, there’s no shortage of action there.

The same 'Doki Doki' group

BRUH, I swear I’ve been seeing that “doki doki” bit from the Ultimania referenced more often than usual

how do these peoples brains even function?

Something like this, I imagine

 

[eleamaya]

Sorry for double posting but wtf is wrong with twitter lmao

Lol twitter dramas.

This is because of:
- CC 14th Anniversary (Sept 13) that they need to shit on Zack, and
- AC 16th Anniversary (Sept 14) that they need to shit on Tifa

 

[frosty]

I feel sorry for the account handler.

People who are accusing the official account of not knowing the plot of their own company's product is extremely...disrespectful. It boggles my mind that saying Cloud and Tifa lived together is "Barret erasure" and saying that it's disrespect for people of color ?

People who are complaining that the official account not giving CC love for the 14th anniversary but choosing to give AC attention... They do know that PSPs are no longer in production, right? And the call to action of the post is clearly to push ACC's rerelase's sales?

They do also know that some people who follow the Remake page have not played the OG... And may not know Aerith is dead right? Hence even if they did want to say "Cloud was mourning Aerith and Zack", they're giving away a spoiler? Hence the safest thing is to reference Tifa, who the new players already know?

And those people who start, "Not to start waifu wars, but Tifa or Aerith? Who is more popular? Who is more mature? Who is the better woman for Cloud?" are CLEARLY shit posters fishing for a response right?

That dude Jairus who keeps saying it's not the creator's intent that matters but that that FF7R is everyone's story and hence needs to give Npc's equal representation... He does realize this is a game, and not a democracy...right?

This fandom gets weirder by the day. In contrast, the Japanese page is relatively peaceful and has so much better content