SPOILERS LTD Remake — It's like New Coke except ... no, it's exactly like New Coke

[Yoru]

In short, his character has become, more than central, a narrative device and nothing else.

Thing is... she always has been.

I'm sorry but if you just try to forget the nostalgia, Aerith in OG IS a narrative device and nothing else.

Game opens with her. It's the first female party member you see and talk to. She's the princess in danger you have to liberate from Shinra. She's more gamedesign than story in the end. She's our introduction to the fantasy elements of this world (Cetra,Lifestream etc etc) and basically the perfect girlfriend you can have just for the game to kill her. And that's it. She's gone. Nothing you can do about it. But what did her death leads to ?

The party resolution to keep going, to make her sacrifice not be in vain. It leads to Tifa understanding a life lesson; tell the blonde guy how you really feel because death can be around the corner anytime etc etc.

Aerith is a narrative device to all the FF7 story.

 

[thetriplerhyme]

Next Cycle, Warrior of Light Cloud is adrift, knowing he has something to fight for, but unable to remember what it is, knowing it was here and now it's gone.

Dissidia (13th cycle ) is released before Duodecim ( 12th cycle ) and C/A all rant before that it was Aerith he lost that's why he's adamant to fight until the prequel of the game is release ~ HAHA CT just have to laugh it hard this is what you get for not understanding the game HAHAHAHA

I'm telling you right know. We're gonna see Aerith and we're gonna cry. Because we thought we could save her this time, but no, they will take her from us again. And it's this hope we had during 2 games that will create this feeling of loss and sadness. Same feelings as we had in 1997, but not with the same execution.

- EXACTLY - I never thought of it until MAX anaylze things ( I'm not confiming 100% since we still have the 3rd game ) but most likely yeah back in 97' the highlighted C/A even made a prediction on Cait sith to assure players of 'future' only devs to take it away - so her death will hurt

- In 2024 there's no need to higlight that anymore, people already know the story and how it goes we're just waiting for execution. Instead of highlighting her death they put the hope' on she can be saved..

ahh we can save her.. In process of doing this they also returned Zack and provide a world were he is saved' Again just like in OG only for devs to take it away~ you were provided all that expectations since Remake and Rebirth and 3rd installment and again a devastation hope all gone ~ same feeling same story

I have to say even for a CT like me i never believe even once she will be saved but Zack returning make me waiver i have to admit.. i mean.. he's there right??? sooo its possible?? - some 'fair made me weak

I don't really agree. For me atleast, I was still heartbroken and felt like tearing up playing that Jenova fight, atleast while her theme was playing, even though I had already seen it happen in the original 3 times.

- no worry that's normal you like Aerith you're expecting it to happened and yet seeing it executions still hurts

I could accept the changes made to it before Aerith showed up to fight Sephiroth with Cloud........ That's when I went "WTF?! she just died! why would they reduce the emotional impact like that!?"

I somehow agree though.. It part of the weirdness since that smile ( i'm not sure if you agree on this one) I would have prefer the at least the emotional impact retained.

As to why Aerith would call it a "date" in front of Tifa...I'm kind of at a loss.

Which leads me to think that this moment is actually meant to service the third dynamic.

- I never understood that either is it just Aerith teasing Cloud and Tifa? Being playful? But maybe you're right its to show Cloud's reaction instead of Tifa being jealous. Added the Gongaga part and the GS kiss.. to establish that Tifa and Cloud's relationship are on a different level.

 

[cgnVirtue]

Thing is... she always has been.

I'm sorry but if you just try to forget the nostalgia, Aerith in OG IS a narrative device and nothing else.

Game opens with her. It's the first female party member you see and talk to. She's the princess in danger you have to liberate from Shinra. She's more gamedesign than story in the end. She's our introduction to the fantasy elements of this world (Cetra,Lifestream etc etc) and basically the perfect girlfriend you can have just for the game to kill her. And that's it. She's gone. Nothing you can do about it. But what did her death leads to ?

The party resolution to keep going, to make her sacrifice not be in vain. It leads to Tifa understanding a life lesson; tell the blonde guy how you really feel because death can be around the corner anytime etc etc.

Aerith is a narrative device to all the FF7 story.

I got this feeling from Rebirth. Outside of some admittedly really sweet and cute moments, she doesn’t really serve much of a purpose but to continue being Tifa’s friend (which as mentioned by someone else earlier, their friendship is more hollow than in Remake) until like Chapter 13 where she has some room to truly shine. It was kind of disappointing to me because I really liked Aerith in Remake. I still teared up a little when she died, but then the boss gauntlet hit me and I died so many times that the impact of her death couldn’t actually hit me. I really wanted more for Aerith because her death is supposed to be one of the most iconic moments in video game history.
Like, if someone’s a CA, someone’s a CA. But I wish more of the radical CAs were vocal about how they treated Aerith in the narrative instead of whether or not handholding is more romantic than kissing.

 

[Yoru]

I really wanted more for Aerith because her death is supposed to be one of the most iconic moments in video game history.
Like, if someone’s a CA, someone’s a CA. But I wish more of the radical CAs were vocal about how they treated Aerith in the narrative instead of whether or not handholding is more romantic than kissing.

Like I already said, the game is crafted meticulously to make you relive feelings you had in OG. You can't really feel the same things if they keep the things as they were. Not saying it's facts. Just saying that's their point of view. They don't want to emulate the same feelings, they want you to FEEL it directly.

That's why the Avalanche crew is depicted differently, that's why they're bringing Tifa & Cloud relationship so soon, and that's why they robbed you of Aerith death for now.

Again, you have all the right to be upset, just saying it's unfair to judge the book by his cover when you've only read 1/3 of it. Because I know it may sound crazy (and I'm personnaly afraid of it to be honest) but we haven't started FF7 story yet. ALL the stuff is happening when Part 3 starts. CD1 of OG is only the introduction.

 

[Yumelinh]

What the hell? most of the members are adult with families or gf/bf, it feels like i am surrounded by uncles and aunties. Mind you i just reach 19 years in march and became a fan of ff7 in 2016 after watching the film AC( even without understanding anything). I recently join this forum and it already feels like a family so thank you all.

I'll be 22 yo in 2027 just like aerith haha ( i hope i don't die )

You're on a forum, discussing a 27-year-old game... What did you expect?

You made me realize something amazing: a lot of young people will be joining the fandom due to Retrylogy, and it makes me sooo happy! I hope people are still talking about FFVII 27 years from now (hope I'm still around too ).

btw, welcome!!!

 

[abzy1200]

a lot of young people will be joining the fandom due to Retrylogy, and it makes me sooo happy!

I'm one of them! I played remake in october 2021 and have been a fan since.

 

[Eerie]

You're on a forum, discussing a 27-year-old game... What did you expect?

You made me realize something amazing: a lot of young people will be joining the fandom due to Retrylogy, and it makes me sooo happy! I hope people are still talking about FFVII 27 years from now (hope I'm still around too ).

btw, welcome!!!

As far as I'm concerned, you're all kids lmao

 

[Sacky]

I'm one of them! I played remake in october 2021 and have been a fan since.

Remake on release is when i got into the series

 

[GamerSkull]

I first played the OG in 2010 when I was around fourteen or fifteen,

So that’s kinda around the time I got into Final Fantasy in general.

I was only like two or three when it first came out.

 

[nars305]

I just started to play OG yesterday. I watched chunks of it on YouTube but I got the itch to just jump in and play it myself.

I wanted to see how I’d feel with the love triangle based on the original. I see I can be really mean to Aerith if I wanted to lmao.

 

[abzy1200]

I first played the OG in 2010 when I was around fourteen or fifteen,

Yeah, I was fourteen when I played remake and 15 when I played the original.

 

[Yoru]

I played OG in 1999 after my best friend introduced me to FF8. I was 11.

So yeah, you're all kids

 

[Dr Frasier Crane]

Regarding the topic of Cloud being a dork (which he absolutely is and we love him for it), this is one of my favourite tweets doing the rounds right now:

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1777335305344852178

 

[nars305]

Regarding the topic of Cloud being a dork (which he absolutely is and we love him for it), this is one of my favourite tweets doing the rounds right now:

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1777335305344852178

I love this but also cmon they are both beautiful bunches of pixels. They deserve each other. PLEASE SE SEAL THE DEAL.

 

[Eerie]

Lol it's Gwent's kind of humour. He's a huge Tifa anf CT fan. There are so many answers to this tweet now

 

[Dr Frasier Crane]

I love this but also cmon they are both beautiful bunches of pixels. They deserve each other. PLEASE SE SEAL THE DEAL.

The beautiful thing is: we now live in a world where people can glibly meme about the reality that Cloud has kissed Tifa, and no one can contradict the premise of the meme.

It’s clear where this is going, let’s just be patient and hope Rebirth is selling well enough that SE can do part 3 the justice it deserves.

 

[Ryushikaze]

He did it for Tifa.

Final Fantasy 7.txt

Dissidia (13th cycle ) is released before Duodecim ( 12th cycle ) and C/A all rant before that it was Aerith he lost that's why he's adamant to fight until the prequel of the game is release ~ HAHA CT just have to laugh it hard this is what you get for not understanding the game HAHAHAHA

The arguments around original Dissidia and Duodecim were quite ludicrous way back when, and it's actually kind of notable how hard those arguments got dropped when even KH still gets trotted out as "C/A evidence" from time to time. But yeah, there were plenty back then. That the 7 crystal was the actual white Materia and thus meant his reason for fighting was Aerith (Not so, and made explicitly not so in Duodecim), that the flowers in the ending only appear when Cloud is on screen (they don't) to the idea that everyone's endings reflect their romantic interest (Fuck you they DEFINITELY don't because the only fucking married man in the cast has an ending that references his brother not his wife) and so many insistences that Aerith would definitely be playable in the sequel. That she was a totally story irrelevant assist attack must have extra stung because Maaya Sakamoto (Who at this point was dating if not already married to Zack's VO, just for the record) was in the game as Lightning, so they absolutely had her on hand if they wanted to do shit with her as Aerith and Nada. No Aerith. Only Tifa.

 

[Stiggie]

I wonder if, as Clerith becomes more and more unsustainable, we'll see them go more and more insane in their death throes?
I was just in the cesspool formerly known as Twitter and I actually saw a Clerith post a picture of Aerith and Cloud sitting on the water tower, and quoting Cloud talking about how "sitting there hoping Tifa would wave at him" sounds like something he'd do.....and actually go heart eyes #Clerith..... these people are insane, they literally want Aerith to be Tifa.

 

[GamerSkull]

I wonder if, as Clerith becomes more and more unsustainable, we'll see them go more and more insane in their death throes?
I was just in the cesspool formerly known as Twitter and I actually saw a Clerith post a picture of Aerith and Cloud sitting on the water tower, and quoting Cloud talking about how "sitting there hoping Tifa would wave at him" sounds like something he'd do.....and actually go heart eyes #Clerith..... these people are insane, they literally want Aerith to be Tifa.

Possibly.

I definitely think the cope still has yet to peak.

 

[GamerSkull]

Final Fantasy 7.txt


The arguments around original Dissidia and Duodecim were quite ludicrous way back when, and it's actually kind of notable how hard those arguments got dropped when even KH still gets trotted out as "C/A evidence" from time to time. But yeah, there were plenty back then. That the 7 crystal was the actual white Materia and thus meant his reason for fighting was Aerith (Not so, and made explicitly not so in Duodecim), that the flowers in the ending only appear when Cloud is on screen (they don't) to the idea that everyone's endings reflect their romantic interest (Fuck you they DEFINITELY don't because the only fucking married man in the cast has an ending that references his brother not his wife) and so many insistences that Aerith would definitely be playable in the sequel. That she was a totally story irrelevant assist attack must have extra stung because Maaya Sakamoto (Who at this point was dating if not already married to Zack's VO, just for the record) was in the game as Lightning, so they absolutely had her on hand if they wanted to do shit with her as Aerith and Nada. No Aerith. Only Tifa.

I feel like it would be hard to use KH these days since KH1 FM confirms he is searching for Sephiroth and KH2 has… well, Tifa being his light. (Or at least, she wants to give him her light).

 

[nars305]

I wonder if, as Clerith becomes more and more unsustainable, we'll see them go more and more insane in their death throes?
I was just in the cesspool formerly known as Twitter and I actually saw a Clerith post a picture of Aerith and Cloud sitting on the water tower, and quoting Cloud talking about how "sitting there hoping Tifa would wave at him" sounds like something he'd do.....and actually go heart eyes #Clerith..... these people are insane, they literally want Aerith to be Tifa.

I really try and be mindful that others can have their own interpretations and feelings. However, when I saw the way certain people twist things to “help their side” of the love triangle I knew it’s something I’d never engage with. Sometimes I really want to question people or correct them but it’s really pointless. I’ve read one thread of people trying to question a “Clerith” and just nothing sunk in.

Like I still can’t get over people waving off the kiss or saying that he only did it because he was jealous. I mean that is just Olympic mental gymnastics. It’s all clear in the little details. Just like the chapter 8 difference where Aerith pulls Cloud’s arm but if you are with Tifa they hold hands and he immediately holds tightly and looks shy about it.

It’s all there people and I feel like SE has sounded the warning alarms so people can brace for impact.

 

[Yoru]

I feel like it would be hard to use KH these days since KH1 FM confirms he is searching for Sephiroth and KH2 has… well, Tifa being his light. (Or at least, she wants to give him her light).

Nomura even implied she may not be real in KH, just a representation of Cloud Light versus the Darkness of Sephiroth

And when we see what happens in Rebirth...

 

[GamerSkull]

Nomura even implied she may not be real in KH, just a representation of Cloud Light versus the Darkness of Sephiroth

And when we see what happens in Rebirth...

View attachment 15426

Yeah, but that’s my point. KH doesn’t imply Clerith anymore, so I don’t see how it can be used.

 

[overheat28]

Possibly.

I definitely think the cope still has yet to peak.

Definitely. They will struggle along till the last game comes out.

I do believe the honor of the final death blow belongs to Zack.

 

[Yoru]

Yeah, but that’s my point. KH doesn’t imply Clerith anymore, so I don’t see how it can be used.

The same way they use OG FF7 lmao.

They saw Traverse Town and stopped the game at Hercule Colloseum.

"Yup. Aerith is here and Cloud is looking for someone. I have seen enough"