SPOILERS LTD Remake — It's like New Coke except ... no, it's exactly like New Coke

Eerie

Fire and Blood
The reason why Zack retaining his individuality will be explained in Part 3. Nojima said he hopes for Zack to get involved with the sense of Planet. This is perhaps something new that Planet has some business with him as he can branch new world based on his decision, will, hope, and dream. Flowers leading him also has nothing to do with Aerith but the Planet's will as Aerith is supposed to follow it too. If Zack was always by her side, it's his own will, his world, his rule; not because Aerith keeping him for what she wants. I prefer that way.
I think so too that it's the Planet's will to keep Zack around; not only because he can help Cloud in his fight against Sephiroth, but also for Aerith.

I suspect greatly that he ends up in Aerith's own Promise Land at the end (he wasn't inside of it before that; the church scene happens in one Aerith's PL for Cloud, but it's not "our" Aerith there. It's part of both arcs to reunite and to help Cloud. We've known that since ACC, they're friends and mentors to him, giving him the wise words that encourage him.

It's always been a wonder why Zack was able to survive without dissolving in AC/C, but him being halfway between our world and the Lifestream (as per the JP), in a world filled with hopes and dreams (but where everything crashes, which creates a new reality for him to try again) all of that to end up finally in Aerith's PL as she dies in our world... it all makes sense to me? He is dead, but he still is full of hopes and dreams, wants to help and wants to reunite with Aerith. Rebirth has been setting up their reunion so hard, and Nojima knows better than to write to not deliver in the end. If it's in game, it's going to be resolved, just like Cloud's identity issues, the true CT reunion, etc.

And I will tell you again, I am not a ZA shipper. In the end personally I'm only a CT shipper, so I don't really care if ZA gets their reunion or not: but I feel it's one of the things lacking in the Compilation that has been pushed hard in Rebirth. I only tell what I see with my eyes for them, there's no special bias for this pair.
 

Sacky

Pro Adventurer
AKA
SackyBoy
My interpretation is thus;

He asks Tifa because they are alone (Tifa asked him to keep the Zack information between themselves) and he just got caught staring at her with a smile on his face, it was a classic case of just changing the subject due to embarassment. He has already ascertained that Aerith might still have feelings for Zack due to her response in Gongaga and he was rather rude towards both Zack and Aerith when he was trying to be supportive. Why do i think he was trying to be supportive and not jealous? Well, look at the very intentional close up of his face, it's a stone cold neutral face with virtually no emotion.. not only that but when he calls Zack a loser he looks to Tifa for reassurance/backup that what he is saying is the right thing to say to support a friend. He obviously comes to the conclusion that he overstepped the mark (more on that with the Aerith date) and you can see the POV camera following Tifa as he claims "another time" obviously to talk to Tifa about this situation later on. Obviously he gets even more of a conclusion in Nibelheim where he remembers not only who Zack is (his friend) but that Zack also was extremely in love with Aerith, so now he's in a positions where he knows the feelings of two of his friends but doesn't know how to approach the subject. Tifa offered to talk and once she says no she hasn't yet he comes to the conclusion Tifa is finding it hard to approach the subject with Aerith because it's a touchy subject due to what he believes to be Aerith's lingering feelings for Zack. Notice the camera is not on Cloud's face this time and his line delivery is pretty neutral, this is because we've already established that Cloud is not "jealous" of the situation and is instead mearly concerned for Aerith. Contrast this moment, for example, with Yuffie telling Cloud that Tifa forgot about him when she came to Midgar, when the camera switches to a close up of Cloud's face as he shows a visible distate for Yuffie's comment because the dev's intention is to show us Cloud's emotions in the moment.

Now lets talk about the Aerith date - I'm not sure if his intention was to bring up talking to Tifa at any point, maybe it wasn't. But notice the two very different situations that bring about the conversation, in the Aerith date this is after she basically confirms to Cloud that her initial draw to Cloud was that she reminded him completely of Zack, and you can tell not only by Cloud's facial expression but by the way Cody delivers the line that he's slightly uncomfortable with the topic because he "remembers" Zack and his feelings for Aerith, as well as what he believes to be Aerith's lingering feelings for Zack. He wants to know if Aerith knows the same thing, but she says she doesn't, and his "Oh.." whilst turning away kind of leads him into a slightly more uncomfortable situation. because she's saying these things to Cloud whilst he has to deal with the knowledge that he believes Zack is dead, and that his best friend was in love with the girl who he's in a rather intimate situation with currently. Notice he doesn't mention Aerith's feelings for Zack because at this point he remembers and has learned from Gongaga, just as he says on the Tifa date he recognises it's a "touchy subject" because of her lingering feelings for Zack and he doesn't want to voice them infront of Aerith incase it upsets her. The two situations mirror each other. In this moment I think Aerith understands or clocks on to Cloud's apprehension and sudden anxiety and that's why she does what she does best and diffuses the situation somewhat by latching onto his arm and asking Cloud if it's okay to just pretend "until the ride is over." Now I know a lot of people will see the handhold as romantic, and if we're being honest, it can have romantic undertones for sure, but if we look at the context of the situation that just happened, Cloud's confused as to why Aerith just latches onto his arm, and understands the whole situation of the "date" just changed after the awkward Zack exchange, Cloud chooses to show us that he has emotionally matured since Gongaga and offers Aerith comfort that quite frankly she seems to seek out in the moment, hence "Until the rides over" and that's how the date ends.

I think the scene was important in both dates because it establishes that both Tifa and Aerith are keeping knowledge from Cloud because of the very complicated nature of the situation between Cloud, Tifa, Aerith and Zack, whether you want to believe this is purely romantic based, or Cloud's false remembering based, well it's up to interpretation, but certainly Tifa and Aerith are talking about a lot of things behind Cloud's back and things we certainly don't see on screen.

Notice also the difference in the climaxes of both dates;
The Kiss happens way after the Zack conversation, infact they talk about themselves first before anybody initiates anything
The Handhold happens almost immediately after the Zack conversation when Aerith latches onto his arm to break the tension of talking about Zack and his connection to Cloud, and how Aerith see's Zack in him. Even though, yes, she suggests that it's okay that Cloud isn't Zack and that she's currently trying to find Cloud.
See this is what i find so strange about the no dates are canon statement. They put so much thought into making each date work with the story no matter what?
 

Yoru

Pro Adventurer
See this is what i find so strange about the no dates are canon statement. They put so much thought into making each date work with the story no matter what?

It's not canon in the sense that all the dates happen at the same time and Cloud can't multiply and attend them all.

So they kept it out of the global story. But they've been craft in keeping in mind the game's lore.
 

shady

Pro Adventurer
See this is what i find so strange about the no dates are canon statement. They put so much thought into making each date work with the story no matter what?

It's not canon in the sense that all the dates happen at the same time and Cloud can't multiply and attend them all.

So they kept it out of the global story. But they've been craft in keeping in mind the game's lore.

And still showed a kiss… go figure
 

Hellenic

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Hellenic
This user who originally posted the translation; CrimsonDiablo, has straight up admitted that they don't like Tifa, yet parades themself as a neutral on the topic while constantly using Clerith arguments.

I think I'm starting to see a pattern here..........
Neutral? I've always seen them argue like a Clerith though, so that smells.
 

Yoru

Pro Adventurer
Anyway, there's no need to analyze anything. Canon or not we don't care. The dates exist in the original game. They could have chosen to just copy them, but no, they chose to extend them. So that means they had to make choices. Knowing what to add and what not to add. And they deliberately chose to give Cloti a kiss. Why did they do that? Because that's where the game tends to go in its classic form. You think it's just fan service? Fair. But then why not give fan service to everyone if you don't care about respecting the narrative?


Exactly.

(And I refuse any justification involving hands when for weeks/months the trailer teasing a Clerith kiss was apparently irrefutable proof that the war was over.)
 

eleamaya

Pro Adventurer
We'll see. I guess you're right.

But the thing is, for me, the planet is Aerith. When she thinks the planet is talking to her and guiding her... it's really just her presence in the Lifestream. She's guiding herself.

It's a totally personal interpretation. It's just the way I've always seen Aerith in OG. Because at first glance, the planet isn't really on our side. It lives its life and thinks only of its own survival. To me, it summons the weapons to eradicate everyone on the surface and make a "reset". So in my mind, I've always interpreted this planet becoming "nice" and really starting to help us as Aerith taking the reins. Or at least being its good guardian.
The planet has been 'nice' since it cures Genesis and keep it as a hero who will comes arises when the planet is in danger.

Tbh, who is Minerva?

Flowers are symbol of the Planet. It wilts away just like the planet is dying and the mako is dry in Zack's world. It has always been in the church, blooming, without Aerith's care before she find it and after her death, because the springs is under the church's ground, as well as the flowers in Elmyra's house. Though, I dont deny that Nomura ever said Aerith is associated to the flowers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rin

Yoru

Pro Adventurer
The planet has been 'nice' since it cures Genesis and keep it as a hero who will comes arises when the planet is in danger.

Tbh, who is Minerva?

Flowers are symbol of the Planet. It wilts away just like the planet is dying and the mako is dry in Zack's world. It has always been in the church, blooming, without Aerith's care before she find it and after her death, because the springs is under the church's ground, as well as the flowers in Elmyra's house. Though, I dont deny that Nomura ever said Aerith is associated to the flowers.

That's why I made it clear that this was just my personal interpretation of things, and that I was probably wrong in the end.

But I need to see way more of the Minerva/Genesis thing to really give weight to this eventuality. It's far too unclear even in Crisis Core.

I agree that flowers are a symbol of the planet. But the yellow flowers are still intrinsically linked to Aerith. The symbol of reunion etc. That's why the whole "follow them, the YELLOW flowers" thing still seems very Aerith centric.

In the end, it doesn't change much of what I wanted to explain. Whether it's the Planet or Aerith, "allowing" Zack (because strong will or not, someone/something has to be ok to bend the rules) to stick around is still a strong sign of his importance to Aerith. He's not just there to look pretty until Cloud can join Aerith in death.
 

Hellenic

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Hellenic
Guys help im getting told Aeriths thank you is i love you in Japanese what level of copium is this now
This is the kinda stuff people are saying
"About the kiss scene, the devs seemingly chose to depict Cloud and Tifa's relationship as more physical because it's the only way they can express their affection at that point. They still have a lot of work to do to sort things out. On the other end, Aerith and Cloud hold hands the way only very close or married couples do in Japan, because the devs wanted to depict their bound as more emotional. Both girls represent very different archetypes of lovers, so it's only natural the relationships don't grow the same way but that doesn't mean one is more legit than the other. And for the "like" dialogue, Aerith is a lot clearer in Japanese but some of the subtlety is lost in translation. She uses two different words to say like, one being more platonic and the other more romantic and she implies very strongly she leans more on the second. When she says "thank you" later on, Cloud is totally taken off guard 'cause saying thank you in that context could be understood as "I love you". The interesting thing is FFX localisation team chose back in the day to translate the same thank you Yuna gave to Tidus as an I love you"
Did they perhaps get this idea from FF10 where Yuna does say "thank you" in japanese while she says "i love you" to Tidus in english? At least that comes to mind as an example of what they could base this stuff on.
 

LunarTarotGirl

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Lunarae
I also want to address another thing that popped up earlier, and that's the idea that Cloud is eliding Zack from his memory so he can feel special, and that's not it. Cloud is trying to live on for Zack and honor his memory, but his mind is so fucked up that what he manages to cobble together is a house of cards heavily built from bits of Zack. He doesn't remember Zack at first because his subconscious won't let him remember Zack because Remembering Zack is both way too painful and might make his mind crack. Cloud doesn't want to forget Zack, he's mad at himself for forgetting Zack, for example. His mind just wouldn't let him remember until he had enough of his own mind built back up.

That's true that he likely is angry at himself for not remembering and his deep desire is to honor Zack.

I do think his ego is also part of it though. For several reasons.

Because of Toriyama's statement when you think of Cloud imagining another SOLDIER at the park with Aerith and that it adds depth to his character. He has a complicated feeling. Not a sad one a complicated one because yes it would break his mind and make him feel guilt. But I think also up till this point he was the coolest kid on the block we see him try to brag about his training and Jessie and Aerith indulge him and I do think this is because of his ego. And It's true that real Cloud deep inside would not want to dishonor Zack. But he calls him a loser too and in OG dialogue there was originally an option to be jealous.

Meaning there has to be some complexity as well.

I don't really think they put that dialogue option there in OG just to be like "ahh Cloud likes Aerith so he is jealous" but because of ego. Because of SOLDIER Cloud's ego specifically. (I mean maybe it was just for Aerith affection points?.. but I think it's more complicated even then) And I believe now in ReTrilogy they may have replaced that with complex feelings and calling him loser.

Finally I had a whole theory back before Rebirth about the play and how the way Cloud talks with Jessie and Aerith and they indulge him as being so cool and getting saved by him is part of Cloud's persona's insistence on wanting to be the hero. This desire comes from his childhood wish to be one for Tifa. And SOLDIER Cloud acts it out like a protagonist in a play. That play is a whole ego wonderland in my eyes. And an expression of the hero he wants to be.

And if we look at Loveless lore, and the costume hints in Ever Crisis mean anything then the real protagonist of that "play" is Zack. So there are layers here. He is standing in Zack's role currently.

So I think yes he loves Zack and misses him but also the devs are using the word complicated and let him so openly call him a loser. And I think it's because there is complicated feelings and I do think his ego and what this Zack guy represents to SOLDIER Cloud is definitely involved in that. at least up till he remembers Zack then feels horrible about it along with feeling like a failure, along with anger along with love.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Also I noticed they made Zack also feel complicated towards Cloud in response in Japanese he does say "I hate you a little." in EN it's less "heard you been busy" probably because it's Zack who may be feeling jealousy over Aerith. Which that's interesting they added that but there is definitely complexity set up here with him. I don't think it's supposed to be love triangle bait as much as a commentary on the complex dynamic. This guy he saved basically took his "place" but also apparently his love. And he is nice about it but it must still hurt.

But I don't think like others have read it that this is romantic jealousy even in OG I think it's a commentary on his ego.
 
Last edited:

Yoru

Pro Adventurer
Also I noticed they made Zack also feel complicated towards Cloud in response in Japanese he does say "I hate you a little." in EN it's less "heard you been busy" probably because it's Zack who may be feeling jealousy over Aerith which that's interesting they added that but there is definitely complexity set up here.

Yup ! And it was good ! It's so sad they chose to change it in english.

It gives Zack depth. He's not just a empty shell who's a bit too stupid to have conflicting feelings.

Of course, he'll never hold a grudge against Cloud completely. Because it's not his fault per se. Zack was gone. And it's him at the end of Crisis Core who tells him to say hello to Aerith if he sees her (=I wish you could run into her and tell her what happened to me).

But it was interesting to show that yes, Zack really is in love, and it's hurting him.
 

Hellenic

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Hellenic
The thing is. I don't know if they're lying or just in such denial they actually believe it. I just wonder what the Japanese speaking CA fans think of all this because one glance and these arguments fall apart.

It makes it so difficult also to talk about what is actually happening with Aerith.
Iirc some of the japanese CAs did want the devs to either remove the Highwind scene for Cloud and Tifa in the third game or put Aerith in there instead or such. To me that does tell that some do understand where everything is going and they want to try and avoid it at all cost.
 

LunarTarotGirl

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Lunarae
Iirc some of the japanese CAs did want the devs to either remove the Highwind scene for Cloud and Tifa in the third game or put Aerith in there instead or such. To me that does tell that some do understand where everything is going and they want to try and avoid it at all cost.
It was actually a Japanese CA that gave me the quotes showing Cloud and Tifa's feelings are mutual and explained the nuances in detail to me. So yeah I do think there are those realize where endgame is going. Many just still appreciate the Clerith moments we do get.

That one specifically was defending Tifa in a thread I was in.

And yes they were 100% a Clerith. They believed Cloud had romantic feelings for Aerith at some point and said they were going to continue to ship them forever but accepted his true self loved Tifa. They exist. *
 
Last edited:

Hellenic

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Hellenic
If they are to address Aerith's feelings in Part 3, do you think there will still be an air of ambiguity or do you think we will get the clear picture of where she stands for both Cloud and Zack? I assume this would need to be discussed between ZA since Marlene told Zack that Aerith has feelings for Cloud.

What is a good way to address and resolve this in part 3 without be messy?

Also, throughout Remake and Rebirth, did you detect Cloud having any romantic feelings towards Aerith?
To be fair, Zack has no idea how Aerith and Cloud would have even met at this point. It's all too confusing to him at the moment and it definitely will be brought up between Zack and Aerith in the third game in some form i imagine.

I don't think it would be messy at all to be honest. Zack is a very understanding guy afterall and if he gets all the puzzle pieces in place, i'm sure he will understand it all just fine and not hold anything against Aerith.
 

nars305

🎵 I am so, so bored 🎶
Anyway, there's no need to analyze anything. Canon or not we don't care. The dates exist in the original game. They could have chosen to just copy them, but no, they chose to extend them. So that means they had to make choices. Knowing what to add and what not to add. And they deliberately chose to give Cloti a kiss. Why did they do that? Because that's where the game tends to go in its classic form. You think it's just fan service? Fair. But then why not give fan service to everyone if you don't care about respecting the narrative?


Exactly.

(And I refuse any justification involving hands when for weeks/months the trailer teasing a Clerith kiss was apparently irrefutable proof that the war was over.)
That’s why I don’t understand the argument between optional and non-optional scene when the placement of a picture in an ultimania is relevant evidence to some people? Makes no sense.

Also, on the topic of these optional scenes, what if we look at the story strictly for the story? Ignoring ALL optional content?

When I think of that, what story beats do Cloud and Aerith have over Cloud and Tifa in Rebirth? I can’t say it’s the same, especially if you want to think about it romantically.
 

LunarTarotGirl

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Lunarae
I don't know if it's just me but I treat everything as equally likely and I don't treat any option as optional. In anything. Ever.

Basically I don't dismiss anything. If it made into the made into the game it can't be for nothing. Someone made the choice to include it.

I try to look at it through the lens of intent why did the creator include this option surely it must be for some reason. Why did the creator give me the option of seeing this scene? Why was it included? Surely it must mean something.

Because creators can just throw stuff in for fun or Easter eggs sure but that doesn't mean options and alternative scenes etc are completely divorced from the original work or that they don't serve a purpose. They still give some information, they still tell us something.
 

nars305

🎵 I am so, so bored 🎶
I agree, I don’t dismiss optional things either. Especially talking about SE since they seem to put so much thought into things.

I’m just saying as far as the LTD, and for a proper debate, it can only be viewed from one basis- either optional things are considered or they are not.

Obviously this does not happen.
 

Sacky

Pro Adventurer
AKA
SackyBoy
I don't know if it's just me but I treat everything as equally likely and I don't treat any option as optional. In anything. Ever.

Basically I don't dismiss anything. If it made into the made into the game it can't be for nothing. Someone made the choice to include it.

I try to look at it through the lens of intent why did the creator include this option surely it must be for some reason. Why did the creator give me the option of seeing this scene? Why was it included? Surely it must mean something.

Because creators can just throw stuff in for fun or Easter eggs sure but that doesn't mean options and alternative scenes etc are completely divorced from the original work or that they don't serve a purpose. They still give some information, they still tell us something.
I have never seen ths optional argument except for this fandom. If a developer spends time and money recording animating and making each scene different with different composed tracks. Then they want you to view them all. They could have easily made every scene over the top fanservice yet they still felt they needed to make them story related and not confuse players. Thats why the kiss matters so much, its not about the actual kiss its about the message the devs are telling, Part 3 makes the most sense for the canon kiss anyway. Its also opened the floodgates of what they will show Cloud doing romantically.
 
Top Bottom