SPOILERS LTD Remake — It's like New Coke except ... no, it's exactly like New Coke

Hellenic

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Hellenic
Speaking of variable dialogue results for the date. I think there might actually be something that also affects the final battle lineups to an extent. I noticed this when a streamer got Tifa for the wing phase of Rebirth Sephi alongside Yuffie and Barret. Every other time i've seen, including my own runs had Red, Yuffie and Barret there.

I have no idea yet what affects this stuff but i might go and experiment on it a little at some point.
 

Eerie

Fire and Blood
Speaking of variable dialogue results for the date. I think there might actually be something that also affects the final battle lineups to an extent. I noticed this when a streamer got Tifa for the wing phase of Rebirth Sephi alongside Yuffie and Barret. Every other time i've seen, including my own runs had Red, Yuffie and Barret there.

I have no idea yet what affects this stuff but i might go and experiment on it a little at some point.
Isn't this based on who your team is before Aerith's death though?
 

pxl_pushr

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Pixel
Look I don't plan to play CCR because I find it clunky but at least I watched a let's play about it lol. So I know the story (alas Genesis cough cough).
I will cackle if the subtitle for part 3 is Redemption because the amount of Genesis looming over this ReTrilogy is equal to the amount of Zack looming over Rebirth ( you can ignore it, but you cannot deny it )
 

Empyrea

Pro Adventurer
Look I don't plan to play CCR because I find it clunky but at least I watched a let's play about it lol. So I know the story (alas Genesis cough cough).
This is fair. Admittedly, that was faster and punchier to say xD
It's probably safer and more accurate to say that they don't 100% know the story and/or the characters they're talking about. Just watched YT clips, read surface level interpretations, played Disc 1 of OG only, etc.

Edit to add: Genesis still has work to do -- he said so in DoC! With Deepground in Remake, Genesis' return is nigh!
 

MissMDusk

Lv. 25 Adventurer
AKA
Mari
Until shown anything concrete that says otherwise, I’m assuming it follows the same rules as other LA/HA scenes in this and the original game: the sentiment is the same, the HA version just emphasizes it

Sometimes, omitting something is more potent than actually saying it ( words aren’t the only way to express how you feel )
Probably. Gotta say though, I think I like the HA more because the "Because we're friends" felt like a slap in the face lmao. Is it just me? The fact he doesn't look at her either is crazy to me, too. To be honest, I'm wondering why they would do that for her send-off with Cloud? Mad.

And to me, it's even worse it's with an Aerith who we didn't even travel with, lol.

Choices were made, I guess.
 

Sacky

Pro Adventurer
AKA
SackyBoy
Probably. Gotta say though, I think I like the HA more because the "Because we're friends" felt like a slap in the face lmao. Is it just me? The fact he doesn't look at her either is crazy to me, too. To be honest, I'm wondering why they would do that for her send-off with Cloud? Mad.

And to me, it's even worse it's with an Aerith who we didn't even travel with, lol.

Choices were made, I guess.
This is the writer who could just blow up one of their heads if you annoy him so they gotta be careful here XD
 

MissMDusk

Lv. 25 Adventurer
AKA
Mari
Oh I hope I don't sound too critical! My favorite parts of this game was the relationship building which I found really good, especially with CT (I'm obsessed with them now, might even be one of my top couples in anime/JRPGs).

It's just that 2% (and to be honest Aerith as a character I have some questions about) that slightly bothered me
 

pxl_pushr

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Pixel
Probably. Gotta say though, I think I like the HA more because the "Because we're friends" felt like a slap in the face lmao. Is it just me? The fact he doesn't look at her either is crazy to me, too. To be honest, I'm wondering why they would do that for her send-off with Cloud? Mad.

And to me, it's even worse it's with an Aerith who we didn't even travel with, lol.

Choices were made, I guess.
Considering where we are after nearly 30 years, a verbal friend zone is about as nice as you could expect.

P3 could pull a “nah, I was too shy to say I kinda liked her too”, but then there’s the little issue of… well… you know. That could also get reversed in p3 too… but then you’d have the whole Tifa thing…

Seriously though, the whole “if Aerith had lived then she and Cloud would’ve totally ended up together” thing that could be the final boss of misconceptions to tackle.
 

Ryeleigh

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Rye
The ones my mom watched are like that (The Korean dramas) lol

And I just remembered, one shoujo I watched that aired from Dec last year to Jan this year (but was written like a decade ago?) had an obvious romance that ran for nearly all 24 of its episodes.

The last episode was the guy finally confessing and proposing to the girl. The couple hug right before the credits -- no kiss.

I watched another just a few years before that had a forehead kiss after having the audacity to tease a kiss.

Point being, there's a reason why I doubted the GS date leaks when they first came out xD
Not even a kiss, huh. I'm not sure I've read one like that? Oh wait, Fullmetal Alchemist. No kisses, I don't think there was even a hug, but they confess at the end with a proposal.

Meanwhile I just discovered the couple from a rom-com manga I used to follow just finally had sex, so I'm catching up on that. This is the problem with people, both CA's and CT's trying to make definitive statements about how things are done in Asia, It isn't a monolith.
This is true. There are plenty of shoujo with implied or not-explicit sex scenes. I think Lovely Complex is a good example of both: the main couple get only kisses and hugs, and Koizumi freaks out about the idea of sex (with a boyfriend she's liked for three years and dated for a year). But the secondary couples were pretty much implied to have sex lives. Then there's Monkey High with a non-explicit sex scene between the main couple.

And after that we get to different genres, such as seinen/josei, ecchi, BL, GL, porn, lol. But I think my original point was that shounen/shoujo tend to be geared towards younger audiences so they're not that heavy with physicality. Edit: And I'd say FF falls more on shounen target audience than older.

I'm very much aware of that, and for the record I'm Asian. Southeast, but Asian nonetheless.

I've definitely seen the type you're talking about, as it's not an isolated case (like Horimiya, which was written years ago but was animated recently, and even that one took 100 odd chapters in the manga). From my experience, though, that wasn't the case in the 90s, which is what I was replying to. And it goes without saying, it's one person's experience.
I think I've read Horimiya manga. But wasn't there some other original version of it which was a lot crazier than the manga? Iirc, it even had something about teenage pregnancy?

Been seeing some bad analyzes about ToTP and Cloud and Tifas relationship in general lately in the cesspool that is Twitter. Considering this person thinks they did a great write up about how Cloud and Tifa is not it, i wonder how they genuinely think there would ever be anything like this between Zack and Tifa (yes this all reads like the usual bullshit of let's throw the problematic characters that get in the way of our ship together)?

I just find this bullcrap deflection so weird if you're supposed to understand these characters in the first place. Zack and Tifa did in fact meet and there was no flirting whatsoever for starters and we know how Tifa is when it comes down to any other guy and their advances besides Cloud.
The beginning of Rebirth also shows Tifa constantly flinching at Z!Cloud because he's too exuberant for her, lol.

4: Haha, we got you, Zeriths are really just Clotis in disguise!!!! and that is an argument.....somehow.
....like? People can ship multiple ships?

So basically in a nutshell they imply that Tifa is a liar in Rebirth for saying that they tried to invite him but he never joined instead.
I mean, the beginning of Remake pretty much shows Cloud as a jerk who has to get used to/soften up to people to get along with them? And it was a kind of parallel to the situation in Nibelheim? Well, aside from Tifa's friends blaming him for the fall. You know, funny enough, Cloud starts to open up to the Avalanche dorks when they show vulnerability first. The same with Aerith in the playground.

It's probably safer and more accurate to say that they don't 100% know the story and/or the characters they're talking about. Just watched YT clips, read surface level interpretations, played Disc 1 of OG only, etc.
You know, there's a surprising number of people in fandoms who have never engaged with the original source materials but they've just watched clips, not even the whole thing but clips, or read other people's meta who may or may not have engaged with the original source materials themselves, lol. To be honest, I find it baffling and kind of exasperating, lol. It's even more baffling when they don't even like the thing they've never watched/played/read but absolutely hate it. Like, why are you spending time hating something you haven't even watched/played/read?

Probably. Gotta say though, I think I like the HA more because the "Because we're friends" felt like a slap in the face lmao. Is it just me? The fact he doesn't look at her either is crazy to me, too. To be honest, I'm wondering why they would do that for her send-off with Cloud? Mad.
I didn't mind it actually since Aerith herself is "That's right. I'm happy to hear Cloud's feelings".
 
Last edited:

MissMDusk

Lv. 25 Adventurer
AKA
Mari
Considering where we are after nearly 30 years, a verbal friend zone is about as nice as you could expect.

P3 could pull a “nah, I was too shy to say I kinda liked her too”, but then there’s the little issue of… well… you know. That could also get reversed in p3 too… but then you’d have the whole Tifa thing…

Seriously though, the whole “if Aerith had lived then she and Cloud would’ve totally ended up together” thing that could be the final boss of misconceptions to tackle.
Ah so is it like more meta commentary and towards the audience? If so I heard that loud and clear lol

I'd understand that more then, if we are going into p3 with the assumption that they'll be building CTs relationship from there
 

Ryeleigh

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Rye
Ah so is it like more meta commentary and towards the audience? If so I heard that loud and clear lol

I'd understand that more then, if we are going into p3 with the assumption that they'll be building CTs relationship from there
I thought CA confirming their feelings of friendship for each other felt a bit meta, much like Aerith's resolution in Remake.

Also, to be fair, they've been building up CTs relationship since the beginning of Remake, lol, so I think Part 3 will be more angst and resolutions part of the relationship.
 

MissMDusk

Lv. 25 Adventurer
AKA
Mari
My bad, I meant that they'll continue to build on their relationship - as in they'll have a lot more focus in a romantic aspect. Thanks for the answers!

I have another small question, in "Cloud smiles", does Aerith's theme/motif play in it?
 

Sacky

Pro Adventurer
AKA
SackyBoy
Considering where we are after nearly 30 years, a verbal friend zone is about as nice as you could expect.

P3 could pull a “nah, I was too shy to say I kinda liked her too”, but then there’s the little issue of… well… you know. That could also get reversed in p3 too… but then you’d have the whole Tifa thing…

Seriously though, the whole “if Aerith had lived then she and Cloud would’ve totally ended up together” thing that could be the final boss of misconceptions to tackle.
The thing is though at that point its playing a game of this could have happened, when this isn't a possible scenario in the story. Its possible that Cloud could have ended up dating none of them if they both survived, Its possible Cloud could have dropped dead the moment after but the story doesn't tell us this so whats the point. Its very highly unlikely in my opinion that the story with how Cloud is written he would have ended up with Aerith but if the writer went that way then the story goes that way. But it doesn't so whats the point in discussing stuff that does not happen.
 

Sacky

Pro Adventurer
AKA
SackyBoy
My bad, I meant that they'll continue to build on their relationship - as in they'll have a lot more focus in a romantic aspect. Thanks for the answers!

I have another small question, in "Cloud smiles", does Aerith's theme/motif play in it?
Cloud smiles is a song that was written in inspiration when Cloud gives his shy smile to Tifa. Music also tells the story without visuals in the story he sees Aerith and Zack one final time. I can't say if it does have her theme but i do hear it personally it makes sense though since he is staring at her and Zack leaving in the end of the scene.
 

MissMDusk

Lv. 25 Adventurer
AKA
Mari
Cloud smiles is a song that was written in inspiration when Cloud gives his shy smile to Tifa. Music also tells the story without visuals in the story he sees Aerith and Zack one final time. I can't say if it does have her theme but i do hear it personally it makes sense though since he is staring at her and Zack leaving in the end of the scene.
It's been a while since I've seen the movie but I thought there was a part where Cloud nods to Aerith and Zack as they pass on. It would make sense if it played there.

I think it was stuck in my mind because an extreme CA pointed it out and then said something like "Take THAT Clotis!"... Didn't really know how to tackle it lol

Besides, I'm pretty sure Tifa's motif or song plays in the main theme of FF7 or Cloud's theme? Think I saw a video on that but would have to check
 

Eerie

Fire and Blood
Gotta say though, I think I like the HA more because the "Because we're friends" felt like a slap in the face lmao. Is it just me? The fact he doesn't look at her either is crazy to me, too. To be honest, I'm wondering why they would do that for her send-off with Cloud? Mad.
Well it's a resolution for Aerith's feelings, it's the CA closure: they are friends, but there's nothing more between them. The FR went with "because I'm your bodyguard" and even though it's a nod at their church meeting it feels even colder lol.
And to me, it's even worse it's with an Aerith who we didn't even travel with, lol.
That's the big problem of this scene, it's that: is our Aerith conscious of what happened there? Or maybe she will be aware of it after passing? Why should I care? Who is this Aerith, is there only one hanging out around or are there thousands lol. Is she OG/LSW Aerith or something else altogether? What is the whole point of this scene exactly?
I have another small question, in "Cloud smiles", does Aerith's theme/motif play in it?
It would be surprising considering Uematsu wrote it for the scene where Cloud smiles at Tifa. This guy knows his themes lol. He saw that line from the script and thought "oh what a rare occurrence!" and went off with it lol.
 

pxl_pushr

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Pixel
It's been a while since I've seen the movie but I thought there was a part where Cloud nods to Aerith and Zack as they pass on. It would make sense if it played there.

I think it was stuck in my mind because an extreme CA pointed it out and then said something like "Take THAT Clotis!"... Didn't really know how to tackle it lol

Besides, I'm pretty sure Tifa's motif or song plays in the main theme of FF7 or Cloud's theme? Think I saw a video on that but would have to check
I think that’s where people get lost in the sauce in this whole thing.

First off, ship whatever you want. I’m not here to police anybody’s favorites folder on their device in question. In fact, don’t tell me I don’t wanna be cursed with knowledge lol

But it’s not a binary thing between these characters. Cloud may not have romantic feelings for Aerith, but that doesn’t mean he doesn’t deeply care about her, like he deeply cares about Zack. So yeah, her theme mixing with his? Could seem romantic in isolation, but in the context of its use, not so much.

So I think saying Cloud and Aerith are “just” friends can be a bit of an understatement though I get it’s said for the sake of brevity. They’re friends, in the most poetic sense, same as how Cloud and Zack are friends to the point of being like brothers ( though I wish they showed this a bit better but I get what they’re saying ).
 

Empyrea

Pro Adventurer
Not even a kiss, huh. I'm not sure I've read one like that? Oh wait, Fullmetal Alchemist. No kisses, I don't think there was even a hug, but they confess at the end with a proposal.
I think I've read Horimiya manga. But wasn't there some other original version of it which was a lot crazier than the manga? Iirc, it even had something about teenage pregnancy?
A kiss would've been nice there, but I'll take it because that confession alone made up for it.

Also, I think I remember reading somewhere that Horimiya started as a Web Novel/Comic? But yeah, I also heard it's crazier than the manga.
 

Empyrea

Pro Adventurer
Like, why are you spending time hating something you haven't even watched/played/read?
Possible double post, sorry.

But you know what? I'm wondering the same thing. But then, I also know not everyone shares my stance of "No opinion unless I've either experienced the thing or gained a solid enough understanding through external sources."

I have no idea why they keep subjecting themselves to the unenviable situation of being challenged by people who can back up their claims.
 

Ryeleigh

Pro Adventurer
AKA
Rye
Possible double post, sorry.

But you know what? I'm wondering the same thing. But then, I also know not everyone shares my stance of "No opinion unless I've either experienced the thing or gained a solid enough understanding through external sources."

I have no idea why they keep subjecting themselves to the unenviable situation of being challenged by people who can back up their claims.
Well, they either have the crazy confidence to talk about things they should know they know nothing about or -- and I guess there is no polite way to word this -- they're that dumb.

But yeah, I'm the same. I'd feel so embarrassed if I talked about something I know I know nothing about, lol. Or at least if I don't know, I'd preface my opinion with that instead of saying with my whole chest that "something is so".
 

abzy1200

Pro Adventurer
I have run into a "the Reunion files Koibito quote means her personality" argument in the wild. As of today.
This argument was debunked over a decade and a half ago.
Forget the idea of heaven or hell being real or not, we're already in the ninth circle.:(
 
Top Bottom