Okay, so I have gone back over some of my notes and have answers to some of these points but not necessarily for others. Please keep in mind the original article was written many years ago when I was much more in-tune with what was going on than I am now. As such, it is probable that answers from the article are probably more relevant than the ones I’m giving here. I am very much open to the possibility that I am mistaken in parts.
DG SOLDIERs’ J-Cell Exposure
Firstly, on the point of cell exposure, Tres has made a strong case above regarding whether or not DG SOLDIERs were exposed to Jenova cells. Having reviewed the scripts and all my notes, I can confirm that it is never stated anywhere that DG SOLDIERs were exposed to Jenova cells. Conversely, it is never stated anywhere that they are not. The only genetic trait commented on is the high quantity of Mako in their bodies.
The 10th Anniversary Ultimania has this to say:
The members belonging to DG are special SOLDIERs which have undergone rigorous experiments. They are only commanded to get stronger and everyday they stand side-by-side with death. Because of the experiments, they must depend upon mako baths or they cannot preserve their bodies, and they need it so much that a weak stream of mako flows through their suits.
(Please note at this time that the term ‘experiments’ refers heavily to the training battles that the SOLDIERs face rather than anything medical or otherwise. This is reflected in a Restrictor’s use of the term in Event 10 – ‘‘E’ for Emperor’ when he describes Weiss’ “experiment” as a handicap match against Azul and Rosso.)
Bear in mind that there are continuity errors regarding what happens to individuals exposed to high degrees of Mako when they die. Former SOLDIERs, for example, such as Zack and Sephiroth are seen to fade to spirit energy very soon after death, while the same is not always true for DG SOLDIERs despite their elevated exposure. During DC: Online, there is even comment by Este-D that the is a SOLDIER 'waste disposal' where dead bodies can be found. Why would that exist if people fade quickly? I would hazard a guess that this is more of an oversight than anything, but valid to my next point.
Tres very astutely pointed out that the Dragonfly chopper that crashes into the Mako swell in DG would have contained DG SOLDIERs, thus any trace of Jenova would disrupt Hojo's plan, and by deduction, they cannot contain Jenova. In addition, what would have happened if all DG was afflicted by Geostigma? Clever points but I do have a few counter arguments:
1) As discussed above, there are several continuity errors regarding the bodies of DG SOLDIERs and this isolated incident cannot be considered in my opinion to have a bearing on the overall story.
2) Hojo ordered that those with Geostigma are not added to the pure Mako. However, this does not mean that any drop of Jenova cells will ruin it, it simply means that the proportion needs to be high enough that the healthy have to be differentiated.
3) He makes a big deal about Nero tainting Weiss because Weiss is the shell, not necessarily because he is a single strand of stagnant Mako.
4) During On the Way to a Smile, I'm sure it mentions in Case of Yuffie or Case of Nanaki (though, I'm not 100% on this) that those worst afflicted by Geostigma are those without a strong sense of self. This reflects the SOLDIER process whereby Mako poisoning can occur for those with 'weak' minds. It could therefore be argued that SOLDIERs may not suffer the same physical aggravations brought about by Geostigma as they have already shown a tolerance to Jenova cells and Mako. We already know that one of the reasons Cloud suffers from it is through his guilt towards Aerith.
While these stories pre-date the creation of Dirge of Cerberus, it is stated in both Final Fantasy VII and Advent Children that
ALL SOLDIERs "have Jenova cells put inside them". However, this could easily be a continuity error or a reflection of the fact neither Cloud nor Marlene know about DG's existence. That being said, I don't think it makes a great of sense to discount the probability that DG SOLDIERs also have Jenova exposure given that modern-day SOLDIER revolves around that genetic enhancement.
Here is Souya's original translation:
Deepground
A secret facility that is built underneath Midgar
Even in Shinra, there is only a few who know of its existence
That place, it ignores and defies all morals,
"To what extent will humans become stronger?"
That experiment and research has been undergoing for a long time......
Those who are being abducted and brought to this place......
Those who are injured and being transported to this place......
Those who are as far back as one can remember......
Those who appeared in that place on a certain day all of a sudden......
Those who know what that place is......
Those who don't know anything......
Various people are gathered there.
Deepground...... Shinra's Dark Secret......
To have an entire military community made up of all sorts of people, some of whom were injured SOLDIERs or trapped there after Meteorfall, challenging one another to test the boundaries of human capability, all while not actually using the genetic enhancements available (that said normal SOLDIERs would already have) seems a bit off. But, it could be argued that this was all part of the 'experiments'.
In addition, we know that Rosso, Nero and Azul are all the sole survivors of their respective experiments (to push the boundaries of humanity, stagnant Mako injected into an unborn child, and the Metamorphose Project), so I'm not sold on the idea that the 'Reapers' who have the chance to make it all the way to Tsviet rank are without any enhancement beyond Mako. Shelke would obviously fall into this - particularly as she does not specialise in combat so compromises would have to be made.
Anyway, the point is that it's all open to interpretation as there are plot holes and inconsistencies everywhere. My vote is that the DG SOLDIERs except Weiss have been exposed to Jenova cells at some point, as it would make sense to enhance them with things other than just Mako, though none seem to possess alternative attributes.
DG SOLDIERs' G-Cell Exposure
The Crisis Core Ultimania has this to say:
Section 7: Connections with the DC Secret Movie
Q7-1: In DC's G Reports, it says that "G", one of the 'two taboos', bears an epithet signifying 'unique'. What does this mean?
A7-1: The 'two taboos' refers to Sephiroth and Genesis. In comparison to Sephiroth, the strongest and worst SOLDIER who tried to seize the life of the planet, Genesis was considered a unique SOLDIER who sealed himself away to protect the planet.
The Shinra Company, in an effort to conceal the relationship between the company and Genesis who had threatened the world, relegated information regarding Genesis to the highest level of secrecy and forbids even the use of the name 'Genesis'. Thus some of the scientists who knew detailed information on Genesis began to refer to Genesis as "G, to whom has been added a word signifying 'unique.'" This is just like how Weiss, Nero, Rosso and Azul were given codenames corresponding to colours.
As for what exactly the name meaning 'unique' is, that's a secret at present.Q7-2: In DC it is said that "the appearance of G changed the course of Deepground (DG)" and "SOLDIERs branded with epithets of colour are the hell spawn of G". Does this mean that Weiss and the other Tsviets with colour epithets who were created in DG were created using the results of Project G for reference?
A7-2: Yes. Only the DG SOLDIERs who have been injected with Genesis' genes could become a Tsviet with a colour epithet.
Q7-3: You call tell from the voices that the two men who appear by helicopter and recover Genesis are DC's Nero and Weiss, but what do they mean when they say "apparently he's a brother of ours" and "however... will he agree to it?"? From DC's hidden movie you can interpret that Genesis has been laid to rest in the cave under Midgar up until he awakens, but...?
A7-3: The 'elder brother' is used in the figurative sense. If they are injected with Genesis' genes, that creates a connection, a bond between the cellular units. That is what is meant by 'brother'.
Tres also made a distinction between gene mapping and cellular infusion:
On the topic of Weiss and the Tsviets, what happened there was gene mapping, which is different from injection. Basically, what Shademp said above:
Shademp wrote:Maybe there is a distinction to be made here. Perhaps there is a difference between transferring cells and only transferring genetic material.
Though the wording I would use here is "genetic traits" rather than "genetic material," as that seems to imply cells, at least to my ears.
Anyway, gene mapping involves the copying of genetic "code" or "blueprints," if you will, without the actual transfer of the original organism's genetic material.
The answer thus comes down to how accurate the translation of the Ultimania questions is. In other words, if the term 'genes' refers to G-Cells, then it is cut and dry. If it refers to genetic mapping, then we have a slightly different situation. I will hold my hands up and say that I interpreted 'genes' as G-Cells so, depending on the outcome of this debate, I may be wrong. The particular statement about the 'unique' epithets also lends weight to Tres' argument that the special bond is not just G-Cells.
EDIT 1
Deepground's Existence in Relation to 'G'
Based on the DC Complete Guide:
Deepground
A creation of President Shinra, its very existence is hidden in the dark. Originally a medical facility for SOLDIER, following the existence of the SOLDIER called “G,” all ethics were disregarded and the purpose of the facility was perverted … as all work now went into producing the most powerful of warriors.
, Tres wrote:
Worth noticing, though, is that SOLDIER and Deepground are consistently specified to have existed before Genesis. It was after his birth that Deepground, originally a SOLDIER medical facility, became what we know it as today. Meaning there were SOLDIERs enhanced only with mako before there were SOLDIERs enhanced with both mako and Jenova.
This is a common misconception. You may notice here the phrase "following the existence of the SOLDIER called 'G'." This is the same phrase repeated throughout the Ultimanias, one which many read as "following the birth of 'G'."
However, the immoral experiments of DG didn't begin until after Genesis joined SOLDIER, or at least when he began displaying signs of abnormal strength. While it is never confirmed anywhere, my interpretation is that the success of Sephiroth's birth was the benchmark of what would become the perfect soldier enhancement (ie a very particular balance of Jenova cells and Mako - later known as S-Cells) but when Genesis (a "failed" experiment) was also strong enough to reach SOLDIER, it gave the scientists of DG food for thought.
We known that Rosso is the first child to be born in DG in [µ]-εγλ 1985. This would put Genesis' age somewhere between 8 and 15 by my reckoning based on the 'born approximately 30 years before FFVII' vagueness.
While once more never really confirmed anywhere, it would not make a great deal of sense for DG to have existed prior to Midgar's construction as Midgar did not become Shinra's HQ until after building on the Plate began in [µ]-εγλ 1976. I would expect the two to have been built simultaneously so as to arouse less suspicion. Given that Midgar was built roughly around the same time as Genesis' birth, we're talking a very short time for DG to have been a medical facility for injured SOLDIERs before things turned sour.
Also, do you have any citation for the
Worth noticing, though, is that SOLDIER and Deepground are consistently specified to have existed before Genesis.
section, particularly the existence of SOLDIER? I'm not suggesting you are incorrect on that matter, but I have personally never considered 'SOLDIER' as such to have existed prior to Sephiroth's birth, though a Shinra military force of some kind must have.
EDIT 2
Argento Facts
One of the main reasons I decided to write the synopsis in the first place was that there were a load of things I had in my collection that couldn’t be found online anymore since most of the sites had been taken down. I’m not really surprised you haven't seen most of it elsewhere. I used to discuss it at length with people who had played the game or had access to Japanese sites and scripts. Suzaku and Shinra Employee in particular were two fountains of knowledge, and Hito pointed me in the right direction a few times.
Below are my comments to things mentioned by Shademp:
During the Wutai War, as part of a mass influx of individuals into Deepground due to Shinra’s desire to further genetic warfare, a young woman named Argento was sent to Deepground. She quickly became highly regarded by her peers for her exceptional sword and analytical kills.
In addition to this, her artistic and creative mind was put to use when she was charged with the task of designing and crafting the weapons of her comrades at the upper-echelons of the Deepground food chain
I have found no confirmation of Argento being transferred to Deepground during the Wutai War, nor that she is the one who made the Tsviet weapons.
Being the one who made the weapons is something that is revealed during one of the game's non-cutscene interactions. This was confirmed by Shinra Employee who had read the full script in Japanese and had translated much of it. Unfortunately, I do not have a copy of the transcript, nor am I in contact with him anymore. I took his word for it as he had been correct on just about everything else and had no reason to make it up. He is also the one who revealed that the npcs in the game suggest Usher was a real SOLDIER who went missing on a mission and was presumed dead.
The transfer to DG for Argento is something that is hazy for me. I have no notes on it that I can find which would suggest that either it was something that came up in passing or I have tried to join the dots about Argento's past from what information is available. Either way, I'm unable to confirm at this time how accurate the statement is and agree that it should be edited.
Communicating his thoughts to the Coloured Tsviets through Argento, the Restrictors’ messenger to the Tsviets and sympathiser to the cause, Weiss divulged his scheme to use someone not restrained by the restriction chip to infiltrate Lost Force.
Also, while the last claim "Communicating his thoughts to the Coloured Tsviets through Argento, the Restrictors’ messenger to the Tsviets and sympathiser to the cause", makes sense, the methods and exact channels in which the scheme was communicated is not shown. We know that Argento is a sympathizer, from this playonline mode scene, where Shelke's and Argento's scheming is hinted at at the end, but that's all.
Argento's inclusion in the plan to overthrow the Restrictors is hinted at all the way through the game, including in a number of cutscenes. For example, not only does she discuss the plan secretively with Shelke in Event 2, she attends the death of the Restrictor in Event 12. And this is just the stuff available to English-speakers.
The comment about Argento being the go-between was more of an embellishment as she is often seen to be a liaison between the Restrictors and the DG SOLDIERs, particularly the Tsviets. However, it is equally likely that Shelke and Weiss communicate via SND so that he can pass his orders along.
Genesis in Deepground
Aware of their cellular connection to the man and the high importance of the mission given their involvement, Weiss explained the situation in Deepground to Genesis and asked him to join them in their fight against the Restrictors. Remorseful of his actions since leading the mass SOLDIER desertion and wishing to reclaim his pride as a SOLDIER by atoning for his sins, Genesis rejected the request. Leaving Deepground soon after arriving, he sealed himself in a chamber below Midgar, only to be awoken when the Planet needed him again.
Highlighted in bold, I have seen no confirmation of Genesis being honestly remorseful. The cause for his rejection of Deepground is unknown, as far as my knowledge goes.
The information comes from the Crisis Core Ultimania:
Section 6: About Genesis
Q6-3: After Genesis is collected in the Shinra helicopter you can see a sheet of paper saying "To become the dew that quenches the land; to spare the skies, the seas to sands; I shall become an unspoken offering." Is this phrase from the lost final chapter of LOVELESS?
A6-3: The final chapter of LOVELESS is missing, and nothing official exists in the world of FFVII. Experts study it, and there are currently various theories about it. The phrase you mentioned is the final chapter of LOVELESS as Genesis conceived it, and reflects Genesis' state of mind.
By being defeated by Zack, Genesis is able to regain the pride he had as a SOLDIER, and with Sephiroth and Angeal now dead, he decided that it is up to him, who has being left behind, to protect the world. And so, in order to prepare for the day when a crisis threatens the world, Genesis seals himself in the flooded chamber on his own volition. This is the true meaning of Genesis' version of the phrase from the final chapter of LOVELESS, and at the same time the true meaning of the secret movie in DC (see A7-3).
Section 7: Connections with the DC Secret Movie
Q7-1: In DC's G Reports, it says that "G", one of the 'two taboos', bears an epithet signifying 'unique'. What does this mean?
A7-1: The 'two taboos' refers to Sephiroth and Genesis. In comparison to Sephiroth, the strongest and worst SOLDIER who tried to seize the life of the planet, Genesis was considered a unique SOLDIER who sealed himself away to protect the planet.
The Shinra Company, in an effort to conceal the relationship between the company and Genesis who had threatened the world, relegated information regarding Genesis to the highest level of secrecy and forbids even the use of the name 'Genesis'. Thus some of the scientists who knew detailed information on Genesis began to refer to Genesis as "G, to whom has been added a word signifying 'unique.'" This is just like how Weiss, Nero, Rosso and Azul were given codenames corresponding to colours.
As for what exactly the name meaning 'unique' is, that's a secret at present.
Q7-2: In DC it is said that "the appearance of G changed the course of Deepground (DG)" and "SOLDIERs branded with epithets of colour are the hell spawn of G". Does this mean that Weiss and the other Tsviets with colour epithets who were created in DG were created using the results of Project G for reference?
A7-2: Yes. Only the DG SOLDIERs who have been injected with Genesis' genes could become a Tsviet with a colour epithet.
Q7-3: You call tell from the voices that the two men who appear by helicopter and recover Genesis are DC's Nero and Weiss, but what do they mean when they say "apparently he's a brother of ours" and "however... will he agree to it?"? From DC's hidden movie you can interpret that Genesis has been laid to rest in the cave under Midgar up until he awakens, but...?
A7-3: The 'elder brother' is used in the figurative sense. If they are injected with Genesis' genes, that creates a connection, a bond between the cellular units. That is what is meant by 'brother'.
In CC Nero and Weiss are on a mission to recover Genesis, so in this case "will he agree to it?" means "will he agree to join us or not?" But, as in the response for A6-3, Genesis rejects it and decides to have himself sealed in the water-filled chamber below Midgar.
To someone who has only played DC, when they watch the secret movie in that game they will take it as "an ominous being sealed in a water-filled chamber has been release onto the world", but if you watch the movie again after having completed CC then one could go 180 degrees and interpret it in a completely different way.
You may be right that he did not regret his actions during Crisis Core as such, but he at least knew that his actions had to change.
Updated Article
I would very much like to see the Deepground History article updated, both with edits and referenced sources at the end. /academical mode
I agree that this is long overdue as I imagine a couple of things will have to be amended. Unfortunately, I spend a lot of time writing elsewhere so I can't guarantee that it gets done anytime soon.
I'll do my best to cite what I can but a fair chunk of the information comes from sites that no longer exist or individuals who would have to be quoted, and a lot of the quotes I don't have - only my own scribblings and notes at the time of the discussion. This is one of the main reasons I didn't do it in the first place. We could maybe open it up to a debate once the citations are given so that a full and comprehensive article can be written for and by the community rather than just me.