Oh WTF...
Seriously?! Are they believing that crap themselfs?
Tifa is like a mother to Cloud, because she got motherly feelings for him
Well, it's normal for a woman to get "motherly feelings". Didn't she also get that because of their new family? She was going to be the mother of it.
If Cloud was happy with Tifa then why did he leave to go live at the church? I mean really.
I mean really, I have you even played the game or watched the movie?
Cloud leaved because he was going to find a cure for Denzel, then he got Geostigma, felt that he couldn't protect his family, so he moved to Aerith's church to
die.
Even if she was the catalyst at that moment, Cloud was ready to give up again after the fight with Kadaj in the woods. It wasn't until Aerith spoke to him that he snapped out of it for good.
What? Her being the catalyst doesn't dissapear for a day. She will always be. Why would SE even put it in the ACC Dengeki Profiles if she just was it for a
short moment?
She gives Cloud the will to fight, so does the children he live with. Denzel and Marlene.
Also all Tifa did was nag nag nag, it was Aerith who made Cloud want to protect Tifa and Marlene! Geeze, what movie were you guys watching?
Thanks to Tifa, Cloud started to move on. Then he got help from Aerith too.
She wasn't nagging, she did the right thing. To make him realize what he was doing.
Was Aerith the one that....? Yeah, TTLY true.
So, if Aerith hadn't 'made him' to protect Tifa and Marlene? Then he wouldn't care at all? I think Cloud did it all by himself, he care for his family deeply.
If Cloud was so happy with Tifa, why did he go to live in the Church in AC?
The happier he is now,
The more Cloud is tormented by painful “memories” of the past.
The more he realizes how happy he is living with Tifa and the children, the more the fear of losing that and regrets toward the past trouble Cloud…
However, when Cloud contracts Geostigma he disappears. Behind these actions lies feelings of guilt towards his past failure to protect people who were important to him..
-FF7 10th Anniversary Ultimania
I think that says it all..