Jairus
Author of FFVII: Lifestream & FFVII: Reflections
Member was warned for disregarding a clear warning to stop this discussion
I was just about to ask for that, Tres, as I'm getting tired of it. But I'd like to say just one thing, if I may, and then I'll leave it. Crazyrabbit, it's not for certain that Jessie's dead. Her glove on the dresser is a clear hint at the possibility that she's alive. It adds nothing to the scene if she isn't. Biggs was supposed to die according to the OG, but he didn't. What the whispers did in his case was undone with their defeat. So it's possible that the same happened with Jessie. Remember, the camera didn't show the other half of the room, what was on the other side of the dresser. You can get a glimpse of it during the pan over to Biggs, just a hint of something that might be another bed or a chair.
It's not clear enough to tell for sure, but it's possible that she might've been over there recuperating as well. And as the most fleshed-out and most popular member of the trio, it makes sense to keep her survival quiet for the time being to keep people talking and give them yet another reason to anticipate Part 2. The pan across from the glove to Biggs isn't long enough for any reaction other than thinking of Jessie, seeing Biggs alive, and wondering what that might mean for her. SE knew full well what putting it there would make people think. They knew people would take it as a hint that she's still alive, that her fate was changed - and as part of the theme of the remake is "defying fate", there's no reason to think her own couldn't be changed as well. As for the menu entry,
it also says in the Chapter 14 summary that "friends" have been lost. Plural. But the only named friends supposedly lost at the point were Biggs and Jessie. And as we know that Biggs is alive, that means that the summary was inaccurate or only meant to convey what Cloud and the others knew at the time. Thus, the menu entry about Jessie can be taken to be merely an observation from their point of view, because they believe they lost her. But it's possible that, like Biggs, she's alive. But since they didn't know that at that point, only knowing what they saw, the summary says what it does. Even though they still went back to find them, meaning they thought even after the pillar that there was a chance they were alive and could be saved. And as their later assumption that Biggs was dead was wrong, so the same can be true of Jessie.
That's all I wanted to say. I don't want to argue about this stuff anymore.
It's not clear enough to tell for sure, but it's possible that she might've been over there recuperating as well. And as the most fleshed-out and most popular member of the trio, it makes sense to keep her survival quiet for the time being to keep people talking and give them yet another reason to anticipate Part 2. The pan across from the glove to Biggs isn't long enough for any reaction other than thinking of Jessie, seeing Biggs alive, and wondering what that might mean for her. SE knew full well what putting it there would make people think. They knew people would take it as a hint that she's still alive, that her fate was changed - and as part of the theme of the remake is "defying fate", there's no reason to think her own couldn't be changed as well. As for the menu entry,
it also says in the Chapter 14 summary that "friends" have been lost. Plural. But the only named friends supposedly lost at the point were Biggs and Jessie. And as we know that Biggs is alive, that means that the summary was inaccurate or only meant to convey what Cloud and the others knew at the time. Thus, the menu entry about Jessie can be taken to be merely an observation from their point of view, because they believe they lost her. But it's possible that, like Biggs, she's alive. But since they didn't know that at that point, only knowing what they saw, the summary says what it does. Even though they still went back to find them, meaning they thought even after the pillar that there was a chance they were alive and could be saved. And as their later assumption that Biggs was dead was wrong, so the same can be true of Jessie.
That's all I wanted to say. I don't want to argue about this stuff anymore.