Finished it last night but decided not to post because I wanted to digest the ending a bit...and sleep
I had Anderson break into Udina's office and deliver that awesome super-man punch.
Really, really enjoyed the fight through the Citadel. It felt epic in scale as a final battle should. Made it to Saren and Fred Tatasciore did a great job giving his Bond Villain "joining us is the only true hope" type speech. I managed to talk him down only for Saren to then blow his own head off, which was a total shocker to me.
At this point I had Joker, after a good ten minutes of deliberating on the decision, rescue the Council in spite of their immense idiocy in handling the entire situation up to that point.
If Joker had died in doing that, I'd have been immeasurably pissed. I like Joker.
At any rate, I was feeling well chuffed with myself and thinking "Wayhey! Talked my way out of the final boss fight!"
Nope. Nope nope nope nope nope
Saren/Sovereign (Sareveign? Eh? No?) was very creepy and honestly it was very harrowing to see the extent of Saren's cybernetic modifications. Saren was a dick before Sovereign, but man was that a harsh deal. Particularly with how much he seemed to fight Sovereign and how he had his doubts, to see him ultimately fail and be subjected to that level of modification was very poignant.
The boss fight itself wasn't overly difficult, but he was a bitch to keep up with once he started really hopping about the place. I liked that Saren thanked Shephard before killing himself (this was earlier). There was something very poetic about a Turian who hates humans being able to regain control (albeit briefly) of his own destiny because of a human. It was very poetic, in my opinion.
Didn't believe for a second that Shephard had died because "hey, sequels!" Honestly though, I don't think I'd have believed it even if I'd been playing it back when the game first came out, there's too much groundwork and set up for the sequels to kill the main character off so readily. Incidentally, Shephard's smile when we discover he survived is the goofiest, most awkward lookin' thing xD
I had Anderson become the human Councillor, because whilst Udina is a very effective politician he's kind of a wankshaft and reminds me too much of Enda Kenny and Joan Burton to ever make him likeable. Sexy Keith David motivational speech at the end there, which alone was enough to make me happy with my choice
All in all, I quite enjoyed Mass Effect. The side missions have a "Go to this one planet you can land on in this cluster, collect the collectables then go here and shoot this thing then leave" formula that's far too repetitive to justify the sheer amount of them. I know they're optional, but I've been told some of them affect the story in the sequels so you end up feeling obliged to do as many as possible and it does start to wear after a while.
The plot was very interesting, and really picks up in the third act. From Virmire onwards it just shoots into Orbit, once Sovereign enters the equation everything just becomes much more engaging and interesting. My main criticism with the game is that the supporting characters don't do much of anything. Garrus has his sidequest, and that's it. Ashley and Kaidan have their choice on Virmire, and that's it. Wrex has his moment on Virmire too but it's small in relation to the overall events of the story. Liara's arc ends with Benezia unless you romance her, to be honest. Tali doesn't do anything of any real significance after you recruit her.
It all just seemed very "Go and talk to these people after this mission to get their thoughts on something they had no impact on or relation too."
Maybe I'm just looking at it the wrong way, mayhaps I'm too used to Final Fantasy-esque storytelling where every character has a big impact in some way on the story. Or mayhaps it's all just setting up for the sequels. It never irritated me too much, I just thought it was poor use of the characters when they all have great potential and interesting personalities.
Genuinely though I did enjoy Mass Effect. I'm going to take a bit of a break for a bit and then it's on to Mass Effect 2. I'm downloading it right now and sweet Jaysus, the file size is even more gargantuan