Username
Banned
No. No it is not.
Let us say Aerith lives. What sets her above the girl Cloud has had a crush on since the age of 8 or younger? What indicates Cloud WOULD HAVE gone after her?
Cloud was loosing/not interested in Tifa during FF7, this was after all the past he had had with her, he went on a one-off date with Aerith, serious or not, it shows he was not really showing interest in tifa.
Cloud showed more interest in Aerith throughout his time with her, regardless if Aerith saw Zack in Cloud, i believe cloud was begginning to bond with her more than just a friend, he hardly knew her yet went on a date and put her ahead of tifa as far as conversations/jokes/etc, If she had lived and this had carried on, it is sure that something COULD of emerged, and i base this on the fact that he showed more interest in Aerith over Tifa.