Octo
KULT OF KERMITU
- AKA
- Octo, Octorawk, Clarky Cat, Kissmammal2000
@ Quex: Except on Disc 1 he wasn't entirely himself, and his interactions with her aren't markedly different from his interactions with Tifa. I don't see how the events of disc 1 relate to Cloud and Tifa's relationship in AC. So how can we use that as a measure of how Cloud/Aerith would have gone?
@The DoC argument. Ok DoC wasn't about Cloud and Tifa, but I get that it would have been nice fan service to see something happen between them. A fucking hug or something. (yes yes we know the Japanesedon't tell stories properly are more subtle in their storytelling) Honestly I think it was deliberate, they're fully aware of the LTD and so they try not to alienate people. Thats just my opinion.
But something I can't put down to 'subtle storytelling' if we're expected to believe Cloud loved Aerith, why no big reunion in AC? Your girlfriend dies, and then you meet her again and just sort of stand there? Wouldn't you embrace her? Even if you 'felt guilty' surely you'd try and hug her and beg her forgiveness? That whole scene between Cloud and Aerith in AC doesn't make any sense if Cloud has 'undying love'.
@The DoC argument. Ok DoC wasn't about Cloud and Tifa, but I get that it would have been nice fan service to see something happen between them. A fucking hug or something. (yes yes we know the Japanese
But something I can't put down to 'subtle storytelling' if we're expected to believe Cloud loved Aerith, why no big reunion in AC? Your girlfriend dies, and then you meet her again and just sort of stand there? Wouldn't you embrace her? Even if you 'felt guilty' surely you'd try and hug her and beg her forgiveness? That whole scene between Cloud and Aerith in AC doesn't make any sense if Cloud has 'undying love'.